3 ms·
One thing not mentioned in this article, and which doesn't seem to be discussed much these days is how the tax law changed to essentially eliminate the backlist
by WillAdams 6mo ago
One thing not mentioned in this article, and which doesn't seem to be discussed much these days is how the tax law changed to essentially eliminate the backlist (which was unsold copies of a book from the initial print run stored in a warehouse).
Time was, an initial print run would be quite large, and books would then be stored and taxes deferred until they were actually sold --- when the law changed, requiring that taxes be paid on unsold inventory each year, these warehouses became a tax liability and the remaindered book market was vastly inflated (previously, it was only those books which had been returned to a publisher and which were not suited to be sold as new) --- one slim text from a religion class I took in college was marked up with a series of price increases as each previous year's taxes were added to the price of the book each year for the inventory which went unsold, finally arriving at $76 from an initial price of $35 or some such from the previous time that course had been taught.
Probably, much of the damage/pricing pressure of this was taken away by the savings of digital book production --- consider that previously, to publish a book a publisher would:
- typeset a hot metal copy using a Monotype or Linotype composition machine to create galleys
- cut those up and do paste-up to create a pagination
- photograph the pasteups to create a negative which was then used to make a printing plate
Usually, the negatives would be stored and re-used for a reprint (or modified to make corrections), hence books of this period noting that they had been "Typeset and printed from new film").
The freedom of digital imposition has also made the huge expansion of book subjects and treatments possible --- math used to be termed "penalty copy" and required specially-trained compositors who would typeset what could be set on hot-metal machine, then source the balance of the characters required from a drawer in a case, if need be, modifying spacing material w/ a saw, then pull a proof to make a negative as before.
- bombcar 6mo ago> the law changed, requiring that taxes be paid on unsold inventory each year, these warehouses became a tax liability How exactly did the law change? I can see them costing as an expense in the year published and not counted as revenue until sold (that's a "tax advantage") - but having to pay tax each year on inventory? That's more than just removing a tax advantage.
- WillAdams 6mo agoMy understanding (I am not an accountant or lawyer and this is not legal advice, but a layman's uncertain organic memory) is that it was just that: - old law: tax is deferred until item is sold - new law: tax is owed on property in inventory each year until sold There were hearings on Congress and Librarians holding marches protesting the bill, but it all seems to have faded away into obscurity and the new status quo.
- bombcar 6mo ago> - new law: tax is owed on property in inventory each year until sold This type of "property" tax is very rare except on physical real estate (at least in US) but it might be they did that. If so, it'd destroy the long tail entirely, so much so that I'd think print on demand companies like Amazon were behind the tax bill.
- WillAdams 6mo agoFound it --- from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backlist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backlist >In the US, backlist and midlist publications were negatively affected by the US Supreme Court decision in the 1979 case Thor Power Tool Company v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue. This decision reinterpreted rules for inventory depreciation, changing how book publishers had to account for unsold inventory each year, and their ability to depreciate it. Because stocks of unsold books could no longer be written down without proof of value, it became more efficient tax-wise for companies to simply destroy inventory.
- bombcar 6mo agoAh, that's much older than I thought.