3 ms·
I think it's reasonable for them to argue that AT&T's server's willingness to give them the e-mail addresses means that obtaining the addresses was not illegal,
by nitrogen 14y ago
I think it's reasonable for them to argue that AT&T's server's willingness to give them the e-mail addresses means that obtaining the addresses was not illegal, and that despite mulling over the darker possibilities available to them, by choosing not to put the e-mail addresses to illegal use they committed no crime. They could argue that they should not be convicted of conspiracy because they ultimately decided not to abuse the list of addresses.
- tptacek 14y agoI would like it to be harder than it seems to be to prove conspiracy to commit fraud. I don't think I'd like it to be harder than it seems to be to prove unauthorized access. I know that's the opposite of what most nerds like me want, but I think we're well served by a very broad definition of unauthorized access, and we're poorly served by vague conspiracy laws in more places than just online. Note that under the US Code, you need both elements. Just plain unauthorized access isn't a federal crime; you need an intent to defraud.
- nitrogen 14y agoI know that's the opposite of what most nerds like me want, but I think we're well served by a very broad definition of unauthorized access, and we're poorly served by vague conspiracy laws in more places than just online. I do agree with you regarding conspiracy, but you are right that I would in principle prefer to have every Internet-facing system as robustly secured as if it had been independently reviewed by you, cpercival, and the people who wrote the space shuttle's software. A small part of the reason I want this is so that absolutely anybody can confidently write and deploy scraping software that collects and analyzes information in new ways (e.g. IBM Watson, better search engines, or some other as yet undiscovered idea).
- tptacek 14y agoThe CFAA does not in practice prevent search engines from scraping pages. In order to be charged under the CFAA, you must willfully access specific information on a website in furtherance of a fraudulent scheme, which in turn means you must be making specific representations as to your identity or actions that a website could reasonably rely on in order to trick that website into doing something it wouldn't have done otherwise. In CFAA cases, the prosecution must prove not only unauthorized access (which is easy) but also fraud (which is not as easy).
- sneak 14y agoI think that you may be my only truly whitehat friend. <g>