3 ms·
This is an important problem. It's fundamentally a problem with the way patents are granted, and the way they are used, and the way they are understood. let's a
by javajosh 14y ago
This is an important problem. It's fundamentally a problem with the way patents are granted, and the way they are used, and the way they are understood. let's address these in turn:
First, you shouldn't be able to patent round corners. That's silly.
Second, you should be able to patent things and then sue people for using your patent if you are not using your patent in any way shape or form. An unused idea should be free for the taking.
Third, there's a great deal of ignorance about what patents are, how to get them, and how to use them. Behind this veil of ignorance, bad things happen.
Unfortunately, this state of affairs means that companies like Apple can and indeed must violate the spirit of the law symmetrically with it's competitors, to protect themselves until the system is fixed.
There is no doubt it's a bad scene, but it's not entirely Apple's fault. If they exercise restraint with these patents, using them purely defensively and then with great perspicuity, then I don't see how they could do any different.
Let us all direct our feelings toward reforming the patent system perhaps by joining an organization like "Defend Innovation"[1], the EFF's group pushing for patent reform.
[1] https://defendinnovation.org/ https://defendinnovation.org/
- wissler 14y agoUseful idiots call for reform. The patent system is intrinsically evil and must be abolished.
- javajosh 14y agoI see. And what do you call a person who calls names and makes absolute statements without any support or reasoning?
- wissler 14y agoIs it your view that one may not express one's view without substantiating it? Because that is the premise implied by your remark, and -- guess what? -- it's an absolute statement you've failed to provide any support or reasoning for, which would make you a hypocrite. So perhaps you should clarify.
- javajosh 14y agoActually, that's more of a statement of worldview, of what I find beautiful. It is axiomatic, and you are free to disagree with it if you like, but if you do, you and I can't (and shouldn't) be friends.
- wissler 14y agoSo, your assertions are unquestioned axioms, mine need substantiation. Yeah, we couldn't be friends.