3 ms·
the Government having this kind of power doesn't represent the "land of the free" very well An interesting thought springs to mind. Being free, and the governm
by sliverstorm 14y ago
the Government having this kind of power doesn't represent the "land of the free" very well
An interesting thought springs to mind. Being free, and the government knowing what you are up to, are not inherently at odds. This is a good thing, as hiding things is only going to get more difficult as technology progresses. Rather than fighting to keep one's deeds (or misdeeds) secret, perhaps we should be fighting to make it such that it doesn't matter if the government knows?
- CodeMage 14y ago'Smith!' yelled a voice from the telescreen. '6079 Smith W.! Hands out of pockets in the cells!'
- sliverstorm 14y agoI guess you're right, that's really the only choice we have; the government we have today, or the government of 1984.
- CodeMage 14y agoI guess you're right, we should trust that the government of 1984 (or any other dystopia) would never come to pass if we relinquish our privacy.
- beagle3 14y agoThe government is made of people. So just replace "government" with "other random people" in your thought above, and see if it makes sense to you. To me, it IS "inherently at odds". edit: to expand on this - information easily leaks from government employees who have been authorized to access it. Especially when it is so easy to get, and is so broad, then a private investigator is likely to find a government employee who would copy the files about person-of-interest-X in return for $1000, for almost every X. For just one additional lookup a week, that employee can make an additional $50,000 tax free with negligible chance of getting caught (with today's nonexistent oversight) except if the resulting leak happens to become a news item. So, realistically also replace "government" with "any willing person with $2000 to spare" (the private investigator will also take a cut :) )
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoThis. To me, Silverstorm's comment seems to be along the line of thinking of "If you've got nothing to hide, then why do you care what they know about you?"
- sliverstorm 14y agoSort of backwards from that. The counter argument to "If you've got nothing to hide..." usually revolves around the fact that you're always breaking laws, just because we have such a tangled legal system. So if you fix the legal system, then there's no cause for worry. Yes, there's the privacy issue, but I'd bet that could be handled.
- aidenn0 14y agoNo, the counter-argument to "If you've got nothing to hide" is that there are lots of perfectly legal things that you don't want other people to know. Maybe you're gay and you don't want your parents to know. Maybe you don't want your abusive ex-husband to know where you live. The more people that know a secret, the harder it is to keep. Remember, the government doesn't know anything, people working for the government know things, and the more people that know a secret, the harder it is to keep.
- sliverstorm 14y agoRight, so that's the privacy part. It seems to me like that ought to be addressable- there's already plenty of people who become privy to private information for this or that reason, and it is very rare it becomes a problem. Unless the system is significantly improved, yes, it probably entails some increased risk to your personal secrets. But to immediately shut down any suggestions of increasing government application of tech on those grounds seems short-sighted and selfish. There are positive outcomes, too! I'm not saying "forget about privacy, it doesn't matter", but rather "shouldn't we try to work a compromise?". Find a balance, where any increase in risk to personal privacy is counterbalanced by a respectable improvement in the capabilities of government to operate effectively. If we are stoic and immovable on the issue, we just impair our own government when we limit them to 20th century technology.