2 ms·
It's always bothered me that laws can be so vague such that, in advance, there's no way for you to know if a particular action of yours would break the law or n
by crazygringo 14y ago
It's always bothered me that laws can be so vague such that, in advance, there's no way for you to know if a particular action of yours would break the law or not. You literally have to do it, wait to see if you're charged, and then wait for a judge/jury to decide which side of the law you fall on. It seems so unfair that law should ever be a gamble.
I've always wished there could be some kind of government agency you could go to, where you would lay out exactly what you would like to do, and they will explicitly decide in advance, and it would even set judicial precedent. Maybe you would have to pay the fees for lawyers on both sides and judge (so it wouldn't be cheap) no matter what the outcome, but if your actions were found to be legal in advance, then that would be binding, and there would be zero risk to your actions.
- rayiner 14y agoFor civil actions, you can seek a declaratory judgment.
- hayksaakian 14y agoYou have to admit though, that action is not very intuitive in most cases.
- rprasad 14y agoEvery government regulatory agency already does this. This is why we have millions of pages of regulations. For example (not exhaustive), the IRS, Immigration, and Labor departments lay out exactly how to follow the statutes, and set judicial precedent in their administrative courts. The flipside to this is that there is so much information that people don't know that their questions have already been answered.