3 ms·
It depends on what you mean by "vibe coding". Is AI coding based on an existing implementation vibe coding? What about only from a natural-language spec? How
by MarsIronPI 5mo ago
It depends on what you mean by "vibe coding". Is AI coding based on an existing implementation vibe coding? What about only from a natural-language spec? How does manual reviewing affect whether or not it's vibe coding?
- matt_kantor 5mo ago> How does manual reviewing affect whether or not it's vibe coding? I think the most commonly-accepted definition of "vibe coding" is when you "forget that the (generated) code even exists"[0]. So vibe-ness entirely hinges upon whether you're manually reviewing. If you make/prompt changes based on what you observe in the generated code (rather than only based on runtime behavior), then you're not "vibe coding". I think the other things you mentioned are orthogonal to vibe-ness. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vibe_coding#Definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vibe_coding#Definition