6 ms·
Man suspected of wearing 'bomb' watch at airport released, no charges filed
- ck2 14y agoCompare this to how the TSA was swearing up and down this guy was no good the other day. And they let him rot in jail while the charges were already dismissed. Talk about a complete power-trip.
- JonnieCache 14y agoMcGann "is not an activist or a terrorist," Horngrad said. This sentence is utterly terrifying. Or at least it would be were I american.
- aes256 14y agoIt's not as though they are being treated as equivalent, they are just potential explanations for this kind of behavior (carrying an improvised electrical device, which would make a viable timer for an explosive device, through airport security) First they establish if he has any malicious intent (i.e. is he a terrorist?), then they establish if he has a legitimate non-malicious reason for such odd behavior (i.e. is he an activist?) Turns out this guy is just a little unhinged.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI'm confused, why would a political activist in particular be more likely to carry an improvised electronic device?
- tomflack 14y agoTo cause a fuss and make a point about the TSA.
- aes256 14y agoIt happens all the time. There are plenty of people who just want to create a scene, cause a fuss, make life difficult for security staff, etc. Journalists have also been known to test the limits of airport security, taking suspicious items on board planes or gaining access to restricted areas, then reporting on the associated security lapses.
- JonnieCache 14y agoLanguage defines thought, and thought informs behaviour. To use the two words in the same sentence like that is to treat the two concepts as equivalent, and to promote their equivalence in future.
- aes256 14y agoThere are, actually, many similarities. Both groups of people defy social norms and seek publicity in the course of acting out grievances with the establishment. Activism and terrorism are often one and the same. I don't think it's unfair to describe 9/11 and similar terrorist attacks as forms of activism — not that this in any way justifies the attacks — nor to apply the 'terrorism' label to many self-described activists (e.g. Anonymous with their computer hacking)
- king_jester 14y agoTerrorism and activism are both political, but I wouldn't call terror attacks activism. They have different means and execution, even if they both strive for political change. Not that this distinction is helped by how politicians love to paint activists as terrorists for political purposes.
- aes256 14y agoOED defines activism as: "The policy of active participation or engagement in a particular sphere of activity; spec. the use of vigorous campaigning to bring about political or social change." Most contemporary terrorists (Islamic extremism being the most salient example) are not terrorizing people for the fun of it. They want to bring about political or social change. The 9/11 terrorists objected to U.S. foreign policy, specifically its support for Israel and continued presence in Saudi Arabia. Terror is just a campaigning tool. I don't think politicians are too far off the mark when they describe certain contemporary activists as terrorists. As I say, it's a very thin line, and plenty of contemporary activists resort to terror tactics.
- shasta 14y agoYou are clearly a philosopher of language and thought and so I am reluctant to contradict you, but it has been my experience that the construction "A or B" is more commonly used when A and B are non-equivalent. Perhaps you're thinking of the situation where B is an acronym inside parentheses, as in: random access memory (or RAM). Applying that experience to the sentence in question (and probably because I am not as vigilant as you in detecting attacks against freedom), I read it to distinguish activists who would perhaps be wearing a faux-bomb as protest against security measures from terrorists who would be wearing a real bomb watch. I look forward to your well reasoned response.
- andrewcooke 14y agoisn't the implication "he's not a bad guy" rather than "he's not either of these two groups, one of which would reasonably explain his behaviour anyway"? i think that's what worries people (and me). that his own lawyer, apparently defending him (not just explaining, but holding him up in positive contrast), seems to be saying, "look, he's not one of these problem groups". and in that sense, as a "problem group", activist and terrorist are presented as similar.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tallanvor 14y agoI was going to say basically the same thing. Whether or not the attorney meant to do so, he was equating activism with terrorism, something that various parts of the government (local and federal) have been doing for many years now. This doesn't mean that activists can't be terrorists, but to equate the two so generally is quite irresponsible.
- Tloewald 14y agoThe guy obviously made a watch designed to give the TSA conniptions (maybe it's some kind of publicity stunt). Do large paramilitary organizations staffed by idiots have a sense of humor? No. Surprise!
- lucaspiller 14y ago"Nelson said even if McGann truly is innocent and didn't intend to harm anyone, he still thinks that McGann showed "a lack of good judgment" and "was not being very smart" in traveling with the watch."
- ccozan 14y agoThis. To me this was a raising brow thing when I read the article. Either is this ingnorance of the current rules, or was a publicity stunt. I know the rules, I follow them, thus never had any issues in airports. But there is a golden rule: if you feel like you are probably going to break a rule ( by carring somethin g strange, for example), do the first step. Always. And it works. Heck, I moved a a few bottles of finest lager from Munich to NY, I went to AA representative and after explained she agreed with me taking them.
- andrewcooke 14y agoseeing the watch for the first time, i'm quite surprised that he's been able to travel with it before. in a curious way that actually impressed me - i would have expected something like (my understanding of) the tsa to stop anyone wearing that every time.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- acabal 14y agoThat watch is ridiculous--I certainly hope the TSA would stop someone wearing that, and I doubt a regular agent is educated enough to decide whether or not a homebrew contraption like that is dangerous. So to a degree, TSA did the smart thing. The question becomes, was arresting him the right thing to do? Maybe it was--if nobody in the airport had the expertise to decide that this thing that looks like a Die-Hard-style bomb was not dangerous, maybe they had to hold him until an expert could be located. The other question is, were the charges dropped because he was innocent, or were they dropped because he got media attention? That's probably the more important question. Not everyone can get the news to write about them, and no doubt many injustices in America and in the world get ignored precisely because they're ignored.
- ck2 14y agoWait, so bulky old electric devices (toggle switch and old school big fuses) are scary things eh? How about the fact practically everyone is carrying a smartphone that can be far more easily used as a wireless trigger? You can do a frequency scan/pulse with a phone with an app! What if someone tried to get onto a plane with a smartphone without a cover and all the electronics exposed, or a clear case? Those xmas toys people carry on planes, even unwrapped, they contain far more electronics and hiding places than that fake watch with electric fuses.
- acabal 14y agoTo you and me who understand how they work, no they are not scary. To a TSA agent who probably has only a high-school education, a power trip, and was raised in a culture where movie supervillains use bombs that look just like that, yes, it's scary. The right thing to do would have been to stop him in the line, bring in some kind of expert to look it over, then let him get on to the plane. It looks like they started on that path, but then went too far. That's where my questions come in.
- JonnieCache 14y agoOr one could choose not to employ such incompetent people to do such a supposedly important job. Unfortunately that would threaten the margins, which is what this is really about. (These people are employed by private contractors, yes? If they're employed by the state, then why are they hiring such morans?)
- raldi 14y agoWhatever happened to Scott McGann, who was arrested at LaGuardia in 2009 for having a power strip?
- nicholassmith 14y agoThe TSA seem to do a pretty large amount of stupid things, but this watch is basically a nice way to poke a bear with a stick, and then appear surprised when it attempts to eat your face. The TSA ate his face, the guy was surprised. I think I saw Boing Boing championing his cause, which isn't too unexpected, but the guy must have known he was running the gauntlet and it detracts from the actual batshit stuff the TSA do.
- jamesbritt 14y agoStopping and questioning him about his watch was not batshit. Having him arrested was the actual batshit. What's also batshit is the idea that people need to curtail their free speech in order not to piss off some ill-trained goons managing a contrived state of fear.
- leejoramo 14y agowas later released after he posted $150,000 bail. So for being completely innocent, he is likely out $15,000 plus attorney's fees and lost work time. I did database programming back in the early 1990's for a California bail bonding company. As I recall the standard cost for a bail bond was 10% which does not get refunded. This is in addition to someone fronting $150,000 of collateral to secure the bond. You can post the $150,000 directly with the court and avoid the bond costs. Even if you are rich and have the cash sitting in an account it can take many days to co-ordinate the transfer of cash. (Plus you will have to prove to the court that it is not funds obtained from a criminal enterprise.) I recall several cases where it appeared that the arresting cops knew there was no case, but figured that they could punish someone due to the cost of the bail fees before the District Attorney, Judges and Juries even got involved. Basically, the TSA can in effectively fine someone $15,000 at anytime through the extrajudicial punishment.
- tadfisher 14y agoThis is exactly why bail bonds should be prohibited, or at least why bail schedules should be set on a sliding scale based on the accused's income. I can't fathom how it benefits society to have $150,000 loaned out at effectively 3000% interest. We punish payday lenders for this behavior.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Shenglong 14y agoSomewhat off topic, but I can wear my solid steel watch through the metal detectors at airports, and it won't set off the alarm (SF, Seattle, Toronto, Halifax, Chicago, etc). Yet, a coin or a belt buckle will. Anyone have an idea as to why?
- mindslight 14y agoBased on my rudimentary knowledge of metal detectors, I'd guess that the individual pieces are too small. I presume that you don't have a watch resembling a shackle, and there is some non-metal/non-conducting linkage between individual sections of the band that prevents it from having a large inductive cross section. Either that, or the guy is too distracted by your spiffy watch and forgets to press the button that makes it go beep beep beep.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoI hate misleading headlines like that. To me that headline says "there was a bomb watch and this man was suspected for wearing it". But what really happened was "the man did in fact wear a watch, which had been suspected of being a bomb." In today's world, being labeled a "suspect" in some crime is pretty much all it takes to ruin your life. While it may not have been smart to wear that ugly watch in the airport, I'm not aware of any law he broke by doing it. He did shine some light on how stupid the TSA actually is though.