33 ms·
RC-scale tiny turbines are sort of a boondoggle. They are loud, dangerous, and quite frankly reliability disasters. Expected component lifetimes are in the h
by ajross 6mo ago
RC-scale tiny turbines are sort of a boondoggle. They are loud, dangerous, and quite frankly reliability disasters. Expected component lifetimes are in the hundreds of hours, most folks overhaul them every 20-50 hours of use, and they fail in the air with shocking regularity (just check youtube).
It's one of those "impressive that it works at all" kind of things. If that's what you want to see in the air, then do it. If you want to watch your one-off custom plane that represents hundreds or thousands of hours of labor fly, you push it with a fan.
- rwmj 6mo agoIs that a physics thing, or just jet engines are hard and RC budgets aren't very big?
- dijit 6mo agoI wonder if it's not a: "maintaining this kind of engine is a heck-of-a-lot of work and is why there are so many aviation regulations and the reason engine overhauls are forced and cost millions-of-dollars" kind of thing.
- lstodd 6mo agoMostly physics. It's hard to do small jets, mostly because small things get too heat-stressed I sorta watched a guy trying to build a hoverboard out of 50-kgf jets, it was crazy, hilarious and didn't go anywhere because flying a backpack of kerosene on four totatally unreliable jets ain't much fun in the end. They also cost about $5K each at the time.
- dylan604 6mo agoJust yesterday, someone posted a link to a Veritasium video[0] explaining how a jet engine internal temps of 1500°C work when the components have a melting point of 1250°C. I couldn't imagine doing that at a small scale by hobbyists. [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtxVdC7pBQM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtxVdC7pBQM
- lstodd 6mo agoYes, and those small engines might work for a bit, but then they just burn out, this is inevitable. If you build an A380 like here you sure don't want to use them unless you want to film it burning down spectacularly.
- dylan604 5mo agoSounds perfect for Hollywood practical effects vs boring CG
- lstodd 5mo agoOne can wish. Besides, thrust control is shit even on their big brothers, on those, it was like throttle down - flameout, throttle up on the other two - flameout, oh crap, thank god we're doing tethered tests. Gas dynamics on these scales are tricky too. Electric is the way to go for this.
- jacquesm 6mo agoThere is an actual airplane (multi engine) that uses these: https://pilotweb.aero/aircraft/flight-test-colomban-jet-cri-cri-6303028/ https://pilotweb.aero/aircraft/flight-test-colomban-jet-cri-...