8 ms·
Samsung's A15 Chromebook Loaded With Ubuntu Is Crazy Fast
- k_bx 14y agoI wish there will be lots of cheap 13-15" ARM ultrabooks on market one day...
- ivany 14y agoComing in even or slightly faster (in most benchmarks) than an Intel Atom D525 from over two years ago is "crazy fast"? I'm impressed with the Chromebook overall and I think it's a cool product but talk about a bait-and-switch title.
- dspillett 14y agoI think people are reporting this relative to expectations rather than absolutely: they assumed it woudl be slower due to the lower cost and lower power consumption but the results defied that expectaion.
- ivany 14y ago$250 is not exceptionally low cost for a netbook. Furthermore the power dissipation of the chromebook under load is only slightly better than a comparable atom system [1]. The idle performance is better, I will give them that. Still, the death of x86 in the face of ARM for performance-sensitive environments (even when power consumption is a factor) has been greatly exaggerated. [1] http://www.anandtech.com/show/6422/samsung-chromebook-xe303-review-testing-arms-cortex-a15/7 http://www.anandtech.com/show/6422/samsung-chromebook-xe303-...
- mtgx 14y agoA15 is 40-65% faster than Atom and uses half the power consumption, according to your link. So yes, I'd say that's pretty impressive at its level. Also, this specific Chromebook is higher quality than those netbooks. It's more like an ultrabook in terms of design. Not to mention that it has twice the battery life of those netbooks under normal usage.
- davedx 14y agoNot surprised by the title given the site itself, more advertising than content. Ugh
- itry 14y agoThe A15 seems to be the same weight as the Macbook air. I always thought about buying an MBA, but I feared the hassle of installing Linux on it. Is the A15 my future development machine? All my development happens in ssh and firefox. So performance is not an issue.
- crayola 14y agoI am also starting to consider this for development, but I need more assurance that it is a viable option. Does everything mostly work out of the box, or would there be a lot of tinkering / troubleshooting required, e.g. because of the somewhat non-standard nature of running ubuntu on ARM architecture? What about drivers, e.g. for wifi and trackpad?
- ivany 14y agoAfter running debian on an ARM box for the past ~5 years, my experience has been pretty favorable. If there's a solid community following (which is a good bet with this product given the hype around it) the drivers should be a non-issue. Installation went very smoothly for me. Everything else, if it can get built from source, should be fine. On my box apt-get install "just works" for almost all of the software I use, and maybe 75% of make installs go smoothly with relatively little tinkering required. For getting actually work done, I use an x86 laptop. I wouldn't ever go back to using a netbook or any non-mainstream notebook with iffy linux support. It's just not worth your time to deal with technical issues. Buy the best tools that you can find (best being what works for you).
- mtgx 14y agoUbuntu is probably the most optimized distro for the ARM architecture out there. Canonical is really pushing support for ARM.
- gabemart 14y ago>All my development happens in ssh and firefox. So performance is not an issue. Does that really bear out? I like the idea of a low-powered netbook connecting to a high-powered server for development, but in my (very limited) experience it's a pain. I have two machines, and old laptop with an AMD RM-70 and a Thinkpad X41 with a Pentium M 1.6 Ghz. On both machines, using Firefox is a painful experience because the performance is so bad. Using chrome is pretty good. I've been thinking about buying a newer netbook with better battery life, but the performance of newer low-powered mobile CPUs doesn't seem that much greater than the systems I already have.
- tluyben2 14y agoWhat's with the only 6.5 hour battery life? I would buy it if it had >=9. Edit: it's a serious question :) I am really wondering why the Nexus 10 has 9 hours and this 6.5? Please Google, add a 3rd 'chromebook without chrome os' which is a Nexus 10 (Android but hopefully soon Ubuntu hacked) with a click-on keyboard (with battery) for $350. Thanks!
- AngryParsley 14y agoGiven the same volume, a tablet has more space for batteries than a laptop. A laptop has to use space for the hinge, keyboard, trackpad, peripheral ports, and display. Worse, you can't fit batteries behind a laptop display without ruining the balance. On the other hand, a tablet is practically a screen with a ton of batteries behind it. Here's some real-world data: The 3rd gen iPad has a 42 watt-hour battery. The 11" Air has a 35 watt-hour battery. The Air is 25% larger in one dimension and over 50% heavier, but it still can't fit the same amount of batteries as the iPad. And of course tablets typically have slower processors, less memory, and less flash than laptops. Their lower specs mean tablets draw less power. With so much going against them, I'm surprised that some laptops manage to come close to tablets in battery life.
- ivany 14y agoIntel chipsets and processors have gotten very, very good with power management. With reasonable screen brightness and Wifi enabled, my X220 idles at ~8.5W. With a 90Wh battery this gives me ~10 hours on a plane, which is more than I can handle in one go. A tablet TDP (iPad) is about 5W which is 2x better. This is 2X better for a device with smaller screen, no spinning drive, no keyboard, and a much weaker processor. Intel has been improving their power efficiency dramatically in the past few years. They have the most advanced fabs and arguably the best technology in the semiconductor industry. All the talk is about ARM and low-power computing but Intel is, watt for watt, a serious threat in the high-performance computing market.
- mtgx 14y agoThat's a 6x larger battery, and it most likely scores only 3x faster in browser tests (this dual core A15 can score under 700 ms in Sunspider). And that's disregarding the much lower price and weight of this machine.
- muyuu 14y agoIs RAM upgradeable? does it take SATA HDs?
- gsnedders 14y agoDunno about RAM, I believe it takes mSATA drives. Waiting for someone to open it up to see how viable it is to upgrade.
- WatchDog 14y agoHere is a tear down: http://www.anandtech.com/show/6422/samsung-chromebook-xe303-review-testing-arms-cortex-a15/3 http://www.anandtech.com/show/6422/samsung-chromebook-xe303-... The ram and nand is soldered to the board. It does have SD card expansion though.
- gsnedders 14y agoAh, that sucks then. Having done stuff with a BeagleBoard with everything on an SD card (even a class 10 one!) it's horrifically slow. Though perhaps with the OS on the built-in NAND and /home on an SD card would give not-horrific performance...
- gvb 14y agoIt has 16GB of on-board flash behind a flash/SATA interface chip, basically a 16GB SSD as parts on the board (more compact and cheaper than a replaceable 2.5" drive). That is plenty big for the OS, lots of programs, and your home directory as long as you don't go overboard with pictures and videos. Those should go "in the cloud" or on a SD card.
- jfb 14y agoWhile it'd be nice to have it be fully upgradeable, I think the important thing to keep in mind here is $249.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoOr you could read the article for a comparison of this to the BeagleBoard.
- saljam 14y agoI got mine last week, and I've been using it as my main machine since then. I put on a small Debian-based chroot and installed Guacamole[1]*, so I can use my favourite editor and X11 programs within a Chrome tab. Compiling large C/C++ programs takes a while, but the Go compilers (what I mostly use) work really well. And I can always SSH into beefier machines (Linode/University) if I ever need to. This replaced a Thinkpad which cost 5 times as much and broke in less than 13 months. So far I'm not missing the Thinkpad. (Well, maybe the 3 button TrackPoint) [1] http://guac-dev.org http://guac-dev.org
- iso-8859-1 14y agoWhere did you learn how to set up the chroot jail? Any tricks necessary?
- itp 14y agoI haven't tried it myself, but http://technoticraccoon.com/post/27876540798/how-to-create-a-debian-chroot-on-your-chrome-device http://technoticraccoon.com/post/27876540798/how-to-create-a... looks like it may be the way to go.
- saljam 14y agoI used Debian's Multistrap on another computer to make the chroot. I just copied it into it's own directory somewhere on /home and used it from there. You'll need to enable dev-mode, and you'll probably need to remount the partition it's on without the noexec option. It's a pretty standard chroot from there on. I can write up the process somewhere or share the filesystem if there's enough interest.
- melling 14y agoCan you quantify the differences in compile speeds between Go and C++ on the device? In particular, I'm interested in using Go to replace some of my scripts.
- etherealG 14y agoI would hazard a guess at at least an order of magnitude, based on reading about go's approach. even more depending on the dependancies.
- orik 14y agoI'm
- autotravis 14y agoyes, you are.
- Too 14y agoARM processor running Ubuntu? What kind of applications can you run on that? (Genuine question)
- mark_l_watson 14y agoI should be able to figure this out for myself, but I will ask anyway: is 16GB SSD really enough to support Ubuntu and a development environment? At a minimum, I would need Ruby+JRuby+Clojure+editors an an IDE. I could probably live with just 4 or 5 extra GBs for project files and whatever my current writing project is.
- codesuela 14y agoProbably not unless you cloudsource your project files
- ebiester 14y agoHowever, it looks like it has an SD card socket as well as a USB 3.0 slot. That means you could put a 32GB SD card in there and have plenty of room for projects. If that ounce is too important, you could probably get away with an Xubuntu distribution that's fairly stripped down.
- mark_l_watson 14y agoThat is true: I could just leave a 32GB card in permanently. No reason to remove it.
- unicornporn 14y agoAnd just in case you want to know what SD card you should get: Samsung MB-SSBGA (SDHC 32 GB Class 10) or MB-MSBGA (same thing as microSDHC). Read Arnd Bergmann's comments here: https://plus.google.com/109993695638569781190/posts/b2fazijJppZ https://plus.google.com/109993695638569781190/posts/b2fazijJ...
- EwanToo 14y agoThe only problem is the way the SD card sticks out so far, it's pretty frustrating
- georgemcbay 14y ago
- ksec 14y agoI wonder how much more performance can we squeeze off from compiler. Since x86 had the advantage from years of tuning. But if a Ivy Bridge of upcoming Haswell was throw into the chart i guess ARM as a performance solution still has a long long way to go.
- naner 14y agoDoes anybody know how well the Mali drivers work on vanilla Linux (non-Android, non-Chrome Linux)? As a longtime Linux guy, these ARM machines (and the similar tablets) are enticing. I'm finding conflicting reports on the drivers, though. It appears they were closed-source, that there is a project to reverse engineer them, and also I found a website (malideveloper.com) where they appear to have source code officially available...
- randallu 14y agoOnly the kernel code is available on malideveloper.com though you can probably obtain binaries for the userland stuff (EGL, GLESv2) easily enough. ChromeOS is close enough to normal Linux (normal libc, etc) that it should be possible without too much hackery.
- gregsq 14y agoI don't know much but it's a bit of a mess. You're right that there's a reverse engineering effort but it's against the 400 GPU, not the 704 in the Exynos. Samsung has been under quite a bit of pressure to open up the GPU code, and they've acquiesced to two binary blobs. See the Arndaleboard in ref below. ARM have released code but it requires the full DDK which is not for general use. It's only available to partners. BTW, in this link is a full linux Jelly Bean android repository. Except for the blobs, which are binary. http://www.arndaleboard.org/wiki/index.php/Main_Page http://www.arndaleboard.org/wiki/index.php/Main_Page
- vibrunazo 14y agoOne of the reasons the Android emulator is slow, it's because it has to emulate an arm chip to x86 instructions. So if I'm running an arm pc as my main dev pc... Would the emulator run magically fast? Like unicorns, rainbows and such?
- mtgx 14y agoMy guess is they would have to make a version of the SDK for ARM, and they haven't yet. But they may soon enough as these ARM chips get closer to PC-like performance, and more people buy ARM machines.
- whalesalad 14y agoIsn't the entire point of the JVM: "write once, deploy everywhere" ??? Emulating the architecture makes sense from the standpoint that you want your development and 'production' (ie, the devices/handsets) to be the same ... but the Android emulator is INCREDIBLY slow. The juice is not worth the squeeze.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Niten 14y agoDalvik isn't the JVM, and Android is more than Dalvik. Android applications can also rely on ARM binaries developed against the NDK, so full ARM emulation is required in order to realistically test these.
- randallu 14y agoThere used to be a "simulator" build of Android, where all of Android got shoved into one process, but it was flaky and broken as of Android 1.0 and never got revived. For the things I've done on Android (games, slideshows, etc) I've been able to exclusively use GL and not the Android UI toolkit, so it's simple for me to have a "desktop" target and do all of my real work there, occasionally building for device and testing...
- aviraldg 14y ago
- ajross 14y agoTeasing out some inferrences: The comparison to the Intel D525 is really unfortunate, as that's a 2.5 year old, 45nm Pine Trail box with a 13W TDP. The low power 22nm Ivy Bridge cores are only 14W, so I'd really wanted to have seen a comparison to a more recent CPU. The Exynos wipes the floor on the parallel NAS tests. I'm not sure why exactly. The Atom core has known issues with floating point relative to desktop CPUs, and the A9 was never particularly good at it. So the FFTE results showing the A15 about 50% faster than Atom and 2x faster than A9 are a surprise. It's almost what I'd expect to see from a desktop box at that. On the other hand, the 7-zip and x264 tests are integer dominated and largely cache-bound, and the A15 doesn't show itself off particularly well here, mostly matching the A9 and Atom per-clock. Yawn. (This is an area where all these CPUs get toasted by Ivy Bridge, btw -- remember that 14W TDP?) The "Smallpt Global Illumination Renderer" and "C-Ray" tests (which I don't know anything about per se) shows everyone about the same (and for Smallpt 2x as fast as PandaBoard). So I'm going to guess this means the tests are DRAM-bound, and thus infer that the A15 has a similar memory bandwidth to Atom (probably 2x 32 bit vs. the Pine Trail 1x 64 bit channels). That's not great, honestly, as it's still about half of what you can get with a desktop part. But then DRAM refresh draws power, so may not have been an option for the Chromebook .
- mtgx 14y ago14W TDP is still too high, when a dual core A15 gets 4W at most. I doubt the IVB you're talking about is more than 3x faster than A15. Intel also has an advantage in process right now, and I'm not sure they will have it in the future. I think 14nm will be delayed, while others will catch-up to Intel on 14nm, and they might launch 14nm chips in the same time with Intel's 14nm chips, around 2015. We'll see.
- ajross 14y agoToo high for what? Note that the backlight on these devices is probably 6+ watts already. And TDP isn't a good comparison for "max power" (and it's down right awful for "typical power") estimates. It's a thermal number saying what you should design your packaging for. The point being that the Netbook being compared corresponds in the modern world to a much more performant ("ultrabook", sigh) system at the same power draw. As far as process nodes go, I'm not sure what you're citing as evidence there. Intel has been getting farther ahead with each node in the recent past. They launched 22nm more or less simultaneously with TSMC's 28nm logic (who themselves have a good lead over the rest of the industry!). Six months on, all you need to do is walk into a store to find 22nm digital logic in PCs everywhere. I don't believe there are any sub-32nm ARM SoCs in consumer devices quite yet (the Exynos-5 in the linked article is 32nm I believe).
- somid3 14y agoSay, for office users is open office the predominant office application suite used by these books, or to they virtual machine m$ office? I ask because i am currently a student
- Cowen 14y agoOn Chrome OS, Google Docs is the go-to office application. Once you install a different OS on it, you're probably going to be falling back on OpenOffice.
- silentmars 14y agoI wish I could pay say, $300, and have it come with a higher resolution screen.
- kindalu 14y agoi5 notebook (ex: MBA) is 3 times faster. (222ms vs 711ms) http://liliputing.com/2012/10/benchmarking-the-249-samsung-chromebook.html http://liliputing.com/2012/10/benchmarking-the-249-samsung-c...