4 ms·
This looks like a follow-up take on the similar TechCrunch article discussed at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4791710 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=
by btilly 14y ago
This looks like a follow-up take on the similar TechCrunch article discussed at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4791710 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4791710.
Let me repeat my comment there.
I would personally not buy their stock any time soon.
I keep meaning to write a blog entry on this. To understand my reasoning it helps to be familiar with The Innovator's Dilemma (see http://www.amazon.com/The-Innovators-Dilemma-Technologies-Cause/dp/0875845851/ref=sr_1_2 http://www.amazon.com/The-Innovators-Dilemma-Technologies-Ca... for the book). The basic assumption of that book (backed up with many examples in industries from ship technology to hard drives to backhoes) is that any technology that has a well-established value proposition will tend to show exponential improvement on that value proposition over time. Users needs also follow an exponential curve, but it tends to be slower than the technology improvement curve. (A lot slower.) Therefore if you have 2 technologies competing for that market, eventually the cheap crappy one will be good enough, and after that point hits it wins. The premium technology will always show great revenue curves even once their low-end users start switching, but those curves hide a great oncoming disaster.
In every market that Apple is in, it is the premium product. It has competitors. And its competitors have a pretty good sense of the value proposition that they need to deliver. Therefore every market line for Apple is doomed. They show no signs of having new ones to wow us with, so Apple has a world of hurt coming.
But, you may ask, why did they not have this problem historically? My answer is because Steve Jobs' genius lay in constantly finding and delivering new value propositions. He found and defined markets for pretty computers, light laptops, smartphones, and so on. The whole Innovator's Dilemma argument depends on competing on a known value proposition, and Jobs never sat still long enough for his competitors to do that.
Of course Jobs is now gone, and there is no sign that Apple has anyone who has that talent.
- calinet6 14y agoShort-sighted drivel. "In every market that Apple is in, it is the premium product." Why do you think that is, exactly? Apple has quality products because it is a culture designed to produce Quality. As long as that does not stop, they will continue to absolutely pave the streets with their competitors' remains, because, frankly, no other company in the market has the company-wide culture necessary to produce the end-to-end quality that Apple does. It's far too soon to tell if they can still innovate into new and unexpected markets, but they've only released a handful of products since Jobs' death. But the truth remains: whatever market they enter, they will dominate. What do they need someone to come up with ideas? Shoot, I'll do it. How desperate do you think they are? If I show up at 1 Infinite Loop claiming to be channeling Steve Jobs, do you think they'd hire me? Hogwash. I wouldn't buy anytime soon either, but only because the stock price will continue to fall as short-sighted investors keep believing things like this.
- fumar 14y ago"Apple has quality products because it is a culture designed to produce Quality" Steve Jobs was a big part of defining that Quality culture. Culture is not static. Jobs was able to direct his teams towards specific goals. IE. iPhone, iPad, iMacs. etc. With each new product the culture shifted. The last major shift was towards tablets and iOS. I think those shifts allowed Apple to leap their competition. Without Jobs Apple's culture has shifted again. I think we have yet to really see what will happen in the market. I am not dismissing Apple's overall ability to continue their dominance. It will be a different "culture, a different company.
- btilly 14y agoYou are long on insults and short on specifics. I guarantee you, as long as quality concerns remain a major motivating factor for Apple buyers, Apple will develop competitors who attempt to deliver it as well. They will never match Apple, but eventually will deliver good enough quality for the buying market. And it isn't new ideas that they need. It is new value propositions that people will want to buy. And no, they aren't going to believe you if you show up claiming to be able to generate them. So your inability to suddenly rise to the top of Apple is not evidence against what I said.
- Steko 14y agoGuys been dead one year and all we hear from people like you is that innovation is dead at Apple because they haven't launched any new $50 billion products in the last 4 quarters. Steve produced a handful of what you're calling "new value propositions" in over a dozen years and most definitely had his hands all over everything Apple has launched from his death to today. Your claim that Apple probably has no new products in the pipeline is one the most laughable things I've ever read on HN. Apple is not Microsoft or Google, they don't demo a thousand shitty products five years early and hope some of them catch fire. Your claim that Apple's current product lines are all doomed is also silly and disproved by inspection of their desktop and laptop business. Apple is an innovation machine and everyone else is trying to hit a moving target. Yes it was drivel and hogwash.
- 14y ago
- toddmorey 14y agoI think Jobs' real genius was actually assembling teams. He was extremely visionary, but he was also amazing at inspiring top-level talent. I think entirely writing off Apple's ability to innovate or find new markets is a bit premature. This may be unpopular, but I sort of think that the 25% haircut Apple has endured is a market correction bringing the stock back to more honest numbers. Investors got ahead of themselves. I'm not sure they ever deserved to be trading north of 700. Even the best performers can get overvalued in the hype cycle. Apple has fallen to 527 per share with half a trillion dollars in market cap. That's still pretty healthy, especially backed by their financials.