4 ms·
Refutations of philosophical ideas happen all the time. Perhaps Bostrom missed something subtle, that negates his argument. Or perhaps the logical form of the
by bediger4000 14y ago
Refutations of philosophical ideas happen all the time. Perhaps Bostrom missed something subtle, that negates his argument. Or perhaps the logical form of the argument is incorrect, or perhaps there's no way to falsify it, rendering it on the level of most superstition.
Besides all that, you can prove negatives at least some of the time: logicians and mathematicians work on decision problems all the time. Sometimes they come up negative: http://mathworld.wolfram.com/DecisionProblem.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/DecisionProblem.html
- lutusp 14y ago> Refutations of philosophical ideas happen all the time. On the contrary, this never happens -- not among philosophers, anyway. Philosophy isn't about reality-testing, that's reserved to science, and it's why science is a branch of knowledge separate from philosophy. The term "natural philosopher" was once used to describe what we now call a scientist, but the problems with an association with philosophy became obvious to all and the name was changed. > Besides all that, you can prove negatives at least some of the time ... No, false. You're thinking of a positive proof that a proposition is false. Let's say I claim there is a largest prime number. If I take this position, Euclid's theorem of the infinity of primes positively disproves my claim -- positively proves it to be false: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euclids_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euclids_theorem > Sometimes they come up negative ... First, your reference (http://mathworld.wolfram.com/DecisionProblem.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/DecisionProblem.html) flatly contradicts your claim -- it says that there is no algorithm that can decide whether a given theorem does or does not have a proof, and this fact has been positively proven. Second, you're confusing a positive proof of the falsehood of a claim, with proof of a negative. To understand the difference, read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russells_teapot http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russells_teapot A quote: "Russell's teapot, sometimes called the celestial teapot or cosmic teapot, is an analogy first coined by the philosopher Bertrand Russell (1872–1970) to illustrate that the philosophic burden of proof lies upon a person making scientifically unfalsifiable claims rather than shifting the burden of proof to others, specifically in the case of religion. Russell wrote that if he claims that a teapot orbits the Sun somewhere in space between the Earth and Mars, it is nonsensical for him to expect others to believe him on the grounds that they cannot prove him wrong. Russell's teapot is still referred to in discussions concerning the existence of God."
- bediger4000 14y agoYou're thinking of a positive proof that a proposition is false. Yes, of course! Thank you for reminding me of that! I abase myself before your superior semantics. I'm not worthy, and I shall soon delete this now defiled account name.