4 ms·

How dramatic. I'll ask you as well: any proof for those colorful pictures you're drawing? Or are the people advocating for Rust a convenient target to vent othe

How dramatic. I'll ask you as well: any proof for those colorful pictures you're drawing? Or are the people advocating for Rust a convenient target to vent other, very likely completely unrelated, frustrations? I'm very happy to work with multiple programming languages without getting religious about any of them. They all have drawbacks, Rust included of course. However, just my mere skepticism about the existence of the "violent proselytizing for Rust" of course immediately had me put in some imaginary group of fanatics. Which is of course normal. People love their binary camps and nuance and discission about merits be damned.

bayindirh 5mo ago
As another data point, I have gone through enough flame wars, incl. the usual ones, and Rust. There's certainly a fanatic group of Rust developers who really want to eradicate C and C++ from the people's knowledge and all codebases in this universe, so far so openly hating the developers and designers of the said languages. Same was (or still is) true for some LLVM/clang people w.r.t. GCC. This is why I use neither. I'm always happy to discuss PLT and merits of programming languages with neutral parties, even in lively fashion, but when open-mindedness gets thrown out of the window, I do leave the room. These kinds of healthy discussions will benefit both parties. Hubris, ego, closed-mindedness and fanaticism won't. Related: What Killed Smalltalk Could Kill Ruby, Too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX3iRjKj7C0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX3iRjKj7C0
- pdimitar 5mo ago
  Well, I don't see them in HN is what I am saying. Obviously not scanning 24/7 but every time I enter an HN thread where Rust is even loosely mentioned, I brace for the inevitable bullies imagining they are victims. And this thread is exactly the same, sadly. I am genuinely curious where this fanatic group is. Where are you witnessing them?
  - bayindirh 5mo ago
    > I brace for the inevitable bullies imagining they are victims. As a person who is bullied physically, verbally and emotionally for years, I'd not throw words bully/victim like wrapping paper like that. Moreover, I'd never bully anyone. I'm not that. > I am genuinely curious where this fanatic group is. Where are you witnessing them? Discord servers, mailing lists, issue threads, discussions, here and there. They are very vocal and abrasive minority, but it's enough to make me stay away from them. A special-ops group of these people claim that Rust needs no official specification and they can just ad-hoc develop the language and spec as the compiler evolves, as a side-product of compiler itself (i.e. spec is the compiler). Last time I encountered them as functional programming fanatics in mid 2000s to 2010s. They successfully made me dislike the community so much that I didn't touch any functional programming language to this day. Make no mistake: My favorite languages have the same fanatics, and I stay away from them, too. For example, C++ fanatics are an interesting bunch. They don't bully other languages, but new C++ developers who doesn't code like them or the way they like. Maybe one day I'll start writing Rust, after gccrs stabilizes (they're going well) or really start writing lisp, but I'm sure that I'll never ask a question to a mere mortal about programming in either language.
    - pdimitar 5mo ago
      > As a person who is bullied physically, verbally and emotionally for years, I'd not throw words bully/victim like wrapping paper like that. Moreover, I'd never bully anyone. I'm not that. I was bullied as well. Knowing karate and aikido helped but not much, those people just hated me for reasons I never quite understood and kept coming in groups even. Some days I wondered whether I'll go back home from school alive. However, me entering middle age has me almost not caring anymore about the reasons they were like that, so I got that going for me which is nice. I am not "throwing" words. I believe I know what I am talking about because I witnessed a few bullies wisening up to losing prestige and status for being rightfully called out and learning to pretend they are the victims... and it worked in part. It was sickening then, it's sickening now, wherever I spot it. HN is one of those places. And btw I was not talking about you. You seem more reasonable than f.ex. this poster under my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48123734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48123734 > Discord servers, mailing lists, issue threads, discussions, here and there. They are very vocal and abrasive minority, but it's enough to make me stay away from them. OK, I'll admit ignorance because I don't go to any of those places or at least it's very rare. One thing jumps at me: you are avoiding those people which is 100% fair and I would as well. But why avoid Rust itself? Why look down on any rewrite-in-Rust initiatives? Why do you allow yourself be emotionally manipulated? Would you stop believing in your favorite alternative-energy or alternative-engine approaches if they had the 0.1% toxic zealots screaming for attention on events dedicated to those areas? I can somewhat relate, mind you. One example: I hated how everyone was trying to make me read some book classics and basically made it a point to avoid them just based on that. I was fully aware that was an irrational reaction that was likely robbing me of enjoying good art. I take big pride in myself for finally overcoming this some 2-3 years ago and starting to go through those books. They were nothing special, mind you, and I still couldn't see why people deem most of them classics but at least now my opinion is my own and built with my own two eyes and brain. > Make no mistake: My favorite languages have the same fanatics, and I stay away from them, too. Well, that by itself seems to close the discussion. You are aware of this nuance. > Maybe one day I'll start writing Rust, after gccrs stabilizes (they're going well) or really start writing lisp, but I'm sure that I'll never ask a question to a mere mortal about programming either language. I refuse to feel shame about wanting to learn and absorb other people's expertise. If somebody is being an arse about it then it's them who are embarrassing themselves; not me. But I do agree it's a waste of time and I'll admit nowadays I start with an LLM session and only then branch out to people if I feel unsatisfied. But that's a function of how awfully busy I am and not that I am becoming more antisocial. (Which also explains I dissociated for 1-2h and preferred to read HN or a book.)

bayindirh 5mo ago

As another data point, I have gone through enough flame wars, incl. the usual ones, and Rust. There's certainly a fanatic group of Rust developers who really want to eradicate C and C++ from the people's knowledge and all codebases in this universe, so far so openly hating the developers and designers of the said languages. Same was (or still is) true for some LLVM/clang people w.r.t. GCC. This is why I use neither. I'm always happy to discuss PLT and merits of programming languages with neutral parties, even in lively fashion, but when open-mindedness gets thrown out of the window, I do leave the room. These kinds of healthy discussions will benefit both parties. Hubris, ego, closed-mindedness and fanaticism won't. Related: What Killed Smalltalk Could Kill Ruby, Too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX3iRjKj7C0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX3iRjKj7C0

pdimitar 5mo ago
Well, I don't see them in HN is what I am saying. Obviously not scanning 24/7 but every time I enter an HN thread where Rust is even loosely mentioned, I brace for the inevitable bullies imagining they are victims. And this thread is exactly the same, sadly. I am genuinely curious where this fanatic group is. Where are you witnessing them?
- bayindirh 5mo ago
  > I brace for the inevitable bullies imagining they are victims. As a person who is bullied physically, verbally and emotionally for years, I'd not throw words bully/victim like wrapping paper like that. Moreover, I'd never bully anyone. I'm not that. > I am genuinely curious where this fanatic group is. Where are you witnessing them? Discord servers, mailing lists, issue threads, discussions, here and there. They are very vocal and abrasive minority, but it's enough to make me stay away from them. A special-ops group of these people claim that Rust needs no official specification and they can just ad-hoc develop the language and spec as the compiler evolves, as a side-product of compiler itself (i.e. spec is the compiler). Last time I encountered them as functional programming fanatics in mid 2000s to 2010s. They successfully made me dislike the community so much that I didn't touch any functional programming language to this day. Make no mistake: My favorite languages have the same fanatics, and I stay away from them, too. For example, C++ fanatics are an interesting bunch. They don't bully other languages, but new C++ developers who doesn't code like them or the way they like. Maybe one day I'll start writing Rust, after gccrs stabilizes (they're going well) or really start writing lisp, but I'm sure that I'll never ask a question to a mere mortal about programming in either language.
  - pdimitar 5mo ago
    > As a person who is bullied physically, verbally and emotionally for years, I'd not throw words bully/victim like wrapping paper like that. Moreover, I'd never bully anyone. I'm not that. I was bullied as well. Knowing karate and aikido helped but not much, those people just hated me for reasons I never quite understood and kept coming in groups even. Some days I wondered whether I'll go back home from school alive. However, me entering middle age has me almost not caring anymore about the reasons they were like that, so I got that going for me which is nice. I am not "throwing" words. I believe I know what I am talking about because I witnessed a few bullies wisening up to losing prestige and status for being rightfully called out and learning to pretend they are the victims... and it worked in part. It was sickening then, it's sickening now, wherever I spot it. HN is one of those places. And btw I was not talking about you. You seem more reasonable than f.ex. this poster under my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48123734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48123734 > Discord servers, mailing lists, issue threads, discussions, here and there. They are very vocal and abrasive minority, but it's enough to make me stay away from them. OK, I'll admit ignorance because I don't go to any of those places or at least it's very rare. One thing jumps at me: you are avoiding those people which is 100% fair and I would as well. But why avoid Rust itself? Why look down on any rewrite-in-Rust initiatives? Why do you allow yourself be emotionally manipulated? Would you stop believing in your favorite alternative-energy or alternative-engine approaches if they had the 0.1% toxic zealots screaming for attention on events dedicated to those areas? I can somewhat relate, mind you. One example: I hated how everyone was trying to make me read some book classics and basically made it a point to avoid them just based on that. I was fully aware that was an irrational reaction that was likely robbing me of enjoying good art. I take big pride in myself for finally overcoming this some 2-3 years ago and starting to go through those books. They were nothing special, mind you, and I still couldn't see why people deem most of them classics but at least now my opinion is my own and built with my own two eyes and brain. > Make no mistake: My favorite languages have the same fanatics, and I stay away from them, too. Well, that by itself seems to close the discussion. You are aware of this nuance. > Maybe one day I'll start writing Rust, after gccrs stabilizes (they're going well) or really start writing lisp, but I'm sure that I'll never ask a question to a mere mortal about programming either language. I refuse to feel shame about wanting to learn and absorb other people's expertise. If somebody is being an arse about it then it's them who are embarrassing themselves; not me. But I do agree it's a waste of time and I'll admit nowadays I start with an LLM session and only then branch out to people if I feel unsatisfied. But that's a function of how awfully busy I am and not that I am becoming more antisocial. (Which also explains I dissociated for 1-2h and preferred to read HN or a book.)