6 ms·
San Diego Refuses To Answer FOIA Requests About Drones
- rthomas6 14y agoIs it just me or does this not seem like a big deal? Yes, they didn't comply with the law, but they appear to have done it out of laziness rather than trying to hide something. After reading the full FOIA request linked in morisy's comment, it seems to me that they were responsive to the request, but not the the extent that Muckrock wanted. They didn't want to go dredge up the footage video that the drone sales team gave them. They probably didn't really know where it was. But they did say that they didn't purchase any drones, and acknowledged a sales inquiry.
- georgeorwell 14y agoNote to people in positions of authority: people have to actively want to use technology that lets you surveil them for it to work. Note to entrepreneurs: build such technology and you'll get rich. Note to people not in positions of authority: don't be so naive.
- morisy 14y agoOriginal story: https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2012/nov/15/san-diego-county-sheriff-refuses-release-drone-doc/ https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2012/nov/15/san-diego... Full FOIA Request: https://www.muckrock.com/foi/san-diego-county-55/san-diego-county-police-department-drone-documents-1487/ https://www.muckrock.com/foi/san-diego-county-55/san-diego-c...
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoFind some info about your own jurisdiction(s) and pass it on to Muckrock to (hopefully) find out what they plan to do wrt drones: https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2012/jul/03/drone-watch-help-eff-and-muckrock-uncover-planned-/#file https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2012/jul/03/drone-wat...
- kordless 14y agoAlameda county is considering purchasing one as well: http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Alameda-County-sheriff-seeks-drone-to-fight-crime-3965122.php http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Alameda-County-sheriff-se... Drones don't appear to be covered by the public domain airspace laws in the US: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_rights Airspace under 500' AGL is traditionally considered to be under control of the landowner - unless they are near an airport and the airport needs right of way for passengers. While the FAA technically controls ALL airspace, they can only use it for right of way purposes when dealing with passengers. It doesn't appear to be valid for unmanned aircraft. The FAA has a few things to say about drones here: http://www.faa.gov/news/updates/?newsId=68004 http://www.faa.gov/news/updates/?newsId=68004. There doesn't appear to be a specific drone law in place by the FCC, only waivers to allow flying the drones by an agency. That poses the question whether we are within our property rights to shoot down any drone flying around inside it? Given the FAA is limiting these drones to operate below 400' AGL, they would appear to be a fair target.
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoShooting them down could likely be described as vandalism or purposeful damage to police property.
- smokeyj 14y ago> Airspace under 500' AGL is traditionally considered to be under control of the landowner Seems like they should have a warrant if they want to operate drones on my property.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoNote that its not illegal yet to blind optical sensors on a UAV/drone.
- asynchronous13 14y ago"Airspace under 500' AGL is traditionally considered to be under control of the landowner" Sorry, but this is not true. Airspace above private property is considered public right of way, in the same way that a sidewalk in your front lawn is public right of way. The ceiling of what belongs to the landowner is a gray area of law, but is generally considered to be the space that is actively used. If you have a trampoline, for example, then your active usage is slightly higher than that of your neighbor without a trampoline. The FAA operates under a white-list. Everything is illegal until a regulation is made to make something legal. Radio-controlled aircraft have an exemption for recreational flight. Unmanned aircraft operated for recreation fall under that same exemption. For commercial, or civil usage, a certificate of authority (COA) is required on a per-case basis since no blanket regulations exist yet. "That poses the question whether we are within our property rights to shoot down any drone flying around inside it?" No. If someone drives an R/C car along the sidewalk in your front yard, you are not entitled to shoot it because of your property rights. At best, you could try to prosecute for trespass. Same with a flying vehicle, but unless the flying vehicle is under 20ft or so, the odds are not in your favor.
- asynchronous13 14y agoUnless there's missing information, this sounds like a non-story. It seems like the San Diego PD looked at a quote that was sent to a different police department and never bought anything. They didn't respond to the FOIA request because they hadn't bought anything. Am I missing something?
- krichman 14y agoI think you are missing out on the furor over US police thinking they are a military organization operating in hostile territory. Edit: this was hyperbole, but I think this is the slippery slope people are objecting to.
- morisy 14y agoWe asked them for any documents related to drone purchasing plans, drone guidance, internal reports on usage, etc. That they decided not to go through with a purchase is irrelevant in this case: They flatly stated they had nothing, which was, at best, inaccurate. Public records laws are of little use if the government can lie or mislead without oversight or repercussion. Hope that makes sense!
- mvanveen 14y agoFWIW, I saw a drone hovering above the 5 freeway back in September right after the border patrol crossing. I think it was in the strip between Camp Pendleton and Oceanside. It looked about the size of a microwave or a toaster oven, had at least 4 blades, and seemed to have a ridiculously good, likely six-axis attitude control and was simply hovering over the 5 doing god-knows-what. Definitely a strange welcome to San Diego after being gone for 5 years.
- mvgoogler 14y agoThat sounds like it would have been within R-2503A, which is the restricted airspace over and around Camp Pendleton. The Marines operate UAVs so it could have been part of a military exercise.
- mvanveen 14y agoThank you so much for this info! So, if I understand you correctly, the airspace above the freeway is still restricted even though the Highway is public land? Is this accurate? I agree that it's entirely feasible that this was a military exercise. What seemed particularly strange about it from my POV was that the drone was hovering directly above passing traffic. As I mentioned, it had extremely good attitude control and was just lingering directly above the flow of traffic with what looked like cameras. I can't personally understand why a "military exercise" requires hovering over civilians for extended periods of time, but I'm sure there could be extremely reasonable explanations. I'd still like the benefit of at least being offered one though.