5 ms·

Have you spent any serious time with other cultures? Yes, we all have the same colored blood and excrement, and we have a lot of similarities. Yet at the same t

by prewett 5mo ago

Have you spent any serious time with other cultures? Yes, we all have the same colored blood and excrement, and we have a lot of similarities. Yet at the same time, we are very different. England's traditional dignity culture (the virtuous man can overlook slights) is very different than Africa's honor culture (honor is zero-sum, and you must fight to maintain it), for instance. Japanese values and American values are frequently opposite (Japan values group membership, America values individuality; Japan honors someone by setting them apart, America honors someone by engaging with them.) In an ideal world we could celebrate each other's differences. But trying to get rid of conflict by getting rid of national borders is naive. Why are the borders where they are? Generally because those are ethno-cultural boundaries. Nations that encompass multiple ethno-cultural groups tend to be somewhat unstable: for instance, Yugoslavia broke up violently, and Iraq has conflict between the Kurds and the rest. This is not a support of nationalism (although I encourage patriotism, which is different), but "countries are [nothing] more than a shared historical hallucination" is just incorrect.

piloto_ciego 5mo ago
I have spent a lot of time in other cultures, I’ve lived overseas as ann exchange student and speak 3 languages. Countries are bullshit and the belief that people are that intrinsically different is silly. Go back to 1940 with that noise.
- vuurmot 5mo ago
  he literally says people are intrinsically the same, but extrinsically different (due to culture) why are you misrepresenting what he says?
- blub 5mo ago
  In a student or IT worker bubble, countries are very similar. When one steps out, they’re going to get a rude awakening. Culture shock is a real phenomenon.
  - piloto_ciego 5mo ago
    I'd bet money I have more experience in this than you. Culture shock is very real (I've lived it), but culture's ain't countries and hell, I get culture shock when I go to the south here in America. It's just some old timey 1940s "we gotta keep these different cultures separated" nonsense. It's nationalism and racism (though it purports to be otherwise). Things don't have to be this way, we choose them to and I'm getting awful tired of people keeping making the same choices over and over again because they think an imaginary line is somehow sacrosanct. It's all made up. Even culture.
    - bigbadfeline 5mo ago
      > I get culture shock when I go to the south here in America. Or even from urban to rural areas. > It's just some old timey 1940s "we gotta keep these different cultures separated" nonsense. That's a huge mistake right there. Those who want to keep their culture should be free to do so, as long as they don't try to force theirs on others - that's a common and traditional American value which is now being attacked by both extremist segregationists and extremist pot-melters. > It's nationalism and racism (though it purports to be otherwise). You should learn what these words mean and stop purporting they mean something else. > It's all made up. Even culture. Bro, not only culture, the entire human civilization is made up. The issue is to make it good, not bad, but you seem to be all confused about it.
      - piloto_ciego 5mo ago
        No, it's racism, because 9/10 times when someone says, "well these cultural differences are so vast" they really mean "I don't like people from that culture" which becomes "I don't like people from that country or who look like that." Almost always. It's always the same thing. Fear of the outsiders and disdain for change. I'm not going to debate you on it, I'm just tired of hearing it.
    - blub 5mo ago
      And yet with all that experience you’ve still managed to come up with a conclusion which describes the exact opposite way humanity evolved and currently lives. Good luck with your revolution. :)
dijksterhuis 5mo ago
> England's traditional dignity culture (the virtuous man can overlook slights) i’m english and i have no idea what you’re on about there mate. are you talking about having basic tolerance for other people? that’s a pretty universal skill not exclusive to england. > but "countries are [nothing] more than a shared historical hallucination" is just incorrect. countries are mostly lines drawn on a map. cultures, which i think is what you’re trying to get at in your post generally, differ everywhere to varying degrees. dundee (where i currently am) has a different culture to glasgow, which has a different culture to edinburgh, which has a different culture to york, which has a different culture to liverpool, which has a different culture to manchester, which has a different culture to leeds leeds leeds, which has a different culture to oxford, which has a different culture to reading, which has … the lines are imaginary. (although yes i live on a massive island so there is a non-imaginary physical boundary where you have to get on a boat or a plane or a train to travel to here).
- piloto_ciego 5mo ago
  thank you for putting it this succinctly
- fakedang 5mo ago
  > are you talking about having basic tolerance for other people? that’s a pretty universal skill not exclusive to england. You'd be surprised how it's not the case in most of the world. Heck, India has a caste system that Indians have now exported to areas where they're in numbers like California. Arabs have a tribal system that makes them suspicious of anyone not from the in-group. Russian Muscovites treat all of their fellow non-Muscovite countrymen like shit.
  - bigbadfeline 5mo ago
    > You'd be surprised how it's not the case in most of the world. What you listed isn't "most of the world". And the exceptions do not make a rule.
    - fakedang 5mo ago
AnimalMuppet 5mo ago
> Nations that encompass multiple ethno-cultural groups tend to be somewhat unstable The US has been remarkably stable for a nation that encompasses multiple ethno-cultural groups. It may not continue to be so, but historically it has been a counterexample.
- aefaegaeg 5mo ago
  what do you think counterexample means? if i say most days it is sunny, is a rainy day a counterexample? please learn how words in sequence work.

by prewett 5mo ago

piloto_ciego 5mo ago

I have spent a lot of time in other cultures, I’ve lived overseas as ann exchange student and speak 3 languages. Countries are bullshit and the belief that people are that intrinsically different is silly. Go back to 1940 with that noise.

vuurmot 5mo ago
he literally says people are intrinsically the same, but extrinsically different (due to culture) why are you misrepresenting what he says?
blub 5mo ago
In a student or IT worker bubble, countries are very similar. When one steps out, they’re going to get a rude awakening. Culture shock is a real phenomenon.
- piloto_ciego 5mo ago
  I'd bet money I have more experience in this than you. Culture shock is very real (I've lived it), but culture's ain't countries and hell, I get culture shock when I go to the south here in America. It's just some old timey 1940s "we gotta keep these different cultures separated" nonsense. It's nationalism and racism (though it purports to be otherwise). Things don't have to be this way, we choose them to and I'm getting awful tired of people keeping making the same choices over and over again because they think an imaginary line is somehow sacrosanct. It's all made up. Even culture.
  - bigbadfeline 5mo ago
    > I get culture shock when I go to the south here in America. Or even from urban to rural areas. > It's just some old timey 1940s "we gotta keep these different cultures separated" nonsense. That's a huge mistake right there. Those who want to keep their culture should be free to do so, as long as they don't try to force theirs on others - that's a common and traditional American value which is now being attacked by both extremist segregationists and extremist pot-melters. > It's nationalism and racism (though it purports to be otherwise). You should learn what these words mean and stop purporting they mean something else. > It's all made up. Even culture. Bro, not only culture, the entire human civilization is made up. The issue is to make it good, not bad, but you seem to be all confused about it.
    - piloto_ciego 5mo ago
      No, it's racism, because 9/10 times when someone says, "well these cultural differences are so vast" they really mean "I don't like people from that culture" which becomes "I don't like people from that country or who look like that." Almost always. It's always the same thing. Fear of the outsiders and disdain for change. I'm not going to debate you on it, I'm just tired of hearing it.
  - blub 5mo ago
    And yet with all that experience you’ve still managed to come up with a conclusion which describes the exact opposite way humanity evolved and currently lives. Good luck with your revolution. :)

dijksterhuis 5mo ago

> England's traditional dignity culture (the virtuous man can overlook slights) i’m english and i have no idea what you’re on about there mate. are you talking about having basic tolerance for other people? that’s a pretty universal skill not exclusive to england. > but "countries are [nothing] more than a shared historical hallucination" is just incorrect. countries are mostly lines drawn on a map. cultures, which i think is what you’re trying to get at in your post generally, differ everywhere to varying degrees. dundee (where i currently am) has a different culture to glasgow, which has a different culture to edinburgh, which has a different culture to york, which has a different culture to liverpool, which has a different culture to manchester, which has a different culture to leeds leeds leeds, which has a different culture to oxford, which has a different culture to reading, which has … the lines are imaginary. (although yes i live on a massive island so there is a non-imaginary physical boundary where you have to get on a boat or a plane or a train to travel to here).

piloto_ciego 5mo ago
thank you for putting it this succinctly
fakedang 5mo ago
> are you talking about having basic tolerance for other people? that’s a pretty universal skill not exclusive to england. You'd be surprised how it's not the case in most of the world. Heck, India has a caste system that Indians have now exported to areas where they're in numbers like California. Arabs have a tribal system that makes them suspicious of anyone not from the in-group. Russian Muscovites treat all of their fellow non-Muscovite countrymen like shit.
- bigbadfeline 5mo ago
  > You'd be surprised how it's not the case in most of the world. What you listed isn't "most of the world". And the exceptions do not make a rule.
  - fakedang 5mo ago

AnimalMuppet 5mo ago

> Nations that encompass multiple ethno-cultural groups tend to be somewhat unstable The US has been remarkably stable for a nation that encompasses multiple ethno-cultural groups. It may not continue to be so, but historically it has been a counterexample.

aefaegaeg 5mo ago
what do you think counterexample means? if i say most days it is sunny, is a rainy day a counterexample? please learn how words in sequence work.