4 ms·
That 'Electronic Bank Run'? Didn't happen.
- eli 18y agoI don't know why so many people gave so much credibility to an off-the-cuff remark from a virtually unknown PA congressman.
- newt0311 18y agoSensationalism. It also infects the media. interesting essay on the same by Crichton: Why Speculate? : http://www.michaelcrichton.net/speech-whyspeculate.html http://www.michaelcrichton.net/speech-whyspeculate.html
- maximilian 18y agoI just read the whole thing. Very interesting - A good read to bookmark for later if you don't have time now.
- Tangurena 18y agoHis remarks got that credibility because of the rush and secrecy used to bail out the institutions last year. Kanjorski isn't the only legislator that was told "the economy will crash if you don't pass this RIGHT NOW!" Like the urgency to invade Iraq in 2003, there won't be any direct quotes by administration people claiming "DOOM!" while at the same time, every utterance, every speech, and every interview was carefully crafted to give the message of "DOOM!" And since the stories of why such drastic measures had to be taken immediately made little to no sense to the public, people had to fill in the gaps with pieces of stories that indeed made sense to them.
- jonknee 18y agoPerhaps because he's on the Financial Services Committee and Capital Markets Subcommittee and gets personally briefed by Paulson. That's a lot closer to the source than a Portfolio.com blogger.
- mattmcknight 18y agoIt immediately seemed false to me. Still, my initial suspicion was that he was being lied to by Paulson's crew, not that he was cribbing unsourced figures from the NY Post.
- eli 18y agoThis also highlights the key difference between journalists and the vast majority of bloggers. A whole lot of people just posted Kanjorski's video with a few breathless comments. Porfolio blogger Felix Salmon actually took the time to critically examine the claim.
- biohacker42 18y agoHmm.. so you've never seen a real professional journalist sensationalize and oversimplify a story? And you've never seen a blogger fact check a story? It seems to me the majority of bloggers AND journalists are crap and the exceptions are good.
- msg 18y ago90% of journalism is crap. But then, 90% of everything is crap. h/t Ted Sturgeon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon's_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon's_law
- MikeCapone 18y agoExactly. Don't turn off your bullshit detector because someone has a more "official" title.
- eli 18y agoHuh? I am linking to the blogger who fact checked this story. That was kinda my whole point. The Portfolio link is a blog post, dude.
- biohacker42 18y agoWow, my brain totally garbled your post. I was blinded by my own prejudices!
- yters 18y agoYet you still got massive upvotes. Well done!
- jonmc12 18y agoWait.. if this were true it would mean that politicians embellish facts to promote an agenda. Can it be?
- b1tr0t 18y agoJournalist, news network or blogger -- it all comes down to brand. "Do you trust the source?", for millions, Fox news is a "trusted source" in spite of published memos from the business side telling editorial staff to change stories. I haven't seen a trust system implemented on the web I'd have confidence in to resolve to automatically suggest a trust weight either.
- eli 18y agoI disagree. The Portfolio piece has specific, verifiable facts that contradict the story that had been circulating. Verifiable facts with citations always trump vague unsourced rumors.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThis seems like an unusual charge to make against a national news organization, so I googled into this last night. Got a link? All I could find were the 33 memos put out by a VP in charge of all news content and an attack piece being promoted by a political group and a few former employees. I also found Fox's challenge to release all internal memos if other organizations do the same. What I didn't find was mainstream collaboration that reporters were directed to change news content. I like studying the media in general (used to do some reporting) and while it seems fashionable by some to slam Fox, this is the first I've seen of anything tangible. So I'd love to hear more about it if you've got anything.
- mjnaus 18y agoAnd just as fast as the first populist post went up, up goes another one...
- zenocon 18y agoReally? It seems this guy's principle argument is summed up as, "Remember where we're at here: the end of the longest week in financial-market history, when no one -- traders, reporters, Congressmen, you name it -- was getting much if any sleep. Simple errors can easily be made, numbers can get fuzzy, everything was moving very fast and confusingly." I'm not saying it did or did not happen, but I am convinced that after reading that entry I'm not any more convinced of what really happened.
- ensignavenger 18y agoActually, he cited several data sources that agree that it didn't happen.