4 ms·
Apple’s Stock Price Is Crashing And There’s No Bottom In Sight
- lucisferre 14y agoApple is trading at under 12 times earnings right now. Still seems like a pretty reasonable buy to me. There is almost always a bottom in sight unless a company just reeks of failure.
- georgebarnett 14y agoPundits are posting clickbait containing the word Apple and there's no end in sight :(
- ChuckMcM 14y agoNow is a good time to use that option knowledge to make a killing! :-) Link baitness aside, tech journalists focusing on stock price rather than companies was one of the less useful parts of the dot com bubble.
- chucknelson 14y agoLet's all chip in here and not click this link. Don't support these pointless articles.
- btilly 14y agoI would personally not buy their stock any time soon. I keep meaning to write a blog entry on this. To understand my reasoning it helps to be familiar with The Innovator's Dilemma (see http://www.amazon.com/The-Innovators-Dilemma-Technologies-Cause/dp/0875845851/ref=sr_1_2 http://www.amazon.com/The-Innovators-Dilemma-Technologies-Ca... for the book). The basic assumption of that book (backed up with many examples in industries from ship technology to hard drives to backhoes) is that any technology that has a well-established value proposition will tend to show exponential improvement on that value proposition over time. Users needs also follow an exponential curve, but it tends to be slower than the technology improvement curve. (A lot slower.) Therefore if you have 2 technologies competing for that market, eventually the cheap crappy one will be good enough, and after that point hits it wins. The premium technology will always show great revenue curves even once their low-end users start switching, but those curves hide a great oncoming disaster. In every market that Apple is in, it is the premium product. It has competitors. And its competitors have a pretty good sense of the value proposition that they need to deliver. Therefore every market line for Apple is doomed. They show no signs of having new ones to wow us with, so Apple has a world of hurt coming. But, you may ask, why did they not have this problem historically? My answer is because Steve Jobs' genius lay in constantly finding and delivering new value propositions. He found and defined markets for pretty computers, light laptops, smartphones, and so on. The whole Innovator's Dilemma argument depends on competing on a known value proposition, and Jobs never sat still long enough for his competitors to do that. Of course Jobs is now gone, and there is no sign that Apple has anyone who has that talent.
- mtgx 14y agoYou only need to see Android's gains (globally ~75%, China - 90%) to realize that this has already been happening. It was just a matter of time for most investors to realize it, too.
- glenra 14y agoClayton Christensen's theory has never applied all that well to Apple, and he admits this. Rather than say "Oh well, I guess this counterexample proves I was wrong!" his latest articles tend to view Apple as a weird outlier, one that pursues excellence (and gets profit as a side-product of this) rather than pursuing profit. http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2011/08/29/jobs-made-apple-great-by-ignoring-profit/ http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2011/08/29/jobs-made-a... It's true that Apple has occasionally pioneered entire new markets, but it's also done pretty well with many of its existing markets.
- btilly 14y agoHis attitude makes more sense if you've read the follow-up book, The Innovator's Solution, which describes the dynamics inside of companies facing this dilemma. However I think that he missed a bigger point. His theory is based on companies competing on a clear value proposition. But I cannot think of a single product where Apple under Jobs ever tried to compete on the same value proposition that its competitors were using. For instance consider the iMac. In theory it was a desktop computer, competing against a plethora of others. However it was the ONLY desktop computer that came in your choice of pretty colors. Competitors laughed, but people bought them. The Macbook had a very different look, but again was distinguished from competitors by its appearance. (The specs were similar to worse than direct competitors, the price was higher.) The iPod entered a market with established competitors, but was differentiated by its extreme design simplicity. The Macbook Air changed things up in a different way. You had another laptop, which was severely underpowered, left out expected features (like a DVD player), but offered extreme lightness before anyone else did. Whether we're talking about Apple's new product lines, or product lines that were in existing markets, there seems to always have been some unique value proposition which Apple offered that its competitors did not. I think that this fact is integral to its success.
- Terry_B 14y ago"The price is still up 30 percent on the year but far from its 74 percent increase a few months back."
- bravoyankee 14y agoI was expressing a similar sentiment just yesterday: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4786923 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4786923 Nobody cares what I think, but I'm going to go ahead and predict that Apple's descent will be dramatic and historical. Apple is shellshocked with Steve's passing and is completely directionless. Apple was Steve, Steve was Apple. One cannot exist without the other.
- thedrbrian 14y agoJust longer, not faster than its rivals nor lighter with faster internets and better battery life? It's not like the iPhone 5 has been getting rave reviews across the the board or anything.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sytelus 14y agoI think most sell off is driven by fear of next potentially disappointing quarterly announcement compared to same holiday quarter of last year. Apple's center of success is gigantic subsidy from mobile operators. Investors might have reason to believe that this model is in great danger because of astonishing slew of similarly capable alternatives available to operators. On iPad front they already essentially cut their absolute margins big time by releasing iPad mini. Add introduction of slew of upcoming models running Surface/Win8 in to the mix and you can see that Apple's gigantic revenue streams are in great danger. The fix for this would have been new products by Apple and that's what Mr Market has been expecting for long time. But instead we have only seen new minor versions of same old. The reason Apple's stock has been able to climb at accelerated pace so far was continuous stream of new products every 3 years and that seems to be gone now. Perhaps that might be the reason for Apple's new employee initiative of 20% time?
- jarrodrobins 14y agoWhile Apple stock have definitely been falling for the last few months (and I know, I have stock), let's not forget that so has everything else lately. In particular, in the last week with focus moving away from the presidential election and back towards actual issues rather than trying to get votes, people are remembering that the so-called 'fiscal cliff' is just around the corner. Apple's fallen yes, but LinkedIn has also fallen, so has Google, so has Microsoft; all quite significantly I might add. Sometimes things aren't as simple as "STEVE JOBS IS DEAD," a new Nexus handset or more lawsuits with Samsung. Sometimes it's just the market overall. Even earlier in the year I noticed it with the Greek bailout issues. Apple stock had been falling for weeks, then suddenly the pro-austerity party in Greece won the election, and stock prices started shooting up again as concerns over Europe collapsing were alleviated.