4 ms·
I'd always wondered what it must feel like to be faced with a radical new set of ideas, for example, people 80-120 years ago with the "atomic" age. I feel that
by petercooper 14y ago
I'd always wondered what it must feel like to be faced with a radical new set of ideas, for example, people 80-120 years ago with the "atomic" age. I feel that total confusion with this. Many of the ideas around atoms have been simplified enough for schoolchildren to understand now. I wonder if schoolchildren in 100 years from now will find quantum mechanics and instantaneous transportation similarly rudimentary and easy to understand.
- Florin_Andrei 14y ago> I wonder if schoolchildren in 100 years from now will find quantum mechanics and instantaneous transportation similarly rudimentary and easy to understand. They will. And, to some extent, they will be wrong. There's nothing rudimentary about a nuclear reactor, yet indeed the basic concepts are now available for a bright primary school student to grasp. I think we just got better at creating a more accessible mythology that stands in place of rigorous math for the laypeople.
- IanDrake 14y agoGuilty as charged.
- doctoboggan 14y agoI would not call it mythology, instead I would use the term analogy.
- Florin_Andrei 14y agoRight. Well, what I had in mind was the huge pile of sterile discussions on topics such as black holes, speed of light, quantum mechanics, etc, that one could see all the time on... well... just about any forum online. And most of the comments during such a discussion are... I would not even call them "wrong", you'd need at least some relation to reality to earn this badge. They're more like pure fantasy, unhinged. For those people, modern science has replaced mythology. But I agree with you. Pop science, correctly done, is heavily indebted to analogy.
- danielweber 14y agoGod I hope so. I've tried dropping fundamentals of quantum mechanics on my kids so that it doesn't seem so alien to them. I still have trouble grokking the spooky-action-at-a-distance experiments, but I know what the punchline is.
- btilly 14y agoIf you understand the Everett interpretation, those experiments stop being spooky-action-at-a-distance. Instead they become a prediction about a system at one locality will interact with a system at another locality when they rejoin. The trade-off is that your picture of reality has to become much weirder.
- Xcelerate 14y agoI'm not a big fan of the Everett interpretation. It seems too contrived. I prefer to think of spooky-action-at-a-distance as the nature of the wavefunction is such that its domain is all particles in the universe (which it is, since splitting it up for single particles is an approximation). Problem solved.
- btilly 14y agoI do not understand what you think is contrived about it. To me the assumption that quantum mechanics does not describe the human brain is much harder to swallow than the Everett interpretation is.
- Xcelerate 14y agoWho says that quantum mechanics does not describe the human brain? As far as we know, it describes it perfectly.
- mistercow 14y agoI don't think that quantum mechanics is going to be rudimentary and easy to understand for schoolchildren unless we have some pretty massive overhauls of mathematics education.
- Osmium 14y ago> I wonder if schoolchildren in 100 years from now will find quantum mechanics and instantaneous transportation similarly rudimentary and easy to understand. Possibly, but I doubt they'll ever find it intuitive. The fact is, we build up our intuition on the "macroscopic" scale, and that just doesn't apply at the quantum scale. So there'll always be a level of weirdness when you learn about it for the first time regardless of how much further our theories advance beyond what we know now.
- Someone 14y agoI do not think the current teleportation is instantaneous, as that would require baffling the intuition of even the physicists that think about teleportation every day. Also: IF (write that in large font, bold, in capitals) teleportation at macroscopic scales becomes common, say with schoolchildren going to a disco on The moon or on Mars every weekend, they will rapidly build up their intuition around such things, just like the current generation is quite used to "going to Madrid/New York for a weekend".
- jere 14y agoThis is a good point. Newtonian mechanics is fairly simple to understand because it operates at scales and velocities we are familiar with. Hell, I'd say you can grok a lot of it by throwing stuff in the air and thinking carefully about what happens. On the other hand, I'm reminded of the following lecture by Brian Cox. He explains the double-slit experiment, draws things on a board, shows a really nice physical demonstration with water, and.... the person on stage is still completely lost: http://youtu.be/PaGwpbHJWGE?t=1m54s http://youtu.be/PaGwpbHJWGE?t=1m54s I'm not sure how much better that could possibly be explained.