3 ms·
> I've only had a single person ever pass this test, out of 10 or so interviewees. Did that person get the job? Lots of companies seem to administer those brai
by bjourne 14y ago
> I've only had a single person ever pass this test, out of 10 or so interviewees.
Did that person get the job? Lots of companies seem to administer those brain-bending tests and then does not use it as the deciding factor when hiring someone.
I've personally been exposed to several quizzies like checking if a number is a prime, walking a directory tree and printing .txt files, implementing a variant of the soundex algorithm, a web server to interact with the twitter api... The worst (or best) was one in which the interviewer asked me to solve a Roman Square problem as a homework. Except instead of a 3x3 square it was a hexagon containing 64 numbers. Aced all the tests, even the Roman Square and the interviewer even told me I was the only one they had interviewed that solved the problem. It was freakishly hard and involved creating a pretty complicated constraint solver.
I still didn't get the job. In fact, the common theme in my professional life, after dozens of interviews, is that if there is a programming test involved then I will not be offered the job, no matter how well I score.
My conclusion is that companies do not use tests to determine whether to hire applicants or not. Interviewers make up their decisions regardless of test results and then use them purely to make their decision seem more objective they in reality are: "Bill scored low on or test, he is not a good candidate..." or "Bill did score well, BUT $blablabla" where $blablabla is some irrational stuff.
- roel_v 14y agoThis particular one did, yes, but not just because she could solve this problem. I refuse to let my hire/no hire recommendations be boxed into binary thinking or autistically rigid 'if a then b' type of testing. I will try my best to interview in a way that will eliminate or suppress any biases I may have, but will still use judgement when interpreting the results of any tests/questions. Rigid algorithms are too easy to game.