2 ms·
"But 'on the machine,' he says, 'you start seeing what's actually there, not what you think is there.'" In the world outside the machine and his experiments, I
by wallflower 18y ago
"But 'on the machine,' he says, 'you start seeing what's actually there, not what you think is there.'"
In the world outside the machine and his experiments,
I like how this statement ties in with Zen/meditation/Mihály Csíkszentmihályi's concept of Flow. I think we can all think of times when we've just been totally aware and immersed. But those are few compared to the too-many times when I've been thinking too much, worrying, and not being aware.
- prospero 18y agoBut our brains don't just hide outliers, they help disparate things make sense with respect to each other. I have to figure the world would seem really disjointed if you were just walking around, rather than sitting in some controlled environment reading off a piece of paper.
- dasil003 18y agoThis also reminds me of the fact that the reason most people can't draw is because they don't really see their visual field, instead they translate it into a series of symbols representing physical information. It makes sense since that is the higher survival purpose of vision (ie. it makes more sense to know how big something actually is than how big it appears in your field of vision). That also explains why it took until the Renaissance for art to achieve any kind of realistic perspective. Most people's relative lack of drawing ability is really just a lack of understanding how to see. Fortunately there are numerous exercises which you can use to break through that barrier and eventually learn to see as an artist, one good one is drawing the negative space around a still life. Of course you still need your 10,000 hours to actually master drawing, but I don't think talent has much to do with the initial learning curve. It's unfortunate that most people give up drawing at a young age when the fundamental difficulty of "seeing" properly is conflated with manual dexterity issues.
- wallflower 18y agoWhat do you think of this book? "The New Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain" by Betty Edwards. Has glowing testimonials like: "I have a degree in commercial art and learned more about drawing from this book than I did in four years of undergraduate instruction. If you practice everyday what Ms. Edwards teaches you will be drawing as good as any professional artist in six months. This really is the best book on drawing ever published!" http://www.amazon.com/New-Drawing-Right-Side-Brain/dp/0874774241 http://www.amazon.com/New-Drawing-Right-Side-Brain/dp/087477... http://www.drawright.com/ http://www.drawright.com/
- dasil003 18y agoI think one of my undergrad drawing teachers incorporated elements from this book in her lesson plan, but I've never read it myself. It strikes me that different people need different approaches to learn how to make the mental shift. The very fact that it's a right-brained thing means it's impossible to give someone a process. You can explain it at a meta-level, but I think the only thing that really produces the desired result is some sort of suggestive technique--like a koan.
- wallflower 18y agoOne of my artist friends has always told me that 'Drawing is about learning to see.' I am starting to believe him. Since I do fantasize about being able to pull out a sketchpad in a public park and draw convincingly and/or do caricatures, I've ordered the book. I feel like I can be open to a non-traditional approach. Just ordered the book along with another book I've always wanted to get 'Impro by Keith Johnstone'
- jcl 18y agoReading the article, I couldn't help thinking of parallels to drawing and particularly that book (well, the original -- I haven't read the "New" one). Contrary to the expectations of most people, life drawing is largely a mechanical process that can be learned. It is very much a matter of learning to "turn off" the part of the brain that interprets images so that you can concentrate on relatively unimportant lower-level visual details, such as the angle at which the contour of a nose intersects the contour of the cheek behind it. The exercises in the book -- copying upside-down pictures, copying pictures in a grid, concentrating on negative space shapes, etc. -- all help do this. The physical left/right brain distinction, by the way, is speculation on the part of the author; apparently people with damaged right brains are also capable of learning life drawing. It does serve as a useful metaphor, however.