3 ms·
A random quick note. The first public discussion of the Hyperloop was in http://pandodaily.com/2012/07/12/pandomonthly-presents-a-fireside-chat-with-elon-musk/
by btilly 14y ago
A random quick note.
The first public discussion of the Hyperloop was in http://pandodaily.com/2012/07/12/pandomonthly-presents-a-fireside-chat-with-elon-musk/ http://pandodaily.com/2012/07/12/pandomonthly-presents-a-fir... starting about 43 minutes in. A revealing bit of the conversation a minute later went like this:
Elon: I have a name for it, the Hyperloop.
Interviewer: Is that like a Jetson's tunnel?
Elon: Something like that, yeah.
Interviewer: You just get in, it whisks you?
Elon: Um, yeah. Yeah.
He later on said, You're guessing in the right direction.
This suggests to me VERY STRONGLY that his technology proposal MUST be a tube of some sort. He also said that it could store enough energy to run 24x7 without using batteries. That implies that he's got a lot of material going very, very fast.
Interestingly this is the time that he made his 30 minutes downtown to downtown comment, and his solar panel comment, but said nothing indicating no right of way issues. Later on he said that he came up with a way to make it much cheaper, and to get rid of right of way issues, but hasn't been repeating the other comments that I know of.
This suggests to me that in July he might not have had right of way figured out, and suggests to me that getting rid of the right of way issues by putting it in the ocean might not be a bad guess as to the insight he had over the summer that dramatically reduces costs.
My proposal may not be on the right track. But I think it is safe to conclude from what Elon has said that it is a tube. It has a lot of mass moving. And I don't think it infeasible that he would be thinking about putting this in the ocean to solve the rights issue.
- jlgreco 14y agoTubes in the ocean, whether sunken or floating, seems like a nightmare when you consider ships. Ships snagging fiber cables with their anchors is one thing, but something with people in it? Great care would probably have to be taken with this sort of thing.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Datonomics 14y agoYour idea seems reasonable. It made me think of when the 4 minute mile was broken. Once it was, people began doing it on a regular basis. Elon promotes this idea and people believe it to be possible, then suddenly it becomes possible. It makes me wonder how many breakthrough ideas are out there, that are undiscovered. Clearly Elon is a genius. How much more of a genius would he be if he knew this principle of human nature, and used it to find the solution to a problem that he hasn't figured out. He would use the collective intelligence of the world to solve the problem. He probably has a reasonable idea that this can be done, but what if he were to use this power he has to essentially scale his genius by harnessing the imaginations of people like you around the world?