3 ms·
There's a fundamental problem here though in power beaming. A plane such as the 777 has engines which use about 170 megawatts of power. Beaming 170 megawatts co
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
There's a fundamental problem here though in power beaming. A plane such as the 777 has engines which use about 170 megawatts of power. Beaming 170 megawatts continuously to a moving target the size of a plane in a way that does not cause any amount of bleed-over around the plane and also somehow doesn't manage to destroy the plane is, suffice it to say, a bit of a technological challenge.
Even if we were talking about a blended wing plane covered in PV arrays and much lighter than a 777 (due to not needing fuel) and thus requiring less power we're still talking about delivering 10s to 100s of kilowatts per square meter of plane. That compares to 1 kilowatt/m^2 of direct sunlight. That's a hell of a lot of power, and I'm not sure there's a way for that amount of power to be safely and effectively delivered without a considerable risk of destroying or damaging the plane.
- stcredzero 14y ago> A plane such as the 777 has engines which use about 170 megawatts of power. Do you mean emergency thrust, takeoff thrust, or during cruise? These aren't going to be the same amounts. You're going to have to have some amount of batteries for emergency purposes, so these could be used to provide peak power. Beamed power will also have different properties which will lead to different economics and standard operating procedures. (With more gradual climbs.) > Even if we were talking about a blended wing plane covered in PV arrays and much lighter than a 777 (due to not needing fuel) and thus requiring less power we're still talking about delivering 10s to 100s of kilowatts per square meter of plane. That compares to 1 kilowatt/m^2 of direct sunlight. That's a hell of a lot of power 1000 watts per square meter doesn't seem such a big deal. Right now, I have a 300 watt parabolic space heater about 8-9" or 20 cm in diameter aimed at me from about 3/4ths of a yard. The intensity of this device is much higher than 1000w/m^2. I note that the rear of this device is made out of ordinary plastic and doesn't ever get too hot to touch. As a matter of perspective, imagine building a large structure out of aluminum with one handheld hair dryer attached to every square meter of the bottom side. (1400 watts.) That would indeed be a lot of power, but barring untimely rain or some kind of design or equipment failure, you wouldn't expect this to go up in flames. Heck, this thing is a toy, and I'll bet the intensity is a good fraction of 1000 watts/m^2.
- InclinedPlane 14y ago> Do you mean emergency thrust, takeoff thrust, or during cruise? Doesn't matter, that's a percentage difference, and doesn't affect the orders of magnitude here. > 1000 watts per square meter doesn't seem such a big deal. Maybe you misread what I wrote, 1 kilowatt/m^2 is the power of direct sunlight. The power per square meter to power a jumbojet realistically needs to be 10s to 100s of times higher than that. And those are dangerous levels of power. For example, the risk of eye damage from reflections would be a significant concern, but realistically at those power levels you could risk melting plastics and so forth.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Maybe you misread what I wrote, 1 kilowatt/m^2 is the power of direct sunlight. The power per square meter to power a jumbojet realistically needs to be 10s to 100s of times higher than that. Indeed I did. However, I was primarily thinking about the waste heat, which would only be about 1 or two kilowatt/m^2. > For example, the risk of eye damage from reflections would be a significant concern I doubt this would be a concern for microwaves. > but realistically at those power levels you could risk melting plastics and so forth. That's only if all the power went towards melting those plastics. If the transmission and conversion is efficient enough, then this isn't necessarily the case. Also, just don't use plastics. Shielding passengers inside a metal hull from 10 kilowatts/m^2 isn't that big a deal. Nor would dissipating 1.5 kilowatts/m^2 of waste heat.
- maccam94 14y agoThe total power output of a 747 at takeoff is 90MW (90,000,000W), while cruising it is 45MW. (According to answers.com). A kilowatt is 1000W (you seem to have been mixing up megawatts and kilowatts).
- InclinedPlane 14y ago10s of kilowatts, not 10 kilowatts. And that's for a huge, delta-shaped blended wing aircraft. If you take the takeoff power of a 777 and distribute it over the entire cross-sectional area of the plane you'll end up with several hundred kilowatts per square meter. Even rounding down to 100 megawatts and then assuming a 70m x 60m triangle (2100 m^2) you end up with about 50 kilowatts per square meter. Now consider that the power gathering equipment not only needs to be extremely efficient (as even 95% efficiency would dump enough heat into the plane's structure to cause it to melt fairly quickly) but also needs to be built extremely carefully as any imperfection that resulted in a drop in efficiency for any small part of the plane would result in catastrophe. And, of course, as mentioned there would be the problems of bleed-over and so forth. You want to be able to fly planes over populated areas, most likely.
- bwldrbst 14y agoMade me think of Terry Pratchett's Strata: "Kin's flyer circled the low offices and headed northward to the big complex on W- continent. It skirted the bulk of what had been Hendry's machine, its new pilot now laying down a pattern of offshore reefs. The manoeuvre gave them an impressive view of the big collector bowl atop the machine, its interior velvety black. 'Why?' said Jalo, peering. Kin twirled the wheel. 'Beamed power from orbiting collectors, slaved to the machine. If we flew over the bowl we wouldn't even leave any ash.' 'What would happen if the pilot made a mistake and the beam missed the bowl?' Kin considered this. 'I don't know,' she said. 'We'd certainly never find the pilot.'"