3 ms·
Electric jets combined with beamed power could be huge. Such craft would be unencumbered by fuel tankage, so there would be huge potential for savings. One plac
by stcredzero 14y ago
Electric jets combined with beamed power could be huge. Such craft would be unencumbered by fuel tankage, so there would be huge potential for savings. One place to start, strangely enough, would be with electric tankers. By lifting fuel to altitude, individual aircraft fuel needs would be greatly reduced to cover the same distance, meaning structural weight could be saved, resulting in even more efficiency. Networks of power beaming stations to power cross country flights would result in aircraft so light, that parachute landing systems for the whole craft might be feasible. (Some on board battery capacity would always be necessary for emergencies.)
- paulsutter 14y agoGood point. Going further, a big advantage of an electric plane is that it can fly at much higher altitudes since it doesn't burn atmospheric oxygen like normal jets. At high altitudes, it may be more efficient to beam the power from orbit then from the ground or flying tankers. EDIT: replaced "the biggest" with "a big", point well taken.
- stcredzero 14y ago> the biggest advantage of an electric plane is that it can fly at much higher altitudes since it doesn't burn atmospheric oxygen The biggest? Not sure about that. Eliminating most of the fuel tankage is pretty huge. > more efficient to beam the power from orbit than from the ground That would be vital for over water flights. This might even be a way to jump start orbital solar power satellites. > flying tankers. By "electric tankers" I meant using beamed electric power to haul jet fuel to altitude, as a first step. Airplanes purpose built for this use case would have range or efficiency advantages.
- flyinglizard 14y agoTrue, but I assume it will use a fan or prop design, which loses efficiency as air density decreases (like swimming in air vs. water). And you will still need to pressurize the cabin.
- TeMPOraL 14y ago> At high altitudes, it may be more efficient to beam the power from orbit then from the ground or flying tankers. In line with InclinedPlane's comment upthread, I do have a question: how do you prevent such power delivery systems from becoming orbital weapons platforms? It wouldn't be difficult to make such satellite transmit power to a building or road insatead of a plane.
- robbiep 14y agoYou could use frequencies that dont interfere with a lot of materials/biological tissues. But once we have the technology to beam huge qtys of power from orbit this will always be a risk: simply retune or develop a satellite just for weapons purposes. Perhaps another way of looking at it is how is it different from ICBMs etc? Most technologies can be weaponised, on 911 some enterprising bastards managed to do it with commercial transport.
- stcredzero 14y ago> how do you prevent such power delivery systems from becoming orbital weapons platforms? Rectennas proposed for power transmission are quite large. You can probably design these, such that diffraction limits make spot focusing the beams difficult. You probably can't prevent them from being used as weapons, but you can probably make them rotten weapons. In any case, you can secure these from most personnel by using crypto and formal methods. This stuff had better work, because if we have powersats, then we'll also have lots of very capable orbital rockets which will use the same security schemes, and those will be >much< more potent weapons.
- jvm 14y ago> a big advantage of an electric plane is that it can fly at much higher altitudes since it doesn't burn atmospheric oxygen like normal jets. My understanding is that air is still the medium they use for propulsion so I'm not sure how big this benefit will be (like how a jetski jet doesn't work out of water).
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThere's a fundamental problem here though in power beaming. A plane such as the 777 has engines which use about 170 megawatts of power. Beaming 170 megawatts continuously to a moving target the size of a plane in a way that does not cause any amount of bleed-over around the plane and also somehow doesn't manage to destroy the plane is, suffice it to say, a bit of a technological challenge. Even if we were talking about a blended wing plane covered in PV arrays and much lighter than a 777 (due to not needing fuel) and thus requiring less power we're still talking about delivering 10s to 100s of kilowatts per square meter of plane. That compares to 1 kilowatt/m^2 of direct sunlight. That's a hell of a lot of power, and I'm not sure there's a way for that amount of power to be safely and effectively delivered without a considerable risk of destroying or damaging the plane.
- stcredzero 14y ago> A plane such as the 777 has engines which use about 170 megawatts of power. Do you mean emergency thrust, takeoff thrust, or during cruise? These aren't going to be the same amounts. You're going to have to have some amount of batteries for emergency purposes, so these could be used to provide peak power. Beamed power will also have different properties which will lead to different economics and standard operating procedures. (With more gradual climbs.) > Even if we were talking about a blended wing plane covered in PV arrays and much lighter than a 777 (due to not needing fuel) and thus requiring less power we're still talking about delivering 10s to 100s of kilowatts per square meter of plane. That compares to 1 kilowatt/m^2 of direct sunlight. That's a hell of a lot of power 1000 watts per square meter doesn't seem such a big deal. Right now, I have a 300 watt parabolic space heater about 8-9" or 20 cm in diameter aimed at me from about 3/4ths of a yard. The intensity of this device is much higher than 1000w/m^2. I note that the rear of this device is made out of ordinary plastic and doesn't ever get too hot to touch. As a matter of perspective, imagine building a large structure out of aluminum with one handheld hair dryer attached to every square meter of the bottom side. (1400 watts.) That would indeed be a lot of power, but barring untimely rain or some kind of design or equipment failure, you wouldn't expect this to go up in flames. Heck, this thing is a toy, and I'll bet the intensity is a good fraction of 1000 watts/m^2.
- 14y ago