2 ms·
I agree that calling the Israeli government Nazis was way out of line, but I don't see how it's antisemetic. I did not say anything about the Jewish people or a
by skrebbel 14y ago
I agree that calling the Israeli government Nazis was way out of line, but I don't see how it's antisemetic. I did not say anything about the Jewish people or about Judaism - I said something (tasteless) about the government of a country. Very tasteless, because many of the people of that particular country are the descendents of those who were persecuted by the Nazis. But how is the comment, in itself, antisemetic? There was no ethnic or religious undertone at all.
Fair point though about the football supporters. Their behaviour show the worst in any people. That said, if Ajax had happened to be associated with Catholics instead of Jews, the rival supporters would've come up with something horribly offensive to Catholics. So I'm not sure that this was real decent antisemitism: more like a very inappropriate form of anti-Ajaxism.
In fact, the way I understand that incident, it's much like using the term "Nazi" to criticize the Israeli governmen. I don't see how that's antisemitic, but it's still ridiculously offensive. When I wrote that, I lowered myself to the standards of mindless hooligans.