3 ms·
I think that you ALMOST have it. You've even explained the following tantalizing quote from July: I think we could actually make it self-powering if you put s
by btilly 14y ago
I think that you ALMOST have it. You've even explained the following tantalizing quote from July: I think we could actually make it self-powering if you put solar panels on it, you generate more power than you would consume in the system. There's a way to store the power so it would run 24/7 without using batteries. Yes, this is possible, absolutely. The cars in the loop store power. A lot of it.
Now why do I say almost? Let's make one small modification. Let's put a lot of one way flaps in the tube so that it is easy for a puff of air to blow out, but not so easy for air to come back in. There would be leakage, but that is going to be OK.
As each car comes by, it piles up air in front of it that blows out of the flaps. Then the flaps fall back, and maintains a partial vacuum. The partial vacuum is no problem for people because there is a pile of air in front of their car that can be tapped for breathing air, that can then be released backwards, where it circulates through the tube (and probably out the flap).
This makes his evacuated tube comment even more of a teasing joke. No, the tube is not evacuated. Nor did you pump air out of it. But it winds up almost evacuated. However it is still fine for breathing.
Now the point is that reduced air pressure inside of the tunnel significantly reduces drag caused by the air dragging on the edges of the tunnel and being pushed by the cars. This does a lot to make the whole thing massively more efficient. Elon's claim is then that it is efficient enough that it can be powered by solar panels placed on the tube.
My big question is how hot it will be. There may be very little gas in the tube, but that gas will be very, very hot. Over time the cars will heat up as well. So you'd need to have the cars regularly coming in and out of the system so that they would have time to cool down.
The practical difficulties in building this are immense. But I do not see any physical reason why it is impossible.
- jacquesm 14y agohey Ben, I think that the gas won't get too hot because it has all of the surface of the sheath to cool it. But that's a precarious balance, and it will need some pretty good book keeping to make sure that all the power generated on a stretch 'x' meters long gets radiated out from the tube to keep the temperature stable. As for the flaps, you're right, I didn't think that bit through, I'm not quite sure what the best solution would be there. But if that's the only thing wrong with what I sketched I'll be pretty happy.
- btilly 14y agoThe problem is that if you're moving fast against a cool surface, friction does more to make you hot than conduction does to make you cool. Furthermore even if the gas was room temperature, the air touching the car has just been compressed by a shock wave. Rapidly compressing gas makes it become very, very hot. Because of both effects, the car is going to be permanently exposed to very hot gas. But I'm sure Elon has thought about that aspect and it is solvable.
- jacquesm 14y agoHm, tricky. Somehow you'd think that that part of the gas that is exposed to friction is limited to the portion that was slowed down by the interaction with the wall, and that the rest of the gas would not be subject to this because it is moving at roughly the same speed as the carriages. During the acceleration phase this would definitely be an issue, the gas in front of the carriage would be compressed because the carriage is moving much faster than that body of gas. But that (hot) gas could be dumped just prior to insertion of the carriage into the tube. Maybe the outside of the 'sheath' could be made from a heatsink like profile? I haven't given the thermodynamics of the thing much thought, I was basically just trying to figure out a solution that would not require some far-out technology. I know that lots of people like to link space with Elon Musk but I think he's much more practical than that, space is a means for him to get to mars and Nasa a convenient way to finance it. Other than that Tesla doesn't have anything to do with space and is ground transportation, I don't see any reason to go into low earth orbit with all the associated risks if you could do the whole thing on the ground and be: - safer - as fast - not have the energy expenditure of having to work against gravity - easier to maintain - shorter path The thermodynamics of having 'slugs' running around a tube are beyond what I can easily compute back of the envelope style, the only thing I see is that the amount of power put in to the system would have to be radiated out somehow or you'll end with a net gain in energy. That's mostly a surface area increase problem, the air over a highway is notably warmer than the air around it simply because all those cars dump the combined energy of burning all their fuel into the environment. If you can reduce the energy input into the system then you'll reduce the amount of energy you have to get rid of afterwards. So I can see that reducing that input energy is really important and that changing the speed of the cars is brutal in this respect because it causes the air behind it to pile up against it (heating it up) when decelerating (but the air in front would cool down due to expansion) and vice versa. It's an interesting problem and if I wouldn't have a ton of other stuff to do I'd happily cook up a simulator for this.