6 ms·
Twitter's descent into the extractive
- smoyer 14y agoWhy are so many sites crashing Safari on my iPad1 now?
- lazugod 14y agoFonts is my guess.
- to3m 14y agoLack of memory on iPad1 plus general lameness of Safari on iOS 5 and above, I should think. (But mainly lack of memory, I suspect - Safari is not quite so bad on iPad3.)
- keithpeter 14y agoThe Web page containing the original article is remarkably large considering that the article is a few paragraphs of text. There are also webfonts to fetch.
- ed209 14y agoI wonder if jaiku.com could have kept twitter honest?
- aes256 14y agoThe business model is broken, the monetization prospects aren't there, and ultimately, Twitter is a fad.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoI don't think they've released much publicly but most of the speculation I have read has said that Twitter's revenues are good. I don't find their advertising model too intrusive either which is a good sign. And with half a billion accounts and at least from what I've seen, more and more people joining, it's hardly a fad.
- lewisflude 14y agoWonderfully written.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rdl 14y agoAt least they didn't go public and tank subsequently, and their downfall looks like it is happening before any IPO would be a risk. Big consumer IPOs which tank hurt investor confidence across the market, and particularly in the tech IPO sector in the future.
- fierarul 14y agoI don't understand how such a simple service is able to block 3rd party clients. Just scrap that web site if need be! I have an user, I can acces the site via a simple text-based protocol, who cares what weird client I'm using?
- aes256 14y agoTwitter want vertical integration. They're not quite sure what they can do with it, but they know any hope of monetization is lost if all they are doing is providing a backend for third party clients.
- phillmv 14y agoThat's a very nice sentiment, but it won't fly if you're trying to provide third party authentication in a manner that minimizes the potential for fraud (hence, the oauth clusterfuck).
- Groxx 14y agoIn part because scraping the website is going to break all the time, and sometimes on things you simply can't see because they're running an a/b test. Then there's usually the site TOS that explicitly denies scraping (I don't know if Twitter does, but it's standard fare).
- antirez 14y agoIt's as simple as this: it is extremely hard to do a big business on something that is trivially reproducible (like Twitter is), just because there is a big momentum at some point. Because the outcome is one of the following three possibilities: 1) You ruin the experience because of the business model. People switch to a competitor that is annoyances free as you were. 2) You ask for money. People switch to a competitor that is free as you were. 3) You invent a business model that is an added value for users instead to be a problem. You win. To make "3" working you need to be open minded and design the business model for months, with creativity, thinking at your users. It's hard but you could do it, but unfortunately there are this guys that gave you millions that will ruin this process. So "3" is very very very hard for Twitter IMHO.
- sks 14y agoI agree with you. Inventing a new business model is difficult and can take a lot of time. While keeping a website like twitter up takes a lot of money, so they do not have the luxury to keep working on this new business model. I guess to succeed in this business you need to have your business model figured out from the start, else you may end up making similar decisions as twitter did under pressure to make money quickly.
- chaseadam17 14y agoIf Twitter were a utility, I'd agree with your points. But it's not, and network effect on Twitter's scale is not "trivially reproducible."
- antirez 14y agoYes what I mean is that if just the technology is trivially reproducible, if you have the network effects on your side (everybody is using XYZ), you take the leadership as long as you don't annoy users over a certain limit. In the attempt to make money it is easy to go over the limit...
- markokocic 14y agoI don't understand why so many people are criticizing twitter for trying to monetize here on HN. Twitter is not a startup anymore, they have real investors and have to earn real revenue, and thus they cut everything that can potentially affect that. Is trying to be profitable now considered a bad thing? Is selling a startup to big company that will close it down the only exit strategy that HN praise? I know that some people feel betrayed by twitter for cutting something that used to be free. But what should twitter do? Jeopardy its own business in order to make others happy? That's not how business works. edit: s/that/they/
- math0ne 14y agoThe reason that they were successful is because of the developer ecosystem they created around their technology. They simply can't just cut that off, that IS what they are. They are literally giving up the one thing that made them successful, perhaps they can glide on the success they have now, but eventually it will end badly for them. As an outsider that doesn't use twitter and has never made a twitter app this seems obvious to me, I'm surprised it's not obvious to them.
- ForrestN 14y agoI think it's healthy and productive for a user base to complain about behavior of a company that affects them negatively. I don't hear anyone saying "screw Twitter for trying to earn money." Rather they are saying "Twitter is making itself a worse product." I think a more interesting question is this: can a business be important, useful, and have a huge user base and yet be best suited to be a smaller company? Is it a problem with the current system that a company sometimes delivers less value to its customers as it gets bigger?
- mariusmg 14y agoI find it ironic to see the usual "follow me on twitter" at the end of the post. Yeah, people will bitch @twitter but nothing will change. Also, Twitter has 1500 employees. That's absurd.
- ianstallings 14y agoI think I'm more curious about what they need 1500 people for. That blows my mind.
- kryptiskt 14y agoAn example of what they could use all that manpower for: a real, non-trivial problem that they need to solve for a better user experience is to squash spam. That is not a fight they are winning at the moment.
- Draiken 14y agoYes it's a very hard task, but you don't need 1500 employees to do that :p
- joelthelion 14y agoSomeone should build a decentralized (p2p-based?) alternative to twitter/reddit. This way we will finally have something we can settle on, we will have multiple competing clients and no censorship or arbitrary rules, and no monetization. Only problem is that it may be a harder technical problem than it sounds.
- georgeorwell 14y agoWhen did the word 'extractive' become the opposite of the word 'inclusive' anyway?
- Void_ 14y agoI'm sad that a link like this makes the frontpage of Hacker News. It contains nothing we didn't know before, it's not interesting at all and there's no value in it. David just talks shit about another company.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]