2 ms·
Ask your dad to cite some instances of little guys who benefited from the patent system working as designed. I would then direct his attention to the case of R
by btilly 14y ago
Ask your dad to cite some instances of little guys who benefited from the patent system working as designed.
I would then direct his attention to the case of Robert Kearns. (See http://www.me.utexas.edu/~me179/topics/patents/case3.html http://www.me.utexas.edu/~me179/topics/patents/case3.html for basic background.) Even though he was legally in the right and won his cases, after legal fees, time, etc, he still lost. (He did win more than his cases cost, but I've heard that, thanks to inflation, he actually lost money. And even if he didn't, he still made considerably less than he would have if he hadn't devoted his life to the lawsuits.
"The little guy" is a convenient fiction.
- brg 14y agoThink instead Dyson and Ben and Jerry's. Both were propelled as businesses as a result of winning similar suits. It is likely that Kearns found the case harder to win after waiting 12 years to bring suit. But wiki shows that the Chrysler judgement was 30M, so we have 2.2M profit from the Ford settlement and likely 22M from the Chrysler judgement. In my opinion this is much more than he would have gotten in licensing fees. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kearns http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kearns