15 ms·
"Why don't you sell Triple Town for 99 cents and make tons of money?"
- ghshephard 14y agoThis article has to be one of the most honest, rational, and clear eyed review of what it takes to be successful, long term (10+ years), as an independent game developer. While 4-6% of the talented game developers might be able to be successful playing the hit-game increasingly backloaded with more expensive collateral, the other 95%+ would be well advised to read Daniel Cook's article. And then read it again.
- sounds 14y agoI only wish entrepreneurs doing any social/mobile/web app would read it. (I think the lesson, evaluating different sources of income, applies to more than games.)
- 001sky 14y agoAgree. its even more general than that. some revenue streams are finite, not perpetual. consfusing the two can be dangerous. musicians and sportsmen are two more examples.
- pjmlp 14y agoThe ones that think about how closed source software is evil should read it as well. All forms of software development are fine, as long as the developers manage to have some form of sustained earnings from it, which is not so easy as many think.
- icebraining 14y agoSo it pays a salary, therefore it's moral? Seems a terrible argument to me.
- pjmlp 14y agoSo now closed source software is immoral? I really love first world problems.
- icebraining 14y agoThat's irrelevant to the quality of your argument.
- thetrumanshow 14y agoI think I can be of service here... pjmlp stated "All forms of software development are fine, as long as the developers manage to have some form of sustained earnings from it, which is not so easy as many think." .. in which, in context, he likely meant that those who are inclined to look askance at closed-source companies should realize that there is much sustained value to be derived from such activities. Our community tends to frown on people who advocate the Jim Gray[1] closed-source perspective, so pjmlp was naturally inclined to be defensive. icebraining was simply taking issue with the portion that reads "All forms of software development are fine, as long as the developers manage to have some form of sustained earnings from it" which, if taken literally, suggests that extreme cases like software that kills kittens is morally good as long as someone makes a buck from it. I am pretty sure that pjmlp did not mean it in exactly this way. [1] http://www.infoworld.com/t/platforms/microsoft-exec-open-source-model-endangers-software-economy-582 http://www.infoworld.com/t/platforms/microsoft-exec-open-sou...
- pjmlp 14y agoMy point is that open source software usually only works with types of solutions where you can build consulting services with, or force the clients to use some kind of software as service. In many markets that require packaged software like the desktop, usually only closed source software offers a sustainable business. In the end, if you are able to earn money with closed or open source software depends on the target market of your solution.
- pom 14y agoHis points are well taken, but as I player I refuse to participate in this business model. On the other, I would buy this game for more than one dollar, because it looks like it's worth more than that. Too bad.
- cageface 14y agoMy objection to this model is that the way it's usually implemented means that I can circumvent any challenge in the game by spending more money. This completely upends the effort/reward equation for the game and makes me feel like I'm just a monkey playing a slot machine.
- dmboyd 14y agoIt really hinges on whether the game is a discrete artwork, kind of like a book or a movie, noone wants to have to pay to see the ending(pay $10 to defeat the boss), or whether it is a developing story and the Pay to play choices are analogous to something which makes sense, i.e. pay your taxes or else you become an enemy of Captain Hector.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bwooce 14y agoI agree, and remove these sorts of games from my son's devices. We try and steer clear of them in the first place, but its not always obvious. Hayday was the last one, and I carefully explained the extortionate business model before doing it. I enjoyed and appreciate Hayday but t'aint no way I'm going to get either of us into that open-ended financial sink.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Negitivefrags 14y agoI don't think that free to play is necessarily the answer. And I say this as a developer of a free to play game. The key, I think, is in two things. The first is having more control over your ability to distribute the product in the long term, and cheaply. The retail model meant that old games didn't have any opportunity to continue to get sales. Digital distribution means that old games continue to be available, and they can continue to make quite a lot of money. The ability to distribute titles yourself means that you don't need to do a big hit all-on-day-one launch to make a sustainable living. The second thing is the ability for some players to pay more money than others. The free to play model is great at this, but it isn't the only way I think that this can happen. We have the ability for someone to pay $1000 to become a "Diamond" supporter which gives someone the ability to design a unique item (with guidance from us for balance reasons). They do not get given a copy, it's an item that is now available for the entire player base and enriches the game by providing more content for the players. This kind of piecemeal support for specific purposes is an interesting area that I think could grow in the future. The overall message I guess is getting away from the need for a big launch then slump, and moving to something that grows and is sustainable for the long term.
- notintokyo 14y agoBig spenders or "whales" are much ignored when considering how to make money with a game. There really are people out there that are willing to spend thousands a month on a social game. You could even think that all the other players merely exist in the game to entertain that small slice that really brings in the money. In my own apps with virtual currency I could see this only in a small way as the incentive was low to spend a lot, so this is more based on the experiences I have heard from fellow devs.
- ripperdoc 14y agoI believe it has been widely recognized that Zynga, GREE, etc earn most of their revenues from "whales". And I think it's an ok practice. But in order to get the money from the whales, it often seems that the rest of the players (the 99%, if you wish), have their experience hampered by constant dangling of offers in front of you. As a player, I'd rather pay a small sum once to avoid the virtual currency - and find other ways to create whales (e.g., as suggested, more like content creation, sponsoring and some vanity items).
- fishtoaster 14y agoTo nitpick just a little, didn't Blizzard have significant success producing packaged hits for over a decade before WoW?
- namdnay 14y agoYeah, and he seems to ignore Id Software too
- trin_ 14y agodidnt Id make most of their money with the licensing of their engines (id tech 1-5)?
- allenp 14y agoInteresting question. According to this site: http://doom.wikia.com/wiki/Sales http://doom.wikia.com/wiki/Sales between 1993-1999 Doom and Doom II sold a combined 4 million units (gross over $120 million worldwide). Not sure what they made from licensing.
- krakensden 14y agoNo, and after iD Tech 3 they made an effort to license their engines less.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nicpottier 14y agoThis is a pretty good take on what being a small indie dev is like. I've been through that exact cycle, of building a portfolio of games, having some big hits fund growing the company, then taking on bigger projects before the inevitable collapse. In our case that collapse actually came from our primary platform disappearing (thank MS for buying Danger) and our failure to pivot well enough into the new hyper competitive iOS market. So I totally hear his rationale from a game developer's point of view, I really do. But though I'm a developer, I'm also a customer, and I just can't swallow the coin model for games. I've played Triple Town and thought it was pretty cute, and yes, I'd probably pay 99c for it, maybe even up to $2.99. But I'm not signing up to a lifetime of paying coins to continue playing it long term. One fundamental issue is that by design, coin based games are going to be 'gamed' to encourage the use of coins, and fundamentally I don't want to participate in a game dynamic where I'm paying for game experimentation with real dollars. It is like me playing a game of chess and having the constant option to drop $20 to buy another queen. Sure it isn't absolutely necessary to win, but it sure helps. Having that dynamic in games just turns me off. Now I understand the problem of running a sustainable business all too well, having had my own game company go under, but I don't believe this is the solution. I'm not sure what the right one is, and on that front I applaud them for experimenting, but as a customer I personally reject it.
- moultano 14y agoThis is a really interesting story: http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/11/03/how-natural-selection-2-was-saved-and-made-by-fans/ http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/11/03/how-natural-selec... An alternative way to get a continuous stream of revenue is to develop a fan base so devoted that they are happy to donate money or preorder years in advance just to keep you afloat.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoSite doesn't work right now, but has an awesome 503 error, powered by [0]. 503 - Service Unavailable An Interactive Fiction by Horace The Endless Server Technician Release 1 / Serial number 110707 / Inform 7 build 6E72 (I6/v6.31 lib 6/12N) HTTP Error You are standing at the entrance to Castle Shotgun. The gates are securely locked, with an unappealing sign on the front. The sign reads "Whoops! RPS is having a bit of a wobbly. Don't worry, we'll be back soon!" To the left of the gates is a large opening in the wall, which Jim is leaning into. John is perched on a small rock nearby, while Alec and Tim are standing on the other side of the gates. A pile of magazines is scattered in a corner. You can see Jim, John, Tim, Alec and a Refresh Button here. > [0] - https://code.google.com/p/parchment/ https://code.google.com/p/parchment/
- pcl 14y agoSo... what's the business model? Do his games have ads in them? Upsells? Something else? "Free-to-play" doesn't sound like a compelling long-term standalone strategy, given my (non-gamer) assumptions about that term.
- ido 14y agoF2P means you don't pay upfront for the entire game but instead pay for in-app purchases (items for your character etc).
- kunaalarya 14y agoExactly. Check out Jetpack Joyride on iOS or Android to get an idea of what the business model looks like.
- gnufied 14y agoThere are really two types of F2P models (possibly more). One where by paying you can actually unlock things that affects game play. For example, League of Legends. You can pay to unlock champions and that obviously affects your gameplay. Or, Eagles in Angry bird. You can use an Eagle to get over a difficult level. There there is - TF2 and Dota2, F2P model. Where you pay to buy cosmetic items, but it does not affect game play one bit.
- socialist_coder 14y agoI would say a 3rd type are games like Dead Trigger and most of the "-Ville" type clones. In those games, you can play without spending real money, but it's going to suck and not be as fun. These are the types of games that have the most backlash because they just seem so "greedy". In games like League of Legends and Angry Birds, you don't need to spend money to get the real game experience. You can still play just fine as a free player and spending money seems more like a bonus instead of a necessity.
- kunaalarya 14y ago
- willvarfar 14y agoLovely, insightful article. Tiny nitpick; I think his characterisation of Minecraft is missing the cult aspect: > (And before you say 'Minecraft', let's give it another decade. :-). And immediately after: > Imagine free-to-play games as practiced by a private company that makes games with long term retention for passionate players in a tightly knit community. Now simply snip the very first part of the first sentence: > > Imagine <snip> a private company that makes games with long term retention for passionate players in a tightly knit community. .... that's Mojang, right?
- kunaalarya 14y agoI believe he's talking about individual games having long term retention for passionate players. Mojang has that with the "old model" of creating multiple titles for its community. He's predicting that Minecraft won't be played in a few years, and there's a good chance that their next games won't be as big of hits, therefore it their playing the 'game' of trying to create hits.
- robryan 14y agoA decade is really tough. Something like WoW has massive resources dedicated to it to continue rolling out content and is probably the best example of longevity in a popular title. It will hit the decade mark in about 2 years time and while they certainly would have had some players who have been with them the whole time the churn over time would be massive. Wonder what the best example of longevity in a game that doesn't have an element of near constant play required to have the full experience would be?
- naitbit 14y agoAFAIK Starcraft and Quake 3 are over decade old and still played. I assume that this days their player base is far smaller than in early days, but they still have tournaments. However they probably did not bring a lot of money for producer in later years because everyone who wanted them already bought them. Quake live if pivot to free to play model but I have no info about its profits.
- mtgx 14y agoAnd people said developers would not make money on OUYA since it only allows the free-to-play model, when in fact these type of games have been topping the charts in grossing income for a while.
- Dove 14y agoI'm not so sure. As a player, I was initially excited about free-to-play games. I viewed them as a rebirth of shareware, a try-before-you-buy sort of thing. But having played a few, and having had a few games I bought go that direction, I'm not nearly so enthusiastic now. They almost always suck, or turn out to suck after they add in-game purchases. Even the games I would have held up as shining examples of "doing it right" sucked six months later. These days I'm wary of games that advertise free to play. As if that were something I, as a player, wanted. I see it less as a try-it-we're-sure-you'll-like-it and more of a we-won't-tell-you-what-it-costs and we-can-get-you-hooked-and-you-won't-care-it's-not-fun and maybe a little we'll-keep-changing-it-so-you-keep-needing-to-pay. There's such strong pressure to have purchases affect gameplay, too. I've seen any number of nice games start out promising that would never happen, and then . . . it happened. I mean, remember when they introduced hats in TF2? Said they'd never, never, never affect gameplay? We know how that went. So I don't know. For me as a player, that sort of game has an uphill battle to earn my trust. Even if it's awesome now, the pressures are just such that it probably won't be in six months. Not the sort of thing I want to build my cherished family entertainment memories around. There's also the rather-disturbing phenomenon of a small percentage of people spending an outlandish amount of money on these games. Sure, some of them might be enthusiastic fans, but that seems unlikely to me. Free-to-play games are just . . . not that kind of game. It seems more likely that they're folks with poor judgement, or who are even mentally ill. I don't know, but it doesn't sit well with me. I'm not a successful indie game publisher or anything, so I don't have a proposed alternative. But I do think I'm not the only one who feels this way, and I'd expect the view to become more prevalent as players gain experience with the model. Free-to-play might be dominant now, but I wouldn't bet on it staying that way.
- gnufied 14y ago> I mean, remember when they introduced hats in TF2? Said they'd never, never, never affect gameplay? We know how that went. Actually I don't know how that went. I play bit of Dota2 which has similar model and Valve has always contested that, in-game cosmetics will never affect game play and so far it hasn't. So I am very curious with TF2 hats affecting game play. Care to elaborate?
- gokhan 14y agoFor a well thought free-to-play model generating tons of money, I would nominate World of Tanks, a MMO PC game.
- jaggederest 14y agoAt some level you have an average revenue per user. If you charge up front some reasonable multiplier of the net present value of that average revenue per user, what is the difference if it's spread out over 10 years or immediate? I guess my point with that is that as a user, I see free to play in general as being somewhat duplicitous. If it has a price tag on it, I can buy it or not. Even DLC, bad as it may be, has that sort of thing going on. But 'free to play' really means 'I won't tell you how much this will cost you up front'. The bottom line is that your game has to be really good to make money, because there are so many games out there and many people want to make games, going so far as to spend large amounts of their free time doing it. Competing with 'free labor' is hard to do. There's no silver bullet, and no business model magic will change that. It's the same as being a rock star musician, or a professional athlete.
- mvzink 14y agoI'm surprised Guild Wars (especially 2) hasn't been brought up. I don't know about a game like Triple Town, but ArenaNet's sort of hybrid model seems promising: up front fee for a great, complete game, and more opportunities with the "coin model" (gems). They also have e-sports going for them, which is one of many things that encourages the long term relationship that Daniel mentions.
- Revisor 14y agoLet's have a look at the immoral gameplay checklist: Timed energy: Check Triple Town is free to play forever. Eventually, you will run out of moves, but they replenish for free if you wait a while, and you can also buy more moves with free coins that you earn in-game. Incentivized ads in-game: Check (wrong for both the player and the advertiser) Update: we've added a 2-minute mode that you can play free, forever, as much as you want, by watching advertisements in between play sessions. This is the real price of the game: If you want to eliminate the move counter altogether, there is a one-time fee for lifetime unlimited moves. Sorry to be blunt, but make a game with real value - not a casual puzzle game with a limited move energy - and the players will buy it. For some nice mobile packaged games see Avernum and Avadon, Silversword, Mission Europa or The World Ends With You and Ghost Trick.
- danso 14y agoThe last two games you mentioned are from powerhouse studios, Square and Capcom, and were not likely to be profitable or popular in of themselves as Premium priced iOS games.
- jamesgeck0 14y ago"Sorry to be blunt, but make a game with real value - not a casual puzzle game with a limited move energy..." Have you played Triple Town? You can argue about the ethics of how the developer is making money, but the gameplay is ridiculously solid. Casual or not, it's a genuinely good, original game with a reasonable amount of depth to it.
- Natsu 14y ago> For some nice mobile packaged games see Avernum and Avadon, Silversword, Mission Europa or The World Ends With You and Ghost Trick. I can't believe Avernum is still around. I remember my friend playing it on his Mac when we were kids. And I heartily second your recommendation of The World Ends With You. Great game.
- anigbrowl 14y agoOn a wholly irrelevant side note, Daniel Cook looks like my identical twin. I didn't make the connection with Triple Town and got a nasty fright when I clicked on the link.
- Dove 14y agoI checked out Triple Town, curious what sort of game someone looking for both strong ties with players and recurring revenue would produce. What I found was a game with a single $4 purchase that unlocked everything. That definitely suits me as a player, but I don't see how it constitutes recurring revenue. It looks and feels like an option to just buy the game. If it turns out not to be, I'll feel betrayed. Am I misunderstanding the model here? Is the 'recurring' aspect supposed to be from players as a group--a certain percent converting on a monthly basis, without publicity events? Is what clearly looks like a 'purchase game' to me not intended as such? Will I sit down to play some evening only to find a warped experience that's grindy and lame without an infusion of coins? Or is all this talk of free to play really about fully functional trials--asking me for $4 after I'm sure I like the game rather than $1 on a hope? (Something which seems sensible, but I don't see how it would help with a boom/bust cycle.)
- CodeCube 14y agoYep, it's for unlimited/unrestricted play ... so in this case it's a trial. But a community has in fact grown around this game, and in the future they could enhance it for additional IAP funds, sort of like the dagobah IAP in angry birds starwars. I don't know if they're actually planning to do this particular thing, but he even says that he wants his games to be ongoing services that evolve and improve over time.
- smackfu 14y agoI'm not super familiar with the game either, but since you can buy $5 worth of coins, I doubt the $4 actually unlocks everything.
- Dove 14y agoOh! I completely missed that you can buy coins. I really ought to switch my default association with coins in games from "game mechanic" to "real cash". The times, they are a' changin'.
- lifeformed 14y agoThe business model should fit the design of the game, not the other way around. If you try to force a freemium model into a traditional game, you cheapen the whole thing. The quality of your game design should be your selling point, not cheap in-game nags and enticements. It's like if Apple subsidized MacBooks with on-screen advertising. Sure, it could make a buck, but if your core vision is a quality product experience, this goes totally against that, and it defines your brand into something you may not have hoped for. On the other hand, if your priority is to create a profitable entertainment product, and you'd like to capitalize on the enticement of a well-designed in-game purchasing system, then you should go all the way. If it's to succeed financially, the purchasing aspect of the game has to be the core in which all major design decisions are measured against. If you want to switch to a traditional single-sale system, you have to alter the game design in extreme ways. Business models are not interchangeable within games, because a freemium system is inextricably tied to the game design. As someone who hopes to see more games that are made first as a game, and second as a product, I'd like to say that a quality-first focus can carry your game to success, if you have the ability to execute. As long as you don't overextend yourself, like the blog post stated, you should be able to continue making hits if you can maintain quality in design and execution.
- aristidb 14y agoToo bad he only mentions Minecraft in passing, because in some ways I think it tries to learn from the same problems: It tries to stay fresh to be able to attract new buyers, and it's so open-ended that it has a lot of replay value. So it still sells quite handily (the speed seems to have slowed down somewhat, but a few days ago, it was announced that they had sold 8 million copies for PC - and that doesn't count the millions of XBox 360 copies at all). Yet it is quite different: It costs money once, and you get updates for free - and there's no in-game market of any sort, whereas the OP wants no money upfront and tries to get people to buy in-game stuff.
- mcherm 14y agoBut he DOES mention Minecraft, by saying to see what it's like in a decade. Now, if there were 10 examples like Minecraft, then I don't think he could dismiss it so freely. But with a single exception... it is reasonable to consider it an outlier.
- rocky1138 14y agoActually, the pace of Minecraft's sales has been holding steady/increasing over time, not decreasing. 1 million - January 12th, 2011 2 million - April 25th, 2011 3 million - August 7th, 2011 4 million - November 7th, 2011 5 million - February 18th, 2012 6 million - not sure. 7 million - August 15th, 2012 8 million - November 14th, 2012 Source: http://gameblaster64.xandorus.com/sales-numbers http://gameblaster64.xandorus.com/sales-numbers Disclaimer: it's my site. Second source: http://www.destructoid.com/minecraft-surpasses-one-million-sales-still-in-beta-191502.phtml http://www.destructoid.com/minecraft-surpasses-one-million-s...
- robomartin 14y agoI find this discussion very interesting. I have been working on a series of educational apps (game-ish) for children, mostly for iOS now. I can't bring myself to place ads on these apps or otherwise monetize other than simply selling them for a fixed price. One approach I have taken is to have some of the apps available for free while the others are not. The theory being that the free apps might drive customers towards the paid apps. Too early to tell if this is a good strategy. In reading this my concern is almost exactly that of the author. I am interested in creating reasonable long-term revenue sources. They don't have to be hits, all they need to do is trickle in a reasonable level of income per month at a reasonably consistent rate. I'd be interested in hearing from others who have done this and their opinions on the best approaches to making this happen.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoYou can make a good living off of fixed price games - micro-transactions have only become popular in the past 5 years or so (at least in the US). The game industry was very profitable long before micro-transactions. Does not matter if you are doing mobile, PC, etc. You probably will not make as much money, but you at least can feel guilt-free about your work (if micro-transactions do make you feel guilty). Many fixed-price games have made millions of dollars on mobile (for games that cost a few hundred thousand to produce, at most). All that said, I am not against micro-transactions. I am against them when there is no other reasonable way to play the game though, or they are psychologically manipulative. I have probably spent a few hundred dollars on micro-transactions, and the experience left me feeling empty (not unlike a washed up drug addict)...which is why I refuse to buy any more games that use this method in an exploitive manner.
- programminggeek 14y agoThis dev is 100% right. Games as a service are probably a more sustainable way to go than a $1 sale and you're done. Most great businesses survive on repeat business - Apple customers tend to buy multiple iphones, ipods, ipads, and macs. Microsoft customers tend to buy multiple PCs or copies of Windows and Office. Google customers tend to keep buying ads and users tend to keep clicking them. A single sale, whether its $1 or $50 means you have to keep making new things to make more sales, vs. a service where you get paid in microtransactions or subscriptions or both allows you to keep selling to existing customers. The LTV is probably higher per customer and it's cheaper because you don't have to keep advertising or advertise as much to get the next sale from an existing customer.
- smacktoward 14y agoI don't work in the mobile-games space myself, but it feels to me like the real problem here is the massive collapse in accepted prices that market has seen. If people were willing to spend $10 on mobile games -- which is still 80% less than what AAA titles on console and PC cost! -- the "hit-driven" model he describes would be much more tenable. But when everything has to cost 99 cents there's just no way for anything other than a truly massive, once-in-a-lifetime hit to be worth it financially.
- 89a 14y agoBlame Rovio, Tiny Wings and Whoever makes Wheres My Water etc. They had hit games, made sequels and therefore had the power to push the market value back up again (even by some small increments) but instead they chose to sell for the smallest amount Apple allows again.
- timmaah 14y agoNone of the paid Rovio games are 99 cents.
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoNo publisher singlehandedly has the power to push prices up. If they raise the prices, they'll sell fewer copies. Given that the number of downloads is the primary way to get exposure on the app store, free games have an edge over paid games, and cheap games have an edge over expensive games. It's my belief that you'll sell more than 4x the copies at $1 than $4. This higher revenue coupled with the increased chance of exposure in the app store makes it a no-brainer.
- trhtrsh 14y ago> It's my belief that you'll sell more than 4x the copies at $1 than $4. That's a horrible thing to believe without testing. There are many experience reports of profit boosts when changing price from $1 to $3, for example.
- djandrew 14y agoMost of the games I make are free to play and have a resource that can be earned as well as paid for. This allows the player to buy time. Time that would have been spent earning the resource. So, if you are a patient player you can play free with ads, if not, buy some of the resource, and I'll remove the ads. This model has worked very well.
- greatscott22 14y agoThere is a lecture about Triple Town's monetization model that is available online, where they discuss what they did wrong with Triple Town and what they learned from it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UH0-9url3KY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UH0-9url3KY
- mindstab 14y agoI was interested he didn’t point out that having a hit free game != having a hit paid game and the conversion rate form free players to paid is like catastrophically small. additionally free games spread via word of mouth way more virulently because they are free, everyone can try. to spread a paid game you need EACH damn person to pay for it, the word of mouth won't even spread as far. I think anyone who even thinks a 1% conversion rate of fans is insane based on no data. Based on data I'd bet its much much less than 1%. Which is why most paid games have to drop a metric fuck ton of $ on advertising. Building sized 10 storey starcraft 2 poster ads aren't free nor are super bowl tv slots for WoW ads. Same for books and media which is how we then end up in the publisher model system. Publishers front a ludicrous amount of money and pump ass loads into advertising to get the word out. That replaces all the free word of mouth and at least the idea of the game reaches a more optimal maximal audience. Still small conversion but yeah.
- lazerwalker 14y agoEverything he says is spot-on, but what's unfortunate is I'm not sure how applicable it is to Triple Town. I adore Triple Town. It's the perfect combination of casual "pick up and play"-ness with meaningful and deep gameplay, layered with a fantastic visual aesthetic on top. It's one of the only F2P games I've happily spent real money on. That being said, it doesn't strike me as an evergreen, "I want people to be active players for ten years" game. Its match-3 mechanic is fantastic, but once you get tired of it you stop playing. When it first came out a lot of my friends were spending hours a day on it for a solid week or two, but I don't know a single person who didn't essentially lose interest and completely give it up within a month. Spry Fox is clearly trying to combat this fatigue by adding in new gameplay modes, but anecdotally that hasn't done anything to overcome the fundamental problem of people getting tired of the core mechanic. It's still a great game, and I still recommend it zealously to friends asking for iOS game recommendations, but I find it hard to believe that it'll be able to accumulate and sustain a highly-engaged userbase in the long term.
- logn 14y agoWell, I wanted to try Triple Town, but on facebook I see this: "This app may post on my behalf, including your high scores and more." Sorry, that's not something I'm willing to "pay".
- trhtrsh 14y agoIt is spyware on G+ too: """ Triple Town is requesting permission to: View a list of people from your circles, ordered based on your interactions with them across Google """
- roc 14y agoThis sounds like a slight-of-hand argument. How is "free to play" design anything other than a lottery ticket of another kind? Sure, if you get a free-to-play hit, it's likely easier to quit your day job while resisting the siren call of "grow the company". (because the revenue doesn't all show up at once) But what are the odds of having a free-to-play hit? What are the odds of keeping it going? Are they even as high as the odds of having a traditional game hit so big that its revenues could support a developer for several years? (if one judiciously sat on the up-front revenue and refused to grow the company) And by using the broad term "free to play" he's casually conflating the worst of in-app practices ("pay to win", "pay for moves") with the defensible corners that just graft on-going revenue onto largely packaged games ("pay for digital hats", ad-supported gaming). I've never played Triple Town. I don't know where it falls on the spectrum of "digital hats aren't hurting anyone" to "nice skinner box you've got there". But it seems to me these are very different things and the sins of the latter can't be excused by allusions to the harmlessness of the former. And beyond all that: The hit-driven nature of game development is no different than in any other medium where people try to create for a living. "One Hit Wonders" are the vast majority of writers, musicians, artists, moviemakers -- even toymakers. Are all those industries "anti-creator" too? And while free-to-play may not be anti-creator, it incentivizes the worst aspects of creation: stagnation, repetition, pandering, conditioning, etc. And while maybe that makes it easier to run a business, it looks anti-art to me. Which is to say: in saying it enables developers to provide a lifestyle hobby for their players, it looks more to me like it's going to kill the hobby for everyone.