9 ms·
Breakfast, lunch and dinner: Have we always eaten them?
- cmdswitch 14y agoAir: Have we always breathed it? News at 11.
- mlchild 14y agoConsidering that the answer to the article's question is essentially "no," this is a weak putdown.
- anonymous 14y agoThat's the same answer as "have we always breathed air?" - no. For a long time our ancestor breathed water. Going even further back, we had neither gills nor lungs and didn't breathe at all.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoOne of the things that has always fascinated me is how much of our culture is a modern affectation rather than being some deep pattern of human behavior. You don't even have to go back a few hundred years; there are things Americans perceive as having been that way forever that did not exist at the beginning of the 20th century. Most of our eating and sleeping habits have been shaped by the Industrial Revolution. Regarding the article, I've experimented with a lot of different eating schedules and structures over the years, largely out of idle curiosity to see if it makes a difference. To be perfectly honest, I can't eat three meals a day. My typical day is eating something very light in the late morning, though I skip it a few days a week, and an early-ish dinner. I've kind of arrived there randomly but it suits me. I don't have time in the middle of the day for a Roman-style big lunch even if I wanted to have one. A big difference between historical eating patterns and now was the lack of massive quantities of refined carbohydrates and sugars in the diet a couple centuries ago. The insulin response to many foods common in modern diets encourages repeated meals. The fact that my diet is typically quite low in refined carbohydrates probably makes it easier for me to eat only one significant meal per day.
- terhechte 14y agoDouglas Adams subsumed it pretty well in the Salmon of Doubt: “I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things.”
- pretoriusB 14y ago>there are things Americans perceive as having been that way forever that did not exist at the beginning of the 20th century. For example, 8 and 10 year old kids used to play free in the streets and come back at home late at night, even in urban areas. Or, there weren't movies aimed at teenagers and kids (and never-grown-up geeks) like now, until the eighties. All movies were made for everybody. Two tidbits of freedom-past I learned from a very good article: http://www.austinchronicle.com/columns/2003-08-22/174046/ http://www.austinchronicle.com/columns/2003-08-22/174046/
- stephengillie 14y agoMy mother told me about getting the first TV in their neighborhood in the 1950s -- people were standing on their porch, staring in, trying to figure out what the hell the bright loud box was. Before that, they got their news from the movies and papers. Some newsreels went on until the 1970s, as seen in MASH. She also told me about the government buying her best friend's house (and everyone else's house around there) to demolish them and put I-5 through the city. Before then, the only way from city to city were highways like Route 66, which wound through cities like residential streets. I'm not sure how our present libertarian population would feel about governments applying eminent domain over thousands of miles of perfectly good farmland and housing.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoAt least as far back as we have data (1909) the diet in the US was primarily carbs, in proportions considerably greater than today. https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnpp.usda.gov%2Fpublications%2Ffoodsupply%2Ffoodsupply1909-2004report.pdf https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnpp.usd... The vast majority of humanity has, historically, eaten a diet comprised primarily of grain, potato and yam. Areas which supported such crops could support a lot of humans, while grazing areas had far lower populations. It's historical nonsense to claim that a diet comprised primarily of refined carbs is some modern invention.
- ok_craig 14y agoThis reminds me of a similar BBC article, The myth of the eight-hour sleep. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-16964783 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-16964783
- ghshephard 14y agoGeneral McChrystal, was a big proponent of a single meal a day. http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2009/09/25/mcchrystal-s-war.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2009/09/25/mcchrystal-...
- fingerprinter 14y agoI've seen more and more research on the benefits of fasting and skipping breakfast. I've actually not eaten breakfast in over 3 years and I have to say, I actually prefer not eating it. It took some time to adapt, but once I did, I actually felt better. I've found it easier to maintain my weight, actually put on muscle (combined with other dietary changes needed to add muscle) and also increased my concentration and focus. What do I do? I have a couple big glasses of water, a cup of coffee or two with heavy cream or butter and that is it until lunch. If I'm not trying to put on muscle I generally eat very low carb and that further gives me more focus and concentration. Basically, my n=1 experience is quite good and I recommend others experiment with it.
- oakenshield 14y agoWhat you're speaking about seems similar to what most people on the Leangains [1] diet follow. In looking around for healthy diet + exercise patterns for predominantly sedentary lifestyles (such as the HN crowd), there seem to be two main styles: (1) eat 6 small meals a day spaced out over your waking period, and (2) eat only 8 hours a day, and fast for 16, a form of intermittent fasting (IF) as is recommended by Leangains. Having tried both, I find that IF is vastly easier to adhere to, and more importantly, much easier to maintain your weight loss (or muscle gain) goals as you have only so much time in a day to stuff yourself. In both schemes however, most of your calories are supposed to come post exercise. In my case, this is the traditional "dinner" time, but like the article says, for pre-electricity ages, this meal may very well have been around noon. [1] http://examine.com/leangains-faq/#summary2 http://examine.com/leangains-faq/#summary2
- CerealPie 14y agoFor those interested in leangains, I can't recommend Andy's site [1] enough. Lots of useful and easy to folloew information there. Also, I created a simple macro calculator for leangains[2] just last week. It is not finished yet, but at least for me it is useable. [1] http://rippedbody.jp/ http://rippedbody.jp/ [2] http://sareyko.net/leancalc/ http://sareyko.net/leancalc/
- Swizec 14y ago
- oboizt 14y agoAfter seeing a friend do the one-meal-a-day routine, I'm pretty convinced to try it out myself. He's very healthy, active and alert. He gets sufficient calories and nutrition and he can pretty much eat whatever he wants (within reason) for his one meal. I've heard him explain several times about how he feels his brain actually functions better this way when his body isn't trying to constantly digest food all day long.
- enqk 14y agoWell my farmer grand father, born in Europe in 1914 would eat four meals. First a light breakfast very early, with a soup. Then around 10 a meat-based light meal after some hard work. Then at 13 lunch, and finally a dinner.
- huffman 14y agowhen was the dinner?
- shimon_e 14y agoJews have codified three meals a day as part of the celebration of religious days (e.g. the sabbath) since the beginning of their religion. Going to the extreme of staying someone who does not prepare for three meals has no portion in the afterlife. At the same time they were critical of gluttony. It amazes me how people can selectively present facts to appear intelligent. There was more to the ancient world than just the Romans and Greeks. So even if they didn't eat 3 meals a day I'm pretty sure there were plenty of ancient civilisations that did.
- lutze 14y agoCalm down there Hulkomania, this article is very clearly written from the perspective of the British Isles, and the Romans were kinda a big deal there. Before you start implying people are trying to "seem clever", maybe check that your indignation hasn't blinded you to the patently bloody obvious.
- jgrahamc 14y agoSure, but (a) the Romans were quite a big deal to the Jews as "Judea" was part of the Roman Empire and (b) it's reasonable of the parent to bring up the Jews because it's an interesting counterpoint to using the Romans as representatives of what people did back then. The original article could have mentioned this but does not.
- lutze 14y agoYou're missing the point. This article is about BRITONS, i.e. the inhabitants of the British Isles. It's not using Romans as representatives of what PEOPLE did back then, it's using Romans as representatives of what BRITONS did back then. Historically the Romans had a huge cultural impact on Britain... whereas ancient Jews had none. So why then should this article randomly mention ancient Jewish traditions? You're complaining about a complete non-issue.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoWell hold on. We have seudah shlishit, I thought, precisely because on days other than Shabbat people ate only two meals.