6 ms·
Speculating about the Hyperloop
- lazyjones 14y agoWhy does everyone expect this "tube" to be filled with air? A liquid is more interesting and it also stores a lot more energy when it moves ...
- btilly 14y agoIf you can find a liquid with low enough friction to be feasible, I'm all ears. The only ones that I'm aware of are thin gases or helium-II. The latter is rather impractical to use for a great many reasons. But I'd be interested if anyone has other suggestions.
- lazyjones 14y agoAre you talking about friction between carriage and liquid or walls and (moving) liquid? The liquid will move at the desired travel velocity, so I believe the latter will be important.
- dpark 14y agoBecause the resistance of any economically feasible liquid is probably higher than that of air. The energy needed to overcome that friction doesn't drop just because the water carries more momentum.
- brilee 14y agoAir is a fluid, too. It's also got a lower viscosity than say, water, so it will create less resistance. Saying it stores a lot more energy when it moves is like saying that we should make our train cars heavier so that we can recover more energy by regenerative braking.
- btilly 14y agoOne point that just occurred to me. If you put this tube inside of another tube, and then pumped most of the air out of the second tube, the vacuum in the inner tube would improve and the whole system would become more efficient. I believe it is linear. For instance if the outer tube reduced atmosphere to 1/3 air pressure, then the energy losses due to pushing air around drop to 1/3 of what they would have been. However local compromise of the outer tube does not significantly compromise the vacuum in the inner tube, which avoids major problems that normally exist in maintaining an evacuated tube. A lot depends on the flaps that let air out but (mostly) not in. When a plunger goes by, you need it to be open for a very brief period to let air out. I'd be curious whether it is better to have a lot of little flaps that can open/shut fast because they are little, or to connect the flaps to a computer system that can open the flap just in time and close it again promptly. The smart system in theory can be more efficient, but the straight mechanical system would be massively easier to design and build. I'm also curious what breakthrough Elon had over the summer that dramatically reduced costs. The things that I'm thinking of involve the design of the plunger. Possibly a spike creating chaotic flow at the right place. Or a plunger design that more efficiently pushes air out. Or some clever design of the behind of the plunger so that the air that is left is not following at high speed. Or even the idea I put above about having 2 shells, with partial evacuation in sections of the outer one.
- jacquesm 14y agoHey Ben, That's pretty clever, so you're using the 'plungers' (carriages?) as the means of partial evacuation and propulsion at the same time... No true vacuum, just enough to reduce drag to something manageable. One thing that still bothers me about the whole concept (besides it being a complete guess as to what Musk has in mind of course) is the stopping properties, emergency shutdown. If you would have to suddenly decelerate in the system I proposed you'd be building up pressure in front of the car which would slow the car down until some maximum pressure i s reached at which point you can breach the walls to relieve it and keep it at that maximum. This provides a nice cushioning effect for emergencies using very little besides the components already in the system. If you were to even partially evacuate the tube then that would no longer work and you'd need active braking at all times. Accelerating into the at a speed slightly higher than the loop speed backing into a slug that has just passed might be a way to mitigate this to some extent, then you still have to worry about stopping the train but the braking energy could be dispersed over a much longer distance due to closer packing. I missed the end of the interview linked by someone else in the other thread where Elon Musk says it has no 'right of way' issues so I think the whole thing is moot but it was a fun exercise anyway.
- abecedarius 14y agoYou could brake (at some rate) by keeping the flaps ahead of you shut. The interesting issue is to make damn sure all braking is in sync enough.
- btilly 14y agoI've seen his right of way comment. But if you've got something ground based, that is 1200 km long, how can you avoid right of way issues? My guess is that he means to build it in the ocean. There aren't a lot of people living there. If so, it could look like anything you want and there would be no "right of way issues". (Update, it just hit me! If you build this in the ocean, with neutral buoyancy under water, then you don't have to worry about earthquakes or weather! Built on land and able to handle earthquakes is a lot harder.) But the stopping properties deserve more thought. California has regular earthquakes. What happens if you've got large hunks of metal going 1200 km/h over a section of loop that just was hit by one, what happens? My suspicion is that you build regular emergency exit tubes. (Many of which might also be good for regular tube service.) The cars are let out at the nearest one. The machinery is at risk, the people are mostly OK. You then try to stop the plungers with regenerative braking, dumping air in, etc. Or you can build a fast emergency stop, such as having exit holes that you can drop plungers into at high speed, which carries them far enough away from the tube that they won't destroy it when they impact. This has to be carefully worked through. But the first and most critical piece is the ability to quickly and reliably dump passengers from most of the system. And that shouldn't be that hard to do.
- axlerunner 14y agoIt will be wonderful until the first time a plunger smashes a car with a family to smithereens because the railgun timing was slightly off due to a voltage irregularity.
- gagege 14y agoWhile that would be horrible, it's still probably a lot less likely than that same family being involved in a fatal car accident.
- btilly 14y agoThere are clearly a lot of details that you have to get perfectly right. However getting them right is an engineering challenge, not a physics challenge, and engineering for safety is something we as a society tend to do pretty well. (As opposed to engineering for cost containment, which we as a society are often horrible at.) If I saw Elon Musk standing up there with cost projections, I'd be optimistic that they were in the right ballpark. If I saw virtually anyone else there, for a project of this type, I'd be assuming that they missed order of magnitude cost issues.
- flatline 14y agoOur current forms of public transportation are certainly not without risk. A runaway DC metro train killed 9 people a few years back. Maintenance workers are regularly killed on the tracks. Extrapolating from a sample of admittedly just one system, I doubt that this would be any less safe than the high speed rail they are proposing.
- archenemy 14y agoAny hypothesis that does not include electric drivetrains (ala Tesla) powered by solar (ala Solarcity) is going to be wrong. Also, the 'loop' part strongly implies that it will store excess energy. I think the 'immune to weather + no need for right-of-way' issue is the most intriguing here.
- dpark 14y ago"No need for right of way" is also enough to know that none of these tube proposals are correct. You can't build a tube from SF to LA without running into right of way concerns.
- socialist_coder 14y agoYeah. That is my assumption too. But all these proposals just seem to gloss over it. edit: Jacques admitted it was an oversight. Still, it's interesting reading these ideas even if they might not be what Elon is thinking.
- jacquesm 14y agoOne of the central supports against patents is that engineers given a problem will all come up with roughly the same solution. So given that Elon has dropped a number of hints the question then becomes: can a bunch of engineers come up with his proposed solution before he reveals what it is. That's a very interesting puzzle to me and I think this may be a way in which the patent office could do their reviews: ask a community of smart cookies to come up with what is in the (secret to that point) patent application, the one that gets it right gets a part of the filing fee and the patent is denied, if nobody can crack it in some set time (say 4 weeks) then the patent is granted.
- btilly 14y agoThere are not right of way issues if your tube is floating under water in the ocean. This also protects you from earthquake risks. He has said that his system is like a “ground based Concorde”. His specs give you a speed of over 1200 km/h. If you're going 1200 km/h on the ground and aren't in a tube, you've got a problem.
- coanda 14y agoYou might want to read this: http://www.daniel-irimia.com/2012/04/19/daryl-oster-vs-henri-coanda-ett-vs-aerotub-express/ http://www.daniel-irimia.com/2012/04/19/daryl-oster-vs-henri.... It's been done as a research project in Romania. Not sure if it can be patented...
- lnanek2 14y agoTransporting mining material, freight, etc. seems like an excellent proving ground. Much less chance of a disaster killing someone and killing the project. Often there's a large amount that has to go from one place to another place, not people who have many different places to go. I guess the only problem is that freight often doesn't have to move fast. If it takes your mining output an extra 8 hours to get to processing it doesn't matter. If it takes a person an extra 8 hours, they'll pay less or use other forms of transport, or require stopping stations...
- stcredzero 14y ago> People go into vehicles that I'll call cars, even though they aren't really cars. These cars can be fired by a railgun to match speeds with the tube Most railguns I've read about produce extreme g-loads. Most people would come out as super-gross wonder-jelly if fired out of one. I think what you want is some kind of electromagnetic accelerator, but not necessarily a railgun in particular. > On its own that space would heat up due to the friction on the gas, but you can put a heat sink (eg a block of ice) in the car and keep it comfortable inside. The cabin of a vehicle is quite small, and the ride time is quite short, so a large block of ice probably would be feasible. But you are talking about having a car leave every second, so for each loop you would have to have a plant capable of freezing something like 2 gallons of water per second, as well as a means of refilling the ice container in each car. That's going to add quite a bit to the expense and energy use of the system you describe. Refrigeration systems become quite a bit more efficient as they become larger, so probably this is manageable. Depending on how quickly you can turn around each car, each loop might require quite a few additional cars. (But still a fraction of the total number)
- reubensutton 14y agoI feel quite certain that Elon Musk will be remembered as our generation's greatest entrepreneur. Even if this idea doesn't succeed, the scale of his ambition is breathtaking.
- dpark 14y agoI hate to be overly negative, but this is just a bunch of extra complexity layered on top of an unworkable idea. The plungers aren't relevant. If you could run this with self-propelled plungers that push cars, you could run this with self-propelled cars. The "flaps" are just trying to play with semantics. Either they work and this is just an overly-complex evacuated tube or they don't work and this is no different than Mattheij's idea. If you land in the middle where they "kind of" work, then you likely get the drawbacks of an evacuated tube (not enough oxygen to keep a human alive) with most of the drawbacks of Mattheij's idea (too much friction to be feasible). Air becomes too thin to support human life before air resistance becomes negligible. This proposal also has the same right of way issues that any tunnel system would have, issues that Musk specifically said Hyperloop would avoid.
- btilly 14y agoI'd appreciate it if you put the same thought into the proposal that you did into throwing out criticisms that it already addresses. If you run this with cars only, the mass of cars that you'd need to accelerate/decelerate is much higher. Also the heat issues that the cars need to deal with is also much higher. Separating plungers and cars means you accelerate/decelerate much less mass, and have far fewer heat issues to deal with. The plungers themselves will get too hot for humans, but that's OK because humans are insulated from them. (And I already said how to deal with the heat in the cars.) If the flaps work as proposed, the air pressure directly in front of the plunger will significantly exceed the air pressure in the rest of the tunnel. The cars sit in a bubble of air maintained by that shockwave. I have not tried to do fluid dynamics calculations to estimate friction, but it is going to be many times less than with Jacques' idea. I can believe it could be low enough to make this system work. I suspect that Elon plans to avoid right of way issues by building it in the ocean. If he doesn't do that, then it is very difficult to see how he can do anything like a “ground based Concorde” (his words) and still avoid right of way issues.
- dpark 14y ago> I'd appreciate it if you put the same thought into the proposal that you did into throwing out criticisms that it already addresses. I'm pretty sure you did not address my criticisms in your proposal. > If you run this with cars only, the mass of cars that you'd need to accelerate/decelerate is much higher. If you run this with cars only, you probably wouldn't make them weigh 70 tons, and then your acceleration costs drop dramatically. > Also the heat issues that the cars need to deal with is also much higher. Separating plungers and cars means you accelerate/decelerate much less mass, and have far fewer heat issues to deal with. The plungers themselves will get too hot for humans, but that's OK because humans are insulated from them. You only have heat issues because you're trying to push a big column of air for no reason. What is the value of this column of air? The air itself is just creating friction. The passengers can't breath it, because it's too hot for them to survive, and it's not enough to sustain life in the event of a failure, because most of this hypothetical tunnel is a vacuum. > And I already said how to deal with the heat in the cars. You proposed adding enough cold thermal mass to offset the heat they'd absorb (literally a block of ice). You're just adding a bunch of extra mass that you have to accelerate, and a bunch of mass you need to re-cool after every trip. > If the flaps work as proposed, the air pressure directly in front of the plunger will significantly exceed the air pressure in the rest of the tunnel. The cars sit in a bubble of air maintained by that shockwave. I have not tried to do fluid dynamics calculations to estimate friction, but it is going to be many times less than with Jacques' idea. I can believe it could be low enough to make this system work. If the flaps work as proposed, then you have all the problems of an evacuated tunnel and most of the problems of Mattheij's idea, as I said. You have an inhospitable environment, need to deal with the pressure differential (throughout most of the tunnel at least), tons of energy lost to friction (or else it wouldn't be too hot for humans), etc. Even if your idea was technically possible, it seems to have no advantages over an evacuated tunnel except that you can say that it's not an evacuated tunnel. > I suspect that Elon plans to avoid right of way issues by building it in the ocean. If he doesn't do that, then it is very difficult to see how he can do anything like a “ground based Concorde” (his words) and still avoid right of way issues. If you build far enough underwater to avoid right of way issues (aka, no boats can get past), you're looking at worse engineering issues than an evacuated tunnel anyway. At just 10m below the surface, you're already at 2 atmospheres of pressure. I'm also not sure that "underwater" counts as "ground based".
- Lerc 14y agoWhat are the advantages of using air instead of liquid? Is it just the breathablity aspect? I posted a few comments in the past on my guess. A liquid filled loop with a (super)hydrophobic inner surface. Energy stored as kinetic, solar accelerated. I have been looking, and haven't been able to find much info on reduced energy loss by using hydrophobic surfaces. It's a new enough tech that all the good info is behind academic paywalls.
- jlgreco 14y agoWould pressure differences throughout the tube caused by differences in altitude be something to worry about? I'm not sure how, if at all, that would effect the hydrodynamics. Also, I would be concerned that with that much fluid moving through it that fast, a possible failure mode could be "temporarily turns into a horizontal launch loop". (which would be awesome ;)
- Lerc 14y ago* Failure would look Awesome Always a winning bullet point.
- btilly 14y agoA random quick note. The first public discussion of the Hyperloop was in http://pandodaily.com/2012/07/12/pandomonthly-presents-a-fireside-chat-with-elon-musk/ http://pandodaily.com/2012/07/12/pandomonthly-presents-a-fir... starting about 43 minutes in. A revealing bit of the conversation a minute later went like this: Elon: I have a name for it, the Hyperloop. Interviewer: Is that like a Jetson's tunnel? Elon: Something like that, yeah. Interviewer: You just get in, it whisks you? Elon: Um, yeah. Yeah. He later on said, You're guessing in the right direction. This suggests to me VERY STRONGLY that his technology proposal MUST be a tube of some sort. He also said that it could store enough energy to run 24x7 without using batteries. That implies that he's got a lot of material going very, very fast. Interestingly this is the time that he made his 30 minutes downtown to downtown comment, and his solar panel comment, but said nothing indicating no right of way issues. Later on he said that he came up with a way to make it much cheaper, and to get rid of right of way issues, but hasn't been repeating the other comments that I know of. This suggests to me that in July he might not have had right of way figured out, and suggests to me that getting rid of the right of way issues by putting it in the ocean might not be a bad guess as to the insight he had over the summer that dramatically reduces costs. My proposal may not be on the right track. But I think it is safe to conclude from what Elon has said that it is a tube. It has a lot of mass moving. And I don't think it infeasible that he would be thinking about putting this in the ocean to solve the rights issue.
- jlgreco 14y agoTubes in the ocean, whether sunken or floating, seems like a nightmare when you consider ships. Ships snagging fiber cables with their anchors is one thing, but something with people in it? Great care would probably have to be taken with this sort of thing.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Datonomics 14y agoYour idea seems reasonable. It made me think of when the 4 minute mile was broken. Once it was, people began doing it on a regular basis. Elon promotes this idea and people believe it to be possible, then suddenly it becomes possible. It makes me wonder how many breakthrough ideas are out there, that are undiscovered. Clearly Elon is a genius. How much more of a genius would he be if he knew this principle of human nature, and used it to find the solution to a problem that he hasn't figured out. He would use the collective intelligence of the world to solve the problem. He probably has a reasonable idea that this can be done, but what if he were to use this power he has to essentially scale his genius by harnessing the imaginations of people like you around the world?
- TeMPOraL 14y agoHow about this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DfDOlUXEBo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DfDOlUXEBo It's chinese concept of a train that doesn't stop - you have the main body in constant motion (going around in a loop), and the passenger cars just attach to it and detach from it via magnetic forces. No need to stop the big train, you can catch on at any time, and this likely could work with - properly outfitted - cars.
- jhuckestein 14y agoI'm greatly enjoying this entire debate, but I'd just like to point out one thing: Elon said he doesn't know for sure how to do it yet or if it's even feasible (although he thinks it is). This means a) It's possible that not all of the statements he ever made about the Hyperloop will be true for the final design (if any). I'd be especially cautious about the comment about right of way issues. This might as well just mean that he found an unused railroad track or something. And b) Nobody knows if it can be done. Keep that in mind when debating the ideas. As far as I'm concerned, all ideas are constructive at this point. I'm not a physicist and it's very likely that this solution is completely impossible, but let me ask anyway. If you just had a 1200 mile long train and you somehow got the mass going in a circle at 1200 mp/h, how much energy would you need to keep that momentum going? Could you cover that with solar panels covering the 1200 miles of track?
- btilly 14y agoKeeping mass in orbit about a point requires absolutely no energy. That is because energy is force times distance (with times being a dot product), and the force you apply is always at right angles to the motion. It is a good thing that this is true, else the Earth could not manage to go around the Sun indefinitely! Therefore the energy to keep a system like this going is entirely what is needed to replace various incidental losses like friction. With maglev technology there some electromagnetic drag, but the bulk of losses are air friction. There is no way to keep a train like you describe going against air friction at 1200 mph. If you eliminated air friction, it would be very doable.
- ethanjlowry 14y agoWhat if the entire loop was in motion? Picture a maglev train 1200km long. There is no "front" to the train, it's a loop, so air is not being compressed as it whizzes along at 1200kmph. Most of the space inside the train could be void, which could be filled with passenger cars as needed. Would that eliminate enough of the air resistance to be feasible? Is a 1200km long contiguous structure feasible?
- 14y ago