2 ms·
"Design patents are only granted if the design is novel and not obvious for all items" Are you saying this is wrong? Does it not reflect the current state of
by jlgreco 14y ago
"Design patents are only granted if the design is novel and not obvious for all items"
Are you saying this is wrong? Does it not reflect the current state of things?
"it is now unquestionable that the nonobviousness requirement applies to both utility and design patents."
The article seems to very clearly explain that novelty is a requirement for design patents. The authors think that should not be the case, but recognize that currently it is. Did you read the article?
Are you conceding that the page turning animations described in this design patent are not novel? It seems to me that you are conceding that it is not novel, but wish that were not a requirement.
- ricardobeat 14y agoNovelty is a reasonable requirement to prevent people from registering other's ideas, but nonobviousness is not, per my previous example. Back to the main thread, I don't have access to the full patent text, it depends on what exactly Apple has claimed. iBooks certainly doesn't look exactly like any other app.
- jlgreco 14y agoSo, to be clear, both wikipedia and that paper are wrong? I am not sure how your example does anything more than explain what you think should be. The relevant question is, "What is?".
- ricardobeat 14y agoI think I'm allowed to have an opinion. As I said, I don't have access to the patent, how could I tell if this patent's claims are novel/obvious or not? Even if I had, you'd probably need to go to court to get a definitive answer.