3 ms·

I think it comes down to "Is the juice worth the squeeze" As someone who worked for a large organization maintaining an OSS project, one issue I faced was how

I think it comes down to "Is the juice worth the squeeze" As someone who worked for a large organization maintaining an OSS project, one issue I faced was how do you show impact? We used to have many organizations really love and use our project , but they would hardly give anything back to the project, including writing blogs where they could have shared some success stories. IMO github stars/pip downloads etc are not good metrics and these are even worser metrics in today's agentic AI world. Its so easy to fake these nowdays.

RobRivera 5mo ago
Github stars are such a terrible metric, completely gameable. The facy it is taken seriously appalls me.
- eikenberry 5mo ago
  They are bookmarks. The more people who bookmark something the more attention it has. That attention is what you care about and is why that has become a metric people use (that and the fact that there is little else).
  - coldtea 5mo ago
    >(that and the fact that there is little else). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect
Joel_Mckay 5mo ago
People can't go into OSS projects expecting anyone will care as much as they do. In general, only a few applications become popular enough to remain in active self-sustaining maintenance a decade later. The real question, is if a project is "worth it" for your own fun. =3
fluoridation 5mo ago
>Its so easy to fake these nowdays. What do you mean? Do you mean that automated agents will needlessly download your code for no reason to bump up your numbers? Or do you mean that you can't compare your own project to other ones because they might be faked?
- 2ndorderthought 5mo ago
  You don't need to use agents to download, pull or fork code believe it or not
- whilenot-dev 5mo ago
  There are various social media gaming services with affordable prices, some for "GitHub Stars" specifically: - https://boost-like.store/category/github-services/github-stars/ https://boost-like.store/category/github-services/github-sta... - https://www.socialplug.io/services/buy-github-stars https://www.socialplug.io/services/buy-github-stars - https://buy.fans/buy-github-stars/ https://buy.fans/buy-github-stars/ - https://www.followdeh.com/order/add?ss=8150 https://www.followdeh.com/order/add?ss=8150 - https://vurike.com/product/buy-github-stars/ https://vurike.com/product/buy-github-stars/
  - ryandrake 5mo ago
    I wish more people would realize this. If there is a star/like/follow/review/rating anywhere on any web site, there is definitely going to be at least one service out there where you can purchase those stars/likes/follows/reviews/ratings in bulk. If any end user can have an effect on something, then it is not a useful signal of quality.
- agunapal 5mo ago
  Yes, one can easily setup agents to bump up the stars, increase pip downloads etc
rendaw 5mo ago
Why did you need to show impact? Was it for internal budgeting?
- throwaw12 5mo ago
  (no impact == no staffing, no resource allocation) -> Leadership: "please, stop working on it"
- alphabeta3r56 5mo ago
  How else do you get money for anything in your organization?

RobRivera 5mo ago

Github stars are such a terrible metric, completely gameable. The facy it is taken seriously appalls me.

eikenberry 5mo ago
They are bookmarks. The more people who bookmark something the more attention it has. That attention is what you care about and is why that has become a metric people use (that and the fact that there is little else).
- coldtea 5mo ago
  >(that and the fact that there is little else). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect

Joel_Mckay 5mo ago

People can't go into OSS projects expecting anyone will care as much as they do. In general, only a few applications become popular enough to remain in active self-sustaining maintenance a decade later. The real question, is if a project is "worth it" for your own fun. =3

fluoridation 5mo ago

>Its so easy to fake these nowdays. What do you mean? Do you mean that automated agents will needlessly download your code for no reason to bump up your numbers? Or do you mean that you can't compare your own project to other ones because they might be faked?

2ndorderthought 5mo ago
You don't need to use agents to download, pull or fork code believe it or not
whilenot-dev 5mo ago
There are various social media gaming services with affordable prices, some for "GitHub Stars" specifically: - https://boost-like.store/category/github-services/github-stars/ https://boost-like.store/category/github-services/github-sta... - https://www.socialplug.io/services/buy-github-stars https://www.socialplug.io/services/buy-github-stars - https://buy.fans/buy-github-stars/ https://buy.fans/buy-github-stars/ - https://www.followdeh.com/order/add?ss=8150 https://www.followdeh.com/order/add?ss=8150 - https://vurike.com/product/buy-github-stars/ https://vurike.com/product/buy-github-stars/
- ryandrake 5mo ago
  I wish more people would realize this. If there is a star/like/follow/review/rating anywhere on any web site, there is definitely going to be at least one service out there where you can purchase those stars/likes/follows/reviews/ratings in bulk. If any end user can have an effect on something, then it is not a useful signal of quality.
agunapal 5mo ago
Yes, one can easily setup agents to bump up the stars, increase pip downloads etc

rendaw 5mo ago

Why did you need to show impact? Was it for internal budgeting?

throwaw12 5mo ago
(no impact == no staffing, no resource allocation) -> Leadership: "please, stop working on it"
alphabeta3r56 5mo ago
How else do you get money for anything in your organization?