3 ms·

The think your last sentence hits the nail on the head: it's good enough for YOU. You've essentially made a novelty song, and I don't believe you're going to be

The think your last sentence hits the nail on the head: it's good enough for YOU. You've essentially made a novelty song, and I don't believe you're going to be listening to it for years. The problem is when people spend 20 minutes prompting up a song and then attempt to make a career out of slop, and in the process drown out all the new creative works that aren't just remixed slop.

Sohcahtoa82 5mo ago
> and I don't believe you're going to be listening to it for years. Well...it's a year and a half old and I still listen to it on a regular basis. > and in the process drown out all the new creative works that aren't just remixed slop. It might be shocking to you, but maybe people actually like "remixed slop".
- QuercusMax 5mo ago
  Lots of people eat McDonald's but that doesn't mean it's good for you and will support your nutritional goals, or even that it's good food which tastes good. If you want to listen to nothing but slop I can't stop you.
gizzlon 5mo ago
> You've essentially made a novelty song Disagree. Gp didn't make anything. I told a waiter in a restaurant what I wanted to eat, and I got it. But I did not make the food : )
- QuercusMax 5mo ago
  Maybe more like collaborated with a robo chef to make a plate of food based on a recipe you've adapted. At some point you have to be OK with accepting "I made this" as meaning "my vision was executed under my supervision".
  - pesus 5mo ago
    > At some point you have to be OK with accepting "I made this" as meaning "my vision was executed under my supervision". No one has to be ok with this.
    - QuercusMax 5mo ago
      Do you argue with a film director when they talk about having made a movie? Do you argue with a founder when they talk about having built a product?
  - gizzlon 5mo ago
    No, I don't have to be okay with that. It's like oneshotting an app with Lovable or cc and bragging about what "I made"
- Sohcahtoa82 5mo ago
  > Disagree. Gp didn't make anything. As the GP, I actually agree. I will never claim to have written the song, and I generally try to avoid claiming I "made" the song unless I include the "with Suno" caveat. I prefer to say that I "generated" the song. > I told a waiter in a restaurant what I wanted to eat, and I got it. But I did not make the food : ) Then can we also stop giving credit to CEOs for the products their company makes? Elon Musk doesn't make EVs or rocket ships.
  - gizzlon 5mo ago
    > Then can we also stop giving credit to CEOs for the products their company makes? Absolutely! CEOs does many and difficult things, but they don't build anything

Sohcahtoa82 5mo ago

> and I don't believe you're going to be listening to it for years. Well...it's a year and a half old and I still listen to it on a regular basis. > and in the process drown out all the new creative works that aren't just remixed slop. It might be shocking to you, but maybe people actually like "remixed slop".

QuercusMax 5mo ago
Lots of people eat McDonald's but that doesn't mean it's good for you and will support your nutritional goals, or even that it's good food which tastes good. If you want to listen to nothing but slop I can't stop you.

gizzlon 5mo ago

> You've essentially made a novelty song Disagree. Gp didn't make anything. I told a waiter in a restaurant what I wanted to eat, and I got it. But I did not make the food : )

QuercusMax 5mo ago
Maybe more like collaborated with a robo chef to make a plate of food based on a recipe you've adapted. At some point you have to be OK with accepting "I made this" as meaning "my vision was executed under my supervision".
- pesus 5mo ago
  > At some point you have to be OK with accepting "I made this" as meaning "my vision was executed under my supervision". No one has to be ok with this.
  - QuercusMax 5mo ago
    Do you argue with a film director when they talk about having made a movie? Do you argue with a founder when they talk about having built a product?
- gizzlon 5mo ago
  No, I don't have to be okay with that. It's like oneshotting an app with Lovable or cc and bragging about what "I made"
Sohcahtoa82 5mo ago
> Disagree. Gp didn't make anything. As the GP, I actually agree. I will never claim to have written the song, and I generally try to avoid claiming I "made" the song unless I include the "with Suno" caveat. I prefer to say that I "generated" the song. > I told a waiter in a restaurant what I wanted to eat, and I got it. But I did not make the food : ) Then can we also stop giving credit to CEOs for the products their company makes? Elon Musk doesn't make EVs or rocket ships.
- gizzlon 5mo ago
  > Then can we also stop giving credit to CEOs for the products their company makes? Absolutely! CEOs does many and difficult things, but they don't build anything