4 ms·

My home PCs XP runs for years now. No crashes, no stuck "Apps", no demand for a change. My laptops 7 is a constant crash, constantly overloaded, reinstalled s

by aluhut 14y ago

My home PCs XP runs for years now. No crashes, no stuck "Apps", no demand for a change. My laptops 7 is a constant crash, constantly overloaded, reinstalled several times but I have to work on it. Did not even think about installing 8...

boyter 14y ago
Maybe the problem lies with the laptop? I never have issues with 7, but my experience is just as anecdotal as yours. Have you tried XP on it to be sure?
- aluhut 14y ago
  Not XP (my private licence) but I have Ubuntu running parallel for my private stuff. Never had any problems with it.
  - boyter 14y ago
    Going to go on a hunch and suggest its a dodgy driver then, or some piece of hardware windows is picking up that Ubuntu isn't. Its annoying that bad drivers still crash windows but the same thing happens on Linux systems.
    - aluhut 14y ago
      That would explain the crash but why is it so horrible slow? I don't feel the speed difference between an Ubuntu/XP is as big as in between Ubuntu/win7 (talking about the old-desktop here).
      - boyter 14y ago
        Going to go with drivers again. The sad truth is closed source drivers can be as hit or miss as open source. By any measure I have tried, Windows 7 is considerably faster then XP for the gear I run, but only when proper drivers are installed (not the included Windows 7 ones). It is annoying when you get something that's slower or doesn't work though. I was burnt by Creative with my Live! Drive and as such will never buy their hardware or software again, but I don't blame Microsoft.
xradionut 14y ago
One computer is anecdotal. I've got a house and a company full of Windows 7 laptops and workstations. (Three of which are on my desk.) Almost all crash related issues with this larger sample population have been with hardware and the very rare malware. Windows 8 in the working population isn't a solution for the majority of productive users outside of the vertical markets that have a need for a tablet.
MattDL 14y ago
I never shut down my PC (Basically always use sleep/hibernate) and have it running for weeks at a time with the only issue being Firefox freezing up now and again. I'd suggest the problem is with your laptop.

by aluhut 14y ago

boyter 14y ago

Maybe the problem lies with the laptop? I never have issues with 7, but my experience is just as anecdotal as yours. Have you tried XP on it to be sure?

aluhut 14y ago
Not XP (my private licence) but I have Ubuntu running parallel for my private stuff. Never had any problems with it.
- boyter 14y ago
  Going to go on a hunch and suggest its a dodgy driver then, or some piece of hardware windows is picking up that Ubuntu isn't. Its annoying that bad drivers still crash windows but the same thing happens on Linux systems.
  - aluhut 14y ago
    That would explain the crash but why is it so horrible slow? I don't feel the speed difference between an Ubuntu/XP is as big as in between Ubuntu/win7 (talking about the old-desktop here).
    - boyter 14y ago
      Going to go with drivers again. The sad truth is closed source drivers can be as hit or miss as open source. By any measure I have tried, Windows 7 is considerably faster then XP for the gear I run, but only when proper drivers are installed (not the included Windows 7 ones). It is annoying when you get something that's slower or doesn't work though. I was burnt by Creative with my Live! Drive and as such will never buy their hardware or software again, but I don't blame Microsoft.

xradionut 14y ago

One computer is anecdotal. I've got a house and a company full of Windows 7 laptops and workstations. (Three of which are on my desk.) Almost all crash related issues with this larger sample population have been with hardware and the very rare malware. Windows 8 in the working population isn't a solution for the majority of productive users outside of the vertical markets that have a need for a tablet.

MattDL 14y ago

I never shut down my PC (Basically always use sleep/hibernate) and have it running for weeks at a time with the only issue being Firefox freezing up now and again. I'd suggest the problem is with your laptop.