4 ms·
It's cute that ESA tries to claim SpaceX will get more expensive and less reliable as they scale up to (sort of) mass production. Uh, no. If you're going for
by rdl 14y ago
It's cute that ESA tries to claim SpaceX will get more expensive and less reliable as they scale up to (sort of) mass production. Uh, no. If you're going for FUD, at least be plausible.
More likely would be "SpaceX might go out of business if the market softens or they hit serious technical problems, whereas EADS can guilt European governments into funding it indefinitely" (true) or "SpaceX won't customize launchers for unique European requirements" (wtf) or "EADS allows Europeans to maintain employment and skills in critical launch industries in the event ICBMs become necessary" (I really hope this is never the reason...).
- danmaz74 14y agoTo be fair, the claim isn't that they will get less reliable with time. It is that time will show how much they are really reliable, and the costs of possible failures would have to be included in the cost structure.
- _delirium 14y ago> "EADS allows Europeans to maintain employment and skills in critical launch industries in the event ICBMs become necessary" EADS is the world's 2nd-largest producer of missiles, and produces a pretty large proportion of European militaries' missiles, so not entirely implausible. Of course, they could refocus: most of the missiles (the French Exocet, the British ASRAAM, etc.) are not ICBMs and don't share all that much technology with space launches.
- stcredzero 14y ago> It's cute that ESA tries to claim SpaceX will get more expensive and less reliable as they scale up to (sort of) mass production. Uh, no. If you're going for FUD, at least be plausible I wonder why they put that shot of his hands in the video. In any case, the look in Elon's eyes when he says Ariane 5 has no hope is very telling, in SpaceX's favor.
- w1ntermute 14y agoI can definitely see EADS getting more subsidies from the government to keep themselves afloat. Playing the "national security" angle is usually pretty effective.