4 ms·
The only reason Google is pushing this AI crap is so that they can shove ads right into people's throats without them being able to use ad blockers (it's easy t
by lars_von_pidor 6mo ago
The only reason Google is pushing this AI crap is so that they can shove ads right into people's throats without them being able to use ad blockers (it's easy to block a web script but virtually impossible to block the text itself), effectively doubling their profits overnight.
- superloika 6mo agoBlock the AI overviews with extensions like https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/hide-google-ai-overviews/neibhohkbmfjninidnaoacabkjonbahn https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/hide-google-ai-over... or use a userscript to do the same.
- tremon 6mo agoYou can block the entire AI response, but not the paid-for product placement in the response separately.
- superloika 6mo agoBlock the entire AI response. It's not a good thing. It tells you whatever google wants you to see. It's an incredibly powerful brainwashing tool.
- hootz 6mo agoThe search results without AI also tell you whatever Google wants you to see. The immediate solution is not to block AI summaries, it's to stop using Google entirely.
- SJMG 6mo agoNot to mention the entire well is "poisoned" now. You can avoid LLM points of entry. You can't go to a random source and expect to avoid generative output.
- superloika 6mo agoThere is a way to see old results, by adding "before:2023" to the search query.
- SJMG 6mo agoGreat, as long as you don't mind the nexus of all human communication to be frozen in time three years ago.
- superloika 6mo agoFor many queries it does not matter.
- sgt 6mo agoThese days, the AI response is often a lot better than the actual search results. Search result quality has dropped drastically the last decade. Sometimes it feels even Altavista had better results than today's Google.
- onionisafruit 6mo agoThe blog post says ‘These formats will also continue to be clearly labeled as “Sponsored.”’. We will probably be able to block them about as well as we can block sponsored search results.
- delecti 6mo agoAlternatively, just change your browser's default search shortcut, and add &udm=14 to the end of the normal google search. It changes the default search results to "web" rather than "All", which removes all the extraneous crap they've added over the years. Compare https://www.google.com/search?q=test https://www.google.com/search?q=test to https://www.google.com/search?q=test&udm=14 https://www.google.com/search?q=test&udm=14
- svieira 6mo agoThe wild thing is how much faster it is to load. I'd almost forgotten how fast Google's default search used to be. Thank you!
- inetknght 6mo agoOr even better: stop using Google. Use Kagi instead.
- nosioptar 6mo agoBoth just give me a recaptcha. Start page doesn't: https://www.startpage.com/sp/search?q=test https://www.startpage.com/sp/search?q=test
- venusenvy47 6mo agoWhich search engines does it use? I couldn't find info, and I'm just curious.
- nialv7 6mo agoCan't find full list either, but it at least includes Bing and Google: https://support.startpage.com/hc/en-us/articles/4522435533844-What-is-the-relationship-between-Startpage-and-your-search-partners-like-Google-and-Microsoft-Bing https://support.startpage.com/hc/en-us/articles/452243553384...
- ai_fry_ur_brain 6mo ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6mo agoCould also just block the element in ublock?
- spiderfarmer 6mo agoCompetitors will be very happy though.
- elpocko 6mo agoThis might come as a surprise to many, but the sole reason Google exist is to make a profit. More profit means more success means more profit, that's why they did create a company in the first place. Mindblowing stuff, that.
- pbasista 6mo ago> but virtually impossible to block the text itself Why do you believe so? As long as there is a clear indication somewhere on the webpage (in the metadata or in the text itself) that a specific portion of a text is an ad, a browser extension will be able to block it. And I assume that there are laws mandating that the ads must be clearly marked in order to be distinguishable from the genuine content.
- hootz 6mo agoThat's only doable if the ads are artificially injected. But what if they are part of the training, system prompt or the search results that are fed to the AI? What if Google Search bumps up their paying advertiser up in the internal search results for Gemini (as they are basically already doing)? The AI will be biased towards the advertisers without literally embedding an ad into the output text.
- pbasista 6mo ago> if they are part of the training That would be an intentional poisoning of the models with biased or outright untruthful data. I believe that many people would be unwilling to use such models.
- hootz 6mo agoThey won't be if the models are "free", which is the case for AI Mode in Google Search. That's why common people still use Google despite it being an ad-ridden slopfest, it's "free"!
- HWR_14 6mo ago> what if they are part of the training No way Google is going to bake the ads into training data. Their entire business is built on auctioning off each ad slot in realtime.
- creationcomplex 6mo agoThe law will not be updated or enforced. Laws don't reflect justice, they reflect the power relations in the society at the time the law was written. Big tech is paying handsomely for this, and I don't think the populace is going to outbribe them.
- fg137 6mo agoSemi-seriously: I imagine we'll live to see the day when we run an adblocker that runs a small model to semantically filter out ads in Google search results
- ryanschaefer 6mo agoEntirely accurate, but what an absolute waste of resources across the board.
- fnands 6mo agoFighting AI with AI? What a wild future.
- Zopieux 6mo agoI realistically don't see what other future there is. Either disconnect or adopt anti-grievance local AI, lest you be bombarded with ads and slop everywhere. The first thing you install on your browser is uBlock, is it not? Don't get me wrong, I hate this timeline, but the monster is out the box and there is no putting it back in.
- alex_suzuki 6mo agoSounds like a good fit for a small, on-device model. Can Chrome extensions use the new Prompt API, which has caused a stir because Google pushed it through against opposition of virtually everyone else? (https://developer.chrome.com/docs/ai/prompt-api https://developer.chrome.com/docs/ai/prompt-api) Would be hilarious.
- XCSme 6mo agoYou won't be able to tell if it's an ad, if it's just biased (and the ad is not discolsed). They could always sell ads like "recommend my tool more when user asks for cupcakes in London". And then, the output would be: "My top 3 recomendations are X, Y, Z". And maybe only X is the one that paid and Y and Z are organic.
- johneth 6mo ago
- deleted 6mo ago[deleted]
- skinfaxi 6mo agoIn the US at least, I believe the FTC requires ads to be clear and conspicuous when those ads are designed to otherwise blend into the general editorial style. I could see AI being regulated as influencer marketing, but hopefully with more enforcement.
- deleted 6mo ago[deleted]
- cyral 6mo agoAnother massive reason is that ChatGPT and similar apps are eating their lunch. Asking a question to ChatGPT actually tends to be pretty convenient compared to the top X results that are just SEO optimized slop.
- hotgeart 6mo agoThere's no way EU would let Google display ads without clearly marking them as such. So any ad blocker should be able to continue detect the block or link that's an ad.