6 ms·
The mutual bloodshed is terrible, and, as a resident of Tel Aviv I'm personally affected, but there is one thing that has always perplexed me a bit, which is th
by pron 14y ago
The mutual bloodshed is terrible, and, as a resident of Tel Aviv I'm personally affected, but there is one thing that has always perplexed me a bit, which is the perception of the actual ferocity of the conflict. Obviously, every death is a terrible loss, but this forum is fond of numbers, so while we're on the subject, here are some numbers:
The total number of deaths in the entire Israeli-Arab conflict over the past 70 years or so, is - according to Wikipedia - under 100,000. Out of which, about 25,000 are Israeli, a similar number are Palestinians, and the rest, I guess are casualties of all the other fighting arab countries combined, although the total seems to me a bit high. That's the total for the past 70 years.
By comparison, in the Libyan and Syrian civil wars, Wikipedia puts the number of deaths at about 30,000 in each country in the last year alone. And the Mexican drug war has claimed the lives of about 56,000 since 2006; some estimates go as high as 100,000.
So, not to compare suffering, but the entire Israeli-Arab conflict has claimed, over the last 70 years, more or less the same number of lives as the drug war in Mexico in the past 6.
I'm not even sure what I wanted to say by that.
- 001sky 14y agoThere is actually some merit to the notion that this is one of the <least> violent times in Human History. But I wouldn't trust that intuition very far. The world is becoming a much more dangerous place as we speak. But for comparison, The US has been at war for 12 years, with under 5K combat deaths including the invasion of IRAQ and what-ever-u-want-to-call mess in Afghanistan. Thats comparable in order of magnitude the civillian deaths of the single day 9/11 in the US.[2] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_military_casualties_of_war http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_military_casualti... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_attacks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_attacks
- nandemo 14y agoThe Iraq war alone has resulted in at least 100 thousand total deaths (including civilians) according to the most conservative estimates. How is the 5k figure relevant? That's like AlQaeda claiming 9/11 wasn't very violent, since they lost only a dozen combatants.
- 001sky 14y agoHistorically, however, these conflicts pale in comparison to the 'normal' wars of the 20th century. Read some history if you doubt this. [1] _________ Iran-Iraq War [2] Casualties and losses 320,000–720,000 soldiers and militia killed (Iran) 150,000–375,000 soldiers and militia killed (Iraq) Economic loss of more than $500 billion (per side) 100,000+ civilians killed on both sides ______________ World War II was the deadliest military conflict in history. Over 60 million people were killed, which was over 2.5% of the world population. [3] _________________ [1] This is also clearly visible in the citation of the GP comment, but i provide more examples. [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
- noibl 14y agoLike pron, you for some reason insist on taking the casualties of one side as representative of the scale of the conflict overall. He says, 25,000 Israelis killed puts the Israeli-Arab conflict on the same scale as the Mexican Drug War (30,000) when in fact the overall death toll puts it more on the scale of the Wars in Yugoslavia (115,000). You say that the 'cost' of the Iraq war is a mere 5,000 deaths, coldly ignoring the deaths of many tens of thousands of people just because they're on 'the other side'. I hesitate to ask exactly which historians you recommend that would justify this selectivity.
- 001sky 14y agoI hesitate to ask exactly which historians you recommend that would justify this selectivity. The post-9/11 wars are not in (or near) the top 10 conflicts for the US. And, en-toto casualties are an order of magnitude lower than Iran-Iraq war, etc if you want to look at it that way. Either way, you lose.
- noibl 14y agoI've certainly lost the thread of your argument since you've replaced the comment I replied to, about 'the cost of doing business', with statistics from the Iran-Iraq war. I'm not really interested in whether certain wars are bigger than other wars. I am interested in how the trivialisation of ongoing conflicts tends to dovetail neatly with pro-war agendas ('cost of doing business'). [Unexplained downvotes, how novel.]
- nivertech 14y ago2 million murdered in Darfur and South Sudan - nobody cares. 1 Hamas terrorist killed - CNN breaking news. Make your own conclusions.
- noibl 14y agoI'm not sure what you wanted to say either but two things are notable about your comment: 1. you broaden the context to include the entire history of the Israeli-Arab conflict, 2. you make no distinction between military and civilian casualties. Between 1860 and 2010 there were a reported (by Israel) 3,971 Israeli civilian casualties of terrorist attacks.[1] Between 2000 and 2012 there were a reported (by Israel) 3,034-3,726 Palestinian non-combatant civilian casualties of IDF operations.[2] Obviously, tank battles in Sinai are not going to produce the same casualty rates as wars of attrition fought at street level in densely populated cities. Air strikes on Gaza (10,000 people / km2) are precisely on the same order of devastation though. The broader you make the context, the more you mask that fact. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_casualties_of_war http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_casualties_of_war [2] http://old.btselem.org/statistics/english/Casualties.asp http://old.btselem.org/statistics/english/Casualties.asp
- pron 14y agoWell, I don't know how many non-combatants die in the cartel wars, but I guess I'm saying that the Israeli-Arab conflict is lesser in magnitude compared to past and present violent conflicts around the world, perhaps contrary to perception. So it's not Vietnam-big (where millions lost their lives); it's Mexican drug war-big. Of course, while not a big conflict in terms of actual warfare, it carries a lot of political influence worldwide.
- noibl 14y agoMaybe I need to be a little more blunt. Because of the gross disparity in casualties between the two sides, attempting to minimise perceptions of the conflict as a whole (with a frame of reference chosen for statistical convenience) amounts proportionally to discounting the importance of the (overwhelmingly Palestinian) deaths. This attitude of "it's bad but we can live with it" is directly reflected in the policies of the current Israeli government with respect to peace.
- three14 14y agoThis is true but a useless statistic. Israelis do kill many more Palestinians than vice versa, but Hamas could end the violence at any time, and Israel can't. If Hamas would simply hold all fire, and publicly announce it, Israel would be forced to stop, both by internal and external pressure. If you mistakenly believe otherwise, you really don't know much about Israelis. [Edit: This is only true of the violence, not about the political dispute. But you don't really need to kill people to have a political dispute.]