3 ms·
Your argument is both irrelevant and incomplete. The parent claimed that a greater level of immigration would likely have dramatic electoral consequences. You
by jjoonathan 14y ago
Your argument is both irrelevant and incomplete.
The parent claimed that a greater level of immigration would likely have dramatic electoral consequences. You implied that the current level of immigration does not have dramatic electoral consequences. These claims are completely orthogonal.
Furthermore, the latter implication (which I assume you made on the basis that it is the only way the rest of your post conceivably supports the claim that the parent argument is bullshit) doesn't follow from the fact that the electoral consequences of immigration represent a continuation of an existing trend.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoDoubling a really small number does not make a large number. We're still talking well under 1% annually. The only reason that recent immigrants can affect the election is because recent immigrants are voting the same way as a large portion of the current electorate. That argument applies today and it will apply in the future even if immigration levels double. If they go up an order of magnitude, it might not, but nobody is suggesting that. I'm having trouble parsing your last paragraph. There are at least 3 different things that "latter implication" can refer to...
- yummyfajitas 14y agoWe're still talking well under 1% annually. I.e., 10% over 10 years. Or 20% over 10 years if we double our immigration rate. Note that I'm generally in favor of increased immigration, I just don't think we should ignore the possible negative consequences.