> I'd need to see evidence that the claims are actually valid. This would indeed be best, no argument here. But this comment thread was more about whether, wit

> I'd need to see evidence that the claims are actually valid. This would indeed be best, no argument here. But this comment thread was more about whether, without evidence, that automatically dismissing a comment because it was on HN or automatically accepting a claim because it was from 'stanford researchers' was ok.