6 ms·
>> for this best to work, particularly when children are more technically aware than their parents, they know how to get around better than mum and dad, that ac
by toyg 14y ago
>> for this best to work, particularly when children are more technically aware than their parents, they know how to get around better than mum and dad, that actually there has to be something which is really simple and which kind of delivers itself to your door
So basically, when children are smarter than us, we should invoke a higher power to keep'em in their place. Where did I hear that before...
(and this from the "progressive" party, you can imagine how bad the others can be. We're all doomed.)
- adnam 14y agoSince when was the Labour Party "progressive"?
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> Since when was the Labour Party no longer "progressive"? Since Blair.
- JonnieCache 14y ago>when was the Labour Party "progressive"? 1918-1995 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clause_IV http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clause_IV
- mibbitier 14y agoIs nationalisation of the entire economy to state ownership really "progressive"? That clause has some pretty nasty overtones IMHO.
- billyjobob 14y agoYou may not be familiar with the history of nationalization in Britain. (Apologies if you are.) We used to have many nationalized industries. They didn't work very well, but their prices were cheap. The Tory party and the New Labour party privatized these industries, and now they work even less well, and also charge very high prices and make massive profits for the prime minister's friends while still relying on massive taxpayer subsidies. So for us in Britain a return to nationalization would indeed be progressive.
- mibbitier 14y agoIf we hadn't privatised industries like British Leyland, British Steel, etc etc etc, we would be bankrupt and in the grips of unions. Maybe you weren't born when this was going on, but "prices were cheap" is idiotic. British leyland, British steel, etc etc were some of the most loss making, unproductive industries. If by "prices were cheap" you mean "were massively subsidized by the government so we were paying through the nose for them anyway", then agreed. Look at the 1970s. Strikes. Union action. Rubbish piling up on the streets, and power cuts. That is what nationalization means. Since privatization, how many times has your water supply or energy supply failed? Even the worst privatization (British Rail) is arguably far better than it was before privatization. One of Thatchers biggest achievements was to take on the millitant socialist unions, and she won. Overwhelmingly. She set us free from their grip. "Profit" shouldn't be a dirty word. I love companies to make profits when they provide a good service. What I dislike are millitant unions striking for endless pay and pension increases, whilst at the same time providing a horrible service. I hate to descend into politics, but you are presenting as "fact" what is actually a very biased and extreme left wing view, which thankfully is pretty outdated in the UK now.
- toyg 14y ago>> If by "prices were cheap" you mean "were massively subsidized by the government so we were paying through the nose for them anyway" Correction: higher-band taxpayers might have been paying through the nose. People paying less tax (i.e. the less well-off) were paying less. >> Even the worst privatization (British Rail) is arguably far better than it was before privatization. {{POV}} Besides, the privatized UK rail network is shambolic when compared to (officially or de-facto) nationalized companies on the Continent. >> One of Thatchers biggest achievements was to take on the millitant socialist unions, and she won. Overwhelmingly. She set us free from their grip. {{POV}} I hate to descend into politics, but you are presenting as "fact" what is actually a very biased and extreme right-wing view, which thankfully is getting less and less popular in the UK now.
- mibbitier 14y ago> Correction: higher-band taxpayers might have been paying through the nose. People paying less tax (i.e. the less well-off) were paying less. Ah yes, because as long as it's those nasty greedy rich people overpaying for inefficient state monopolies, that's fine?!! If it's considered "extremely right-wing" to believe in the freedom for individuals to own property, free enterprise free market, and smaller government without state monopolies locking out competition, then I guess I'm a right wing extremist.
- JonnieCache 14y ago>Is nationalisation of the entire economy to state ownership really "progressive"? >pro·gres·sive /prəˈgresiv/ Noun: A person advocating or implementing social reform or new, liberal ideas. Ok, that doesn't completely line up, but you get the idea. Progressive != "progress"
- mjwalshe 14y agorealy you know that labour was entusiastic about reporting MP's it thought were fellow travelers to Mi5
- martswite 14y agoNice to see the authoritarian streak is still strong... eh?
- tonyblundell 14y agoIs it really authoritarian to prevent your children from seeing obscene content online?
- DanBC 14y agoPreventing your children from seeing obscene content is fine. Deciding that other people are too stupid to be able to do this, and thus those other people need a government mandated filter at the ISP to filter adult content is perhaps a bit authoritarian. Don't forget that UK mobile providers already filter adult content (T-Mobile have something called "Content lock" - you need to go to the shop with ID to prove age to have it switched off. O2 and the others have something similar.) And the UK has the Internet Watch Foundation - a quango that has the power to request that ISPs filter some pages and images. I don't know what the answer to protecting people from extreme imagery is, but I do know a government filter isn't it.
- tonyblundell 14y agoI guess we disagree then. I believe protecting children is partly the responsibility of the government, and the level of protection a child receives, shouldn't be dependent upon the technical proficiency of their parents.
- jetti 14y ago> I believe protecting children is partly the responsibility of the government, While this is noble, what happens when I as a parent disagree with what the government thinks my child needs to be protected from? Another thing, where the hell are the parents in all of this? If the kid is young enough to need protection from many things on the internet, that same kid shouldn't be surfing the internet unsupervised!