4 ms·
Philip Greenspun - he also mentioned SQL and I think ML. The current generation of Lisp users is the last one. Python and Ruby have enough of Lisp's features t
by gaius 18y ago
Philip Greenspun - he also mentioned SQL and I think ML.
The current generation of Lisp users is the last one. Python and Ruby have enough of Lisp's features that switching to a "real" Lisp offers rapidly diminishing returns. Haskell and F#/OCaml and Erlang are alive and well and gaining new users and taking things in a different direction. The argument "but it's too difficult for commercial programmers" makes Lispers feel good, but it simply isn't true. Commercial programmers once wrote vastly complex systems in assembly language. And anyone who can use C++ in anger is certainly smart enough to learn any language.
If there's hope it lies in Clojure but again, it's not entirely clear that Clojure offers significant advantages to someone who is already getting stuff done in one of those others (and the average Java programmer doesn't understand why anyone would use anything other than Java).
- gibsonf1 18y ago"The current generation of Lisp users is the last one" Hmm, I guess time will tell on that. The future is much harder to predict than most people realize. I'm guessing, though, that more successful large Lisp projects will keep the language alive and cause the conversion of more programmers to lisp. Our little startup converted one Java programmer over, and I can only imagine the impact ITA is having with its Orbitz product. Also, the move to more "semantic" approaches may also spark more interest in Lisp. We'll see.
- Zak 18y agoHaving recently made use of Clojure to make a simple, multithreaded image processing program[0], I can say the advantages over Python and Ruby are significant. Here's what I got, essentially free by using Clojure: Processing a directory full of flies using as many threads as there are cores. No UI-hanging due to long-running callbacks. Automatic queuing of actions started from the UI Fast, statically typed primitive operations, but only when I ask for them Friction-free access to Java's rather sizable collection of libraries I didn't write any macros, so all of this would have been possible in a language with Clojure's features and a non-Lisp syntax. That said, I have no doubt that if I write a longer program involving Swing, there will be macros involved, and they will save a significant amount of pain. [0] http://github.com/zakwilson/imagesieve/tree/master http://github.com/zakwilson/imagesieve/tree/master