4 ms·

How would this impact platforms like Reddit or HN?

cbg0 5mo ago
When it comes to forcing platforms outside of Greece to comply with this, those platforms will just close their service down to Greece. If you want to talk about the concept itself of removing anonymity: on HN the impact would not be huge, a lot of us are not really anonymous with links to personal sites in our profiles. Reddit is a different beast entirely.
- kingnothing 5mo ago
  Or they'll leave their services open to Greece. They don't have a physical presence there and aren't subject to their laws.
  - jamespo 5mo ago
    Then they will be blocked & only accessible via VPN
    - throwaway613746 5mo ago
      [dead]
  - cbg0 5mo ago
    You don't need a physical presence to be subject to another country's laws. Disobeying a judicial order would be grounds for issuing a warrant which could easily be expanded to an international warrant for the owners of the platform.
    - vondur 5mo ago
      Don't think that will happen, they will probably tell their ISP's to block access t those sites.
    - mothballed 5mo ago
      The "judicial order" in the first place violates the first amendment, which isn't binding on Greece, but is binding on the nature of any extradition order they wish to seek in the USA.
  - jeroenhd 5mo ago
    Greece may come after Reddit Netherlands B.V., though.
- hdgvhicv 5mo ago
  I do wonder how easy it is to de-anonymise a typical reddit user based on topics, ways of writing, time of writing etc. throw into some form of pattern recognition and see if it links up with other reddit accounts, accounts on forums, things like Facebook etc. Throw in information Reddit has (ip addresses, user agents etc) and it’s no doubt a certainty.
  - SpaceManNabs 5mo ago
    You would probably get the right person in a list of candidates that would be too long to be useful.
    - hdgvhicv 5mo ago
      https://threatroad.substack.com/p/researchers-deanonymize-reddit-and https://threatroad.substack.com/p/researchers-deanonymize-re...
      - SpaceManNabs 5mo ago
        huh it is actually the opposite direction, low recall and high precision. once again getting the right answer on the internet is posting a wrong one assertively :) thanks

cbg0 5mo ago

When it comes to forcing platforms outside of Greece to comply with this, those platforms will just close their service down to Greece. If you want to talk about the concept itself of removing anonymity: on HN the impact would not be huge, a lot of us are not really anonymous with links to personal sites in our profiles. Reddit is a different beast entirely.

kingnothing 5mo ago
Or they'll leave their services open to Greece. They don't have a physical presence there and aren't subject to their laws.
- jamespo 5mo ago
  Then they will be blocked & only accessible via VPN
  - throwaway613746 5mo ago
    [dead]
- cbg0 5mo ago
  You don't need a physical presence to be subject to another country's laws. Disobeying a judicial order would be grounds for issuing a warrant which could easily be expanded to an international warrant for the owners of the platform.
  - vondur 5mo ago
    Don't think that will happen, they will probably tell their ISP's to block access t those sites.
  - mothballed 5mo ago
    The "judicial order" in the first place violates the first amendment, which isn't binding on Greece, but is binding on the nature of any extradition order they wish to seek in the USA.
- jeroenhd 5mo ago
  Greece may come after Reddit Netherlands B.V., though.
hdgvhicv 5mo ago
I do wonder how easy it is to de-anonymise a typical reddit user based on topics, ways of writing, time of writing etc. throw into some form of pattern recognition and see if it links up with other reddit accounts, accounts on forums, things like Facebook etc. Throw in information Reddit has (ip addresses, user agents etc) and it’s no doubt a certainty.
- SpaceManNabs 5mo ago
  You would probably get the right person in a list of candidates that would be too long to be useful.
  - hdgvhicv 5mo ago
    https://threatroad.substack.com/p/researchers-deanonymize-reddit-and https://threatroad.substack.com/p/researchers-deanonymize-re...
    - SpaceManNabs 5mo ago
      huh it is actually the opposite direction, low recall and high precision. once again getting the right answer on the internet is posting a wrong one assertively :) thanks