3 ms·
Maybe you'd have to provide a separate right to the characters in a fictional work, so that characters can be reused in other fictional works, but not in a way
by nitrogen 14y ago
Maybe you'd have to provide a separate right to the characters in a fictional work, so that characters can be reused in other fictional works, but not in a way that implies that the original character/author supports some other entity or product, such as the aforementioned Calvin and Hobbes promoting cereal and toys.
- lmm 14y agoLike I said, I'm pretty sure that would rule out HPMoR (Harry might not explicitly join a rationality organization, but the story exists to promote them).
- nitrogen 14y agoHPMoR has significant value as a standalone work of fiction. There's a lot of new creative work. It's possible to read HPMoR on fanfic.net without ever knowing that the author, "Lesswrong," is Eliezer Yudkowsky, or what his affiliation is with the Center for Applied Rationality. I'd say that's a far cry from Harry appearing in a breakfast cereal commercial. Of course, I probably agree with you that it would be much easier to avoid making the distinction at all. I'm just trying to point out that, if someone insists on making the distinction, it's possible to draw the line exactly where I want it ;-).