2 ms·
"Housing prices were not artificially inflated." Well, considering that during the time that housing prices increased there was a large mortgage interest deduc
by grandalf 18y ago
"Housing prices were not artificially inflated."
Well, considering that during the time that housing prices increased there was a large mortgage interest deduction, an implicit bailout of Fannie/Freddie, a huge capital gains tax loophole on selected home sales, as well as a variety of programs designed to allow people who wouldn't normally have been able to afford a house to buy one, I'd beg to differ.
The above are all demand stimulating laws. For some reason people believe that paying interest to a bank (instead of rent to a landlord) is the American dream, and significant government revenue was allocated to creating home ownership.
Why wouldn't any smart speculator double down on the idea that by betting on home prices increasing he's got the government on his side and stands to make a mint?
Now, those speculators (and in this group I include anyone who bought a house expecting it to increase faster than twice the rate of inflation) are being bailed out by the policymakers who made their gambles possible!
- justindz 18y agoThe problems you cite were legitimate. All I was suggesting was that prices were still not artificially inflated because they are set by demand. You could say that unsustainable demand was generated by policy, but I don't think that's the same thing as artificial price inflation. People were legitimately willing to pay way too much for these (in my area at least) shoddy McMansions. And I'm not defending the sequence of inanities that led up to this whole debacle. Voted you up, too, because I think the conversation about renting versus interest is a good one. I sold my house about half a year before the collapse and have a sweet rental at the moment.