5 ms·
Oh man. You know how annoying Star Trek is to physicists? Or how Hackers was a riot because of how hilariously wrong it got ... well ... everything that matter
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Oh man.
You know how annoying Star Trek is to physicists? Or how Hackers was a riot because of how hilariously wrong it got ... well ... everything that matters?
Yeah. So. That's what this reads like to anyone who's studied the Common law.
I used to think expert systems might be useful for legal situations.
And then ... I studied law.
You know why law is complex? Because of problem domain -- everything humans do -- is complex. Right now a judge is being asked to give a ruling on a particular combination of facts that has never arisen before, ever, in the history of the human race.
It probably belongs to a fuzzy set of existing situations canvassed by cases raised in the past thousand years.
But it might not.
There is always novelty in the law.
- rmc 14y agoOr how Hackers was a riot because of how hilariously wrong it got ... well ... everything that matters? Compared to some TV shows, Hackers is accurate. I give you 2 people typing on the same keyboard to try to fight off a hacker. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8qgehH3kEQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8qgehH3kEQ
- jacques_chester 14y agoThough there was a lot of "who can type fastest" when, at the climax of Hackers, they... (big breath) HACKED THE GIBSON
- hooande 14y ago> It probably belongs to a fuzzy set of existing situations canvassed by cases raised in the past thousand years. Computers own those. Don't write off expert systems because you can't see how you would implement it right now. It would take an unprecedented effort (like apollo mission sized), but we have the means to build legal expert systems available to us today. It's not being done because it wouldn't be immediately profitable, in part due to the bias you expressed. For every judge with a truly unique case on their docket right now, there are a thousand other judges with wholly predictable and commonplace cases. The law is incredibly complex, but 80% cases don't require any one-of-a-kind judgement. Humans are actually highly predicable in large numbers (just ask Nate Silver). The idea of using the technology behind IBM's Watson is Hackers level laughable (though I think that was chosen because it's well known). The right tools for this job do exist, the billion dollar problem is getting the right input.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI want to believe it can be done in a single, gigantic project. It won't happen that way. What will happen is that special purpose systems will nibble at the core of relatively well-settled areas of law. Trusts. Contracts. The bread-and-butter stuff. Most such disputes never reach the court, because the particular law is so well settled. Party A goes to their lawyer, who can confidently say whether or not they would win in the courts against B. That's the beauty of stare decisis, in the long run it drives down the amount of court time needed for civil disputes. But: 1. Some people still want their day in court. As a lawyer you are obliged to give your client your utmost efforts, even if they are idiots without a legal leg to stand on. I imagine a lot of them will demand human judgement be used. 2. Hard cases still come up. All the time. More frequently than you imagine. To the point where the Supreme and High Courts of the world turn away far more tricky corner cases than they address.
- shasta 14y agoWhether and how it will happen is a different question from whether it could and should happen. Most legal rules could be vastly improved by reducing them to principles that are combined in a framework of cost/benefit analysis. One of the main reasons that hard cases frequently come up is because the law is, in software terms, extremely buggy. Those "corner cases" are mainly a problem because the law attempts to solve so many problems by partitioning into ad hoc cases. The law (meaning the courts and the legislative process, as well) is so completely broken that it's hard to imagine a fix actually happening in the US.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> Most legal rules could be vastly improved by reducing them to principles that are combined in a framework of cost/benefit analysis. Lawyers already do this. The world is still too complex to reduce to a single, central set of uniform principles. Instead you have lots of little pockets of temporary uniformity. What happens is: 1. Lots of disconnected cases. 2. One day, a lawyer or judge notices a pattern. 3. A new principle is expounded in a case. 4. Other judges might pick it up and it becomes the common law. Or they don't, and it doesn't. 5. If it's widely accepted, the new principle begins to accrete exceptions, odd outliers, dusty corners and so on. 6. One day, a lawyer or judge notices a pattern ... You need to stop thinking of law as a product and think of it as a process. It is not a static, manufactured good. It is a procedure for discovery.
- zerostar07 14y agoI don't think it's complex but maybe it's unpredictable (or not easily predictable). It's all a matter of trust though, these expert systems are going to have to prove themselves to be superior to human judges (such as in cases of mistrials) before people can trust them. They don't have to have encountered all possible combinations of facts either, machine learning is good at generalizing. In fact, civil law systems have already codified everything, and the system works. Also having machine-judges doesn't mean we can't add new laws when needed. This system would lead to a whole class of "artists" trying to game the system by manipulating the data before feeding it to the machine-judge (a combination of what's already happening in courts + SEO tactics).
- jacques_chester 14y ago> civil law systems have already codified everything, No, they have not, because "everything" is constantly changing.
- zerostar07 14y agoWhat does that imply? We can always alter the rules of an expert system or add new rules. [Edit:] i am referring to civil law legal systems, not civil law in common law systems. Precedents count very little in the former.
- jacques_chester 14y agoAnnnnnnnd who will come up with these rules? Edit for your edit: civil law still has to be constantly amended. The main difference is that civil systems unifies the judicial and legislative functions under the premise that it can all somehow be decided in advance for every case.
- zerostar07 14y agoWell, to answer your question, humans will come up with these laws (through legislative action or sth, IANAL). An expert system wouldn't need to record its previous decisions since it can come up with them when needed. In this sense it can be more adaptible than common law courts.