6 ms·
Before thinking about enhancing tranportation, we should ask ourselves IF we need to travel more. In the last five years I took 500 flights (all on economy clas
by simonebrunozzi 14y ago
Before thinking about enhancing tranportation, we should ask ourselves IF we need to travel more.
In the last five years I took 500 flights (all on economy class except for two), and I also took about 100 train rides.
For "short" trips (<600-700 km or 400-500 miles) train might be slightly slower, but there's essentially no dead time and it's cheaper (no rush to the airport, no stupid security checks at the airport, no weather affecting the trip, no big delays, no taxi trip from arriving airport to city center). As a consequence, we should "aggregate" airports and use them only for long range travel, and revert to rail or road for shorter trips. By doing this, we would maximize the frequency and availability of flights from these mega-airports.
Then, by simply providing more leg space, power, and possibly internet connection, we could make flights "suck less".
This is doable now. Any other technology would take decades to develop.
And again, most people don't need to travel NY to Hong Kong in 3 hours. Most people need to travel cheaply, and possibly in a green way.
- marquis 14y agoI rarely travel for business: that one's been sorted by the internet. But I can't go long periods of time without seeing friends and family who are all over the world, and as I'm the one with the freedom I'm the one that travels. As a bonus I get croissants in Paris one day and shrimp in Sydney the next. I don't want to give this up - I want to pay some kind of forward-travel-tax that makes this more sustainable. Speaking of Paris, the Concorde is taunting me sitting at Charles de Gaulle and Orly right now, lifted up as if it's waiting for stronger winds.
- Eyght 14y agoHow would you feel about traveling in a larger vehicle, think zeppelin, that took 20 hours longer to reach its destination, but in return it would be cheaper and more comfortable - more like traveling on a cruise ship?
- gutnor 14y agoI really wonder if a Zeppelin would be cheaper considering that it would require more personnel, accommodation and service for long period of time. Actually like cruise ships: they are not cheaper than flying. They are a lot more comfortable.
- stcredzero 14y ago> I really wonder if a Zeppelin would be cheaper considering that it would require more personnel, accommodation and service for long period of time. What if you made them really huge and mostly automated? Make the service be mostly self-service, like at an extended-stay hotel?
- marquis 14y agoI would adore it, given I was comfortable with its safety. Assuming it had high-speed internet it's a travelling hotel, and considering travelling itself is the worst part of travelling I'd welcome it to be pleasurable in itself.
- 001sky 14y agoI can't go long periods of time without seeing friends and family who are all over the world -- First world problems, people !
- marquis 14y agoAbsolutely! But I also think of it as a responsibility to live and travel and experience, given that I have the rare opportunity to do so without being born into wealth. In regards to the proposed tech: if this allows for cleaner, cheaper transportation down the road for everyone then the economic opportunities improve for the globe.
- bigiain 14y agoKeep in mind, as soon as someone notices enough people are choosing trains instead of air travel, "stupid security checks" will start showing up at train stations as well… My personal transport-of-choice is a motorcycle. I can get anywhere within ~400km of home in less time by bike than by plane. I reasonably regularly choose to ride Sydney<->Port Macquarie or Sydney<->Canberra for work, mostly because I enjoy the ride, only partly 'cause it takes me less time than cab-to-airport/checkin/fly/cab-at-other-end.
- snogglethorpe 14y ago> Keep in mind, as soon as someone notices enough people are choosing trains instead of air travel, "stupid security checks" will start showing up at train stations as well… Then those people will have to be stomped on, hard. People hate, but put up with, airline security checks because they (perhaps grudgingly) admit they serve at least some purpose, even if the actual details are often pretty questionable. But trains and airplanes are fundamentally different in this respect. There's no rational reason to have airline-style security checks for train travel, at all.
- hobbe80 14y agoLondon, July 7 2005. Now, I don't agree with any security checks on train stations (and think the security checks on airports are ridiculous) but I'm afraid that those who want to implement such things can at least dig up some argument (not commenting on the validity of those arguments)...
- snogglethorpe 14y ago> London, July 7 2005 What's that supposed to illustrate? That a bomb in a crowded place can be harmful? Hmm, ok, better get the TSA to cordon off all malls, clubs, popular restaurants... The thing about air travel is that there is a better argument for (some) security to prevent hijackings and bombs, both because planes are very fragile (there's a decent chance for a smallish bomb to result in the entire plane being lost and all passengers killed), and because they're usable as missiles against much larger targets (as illustrated by 9.11). Planes, in other words, have a somewhat unique ability to magnify the effect of a given terrorist attack. None of that is the case for rail transport. For the most part, a train is simply a very crowded place, in a society that's absolutely chock-full of very crowded places. Indeed, the long-distance/regional trains most likely to receive TSA "attention" are much less crowded than local trains and subways which will almost certainly never be allowed to fall under TSA control for practical reasons.