5 ms·
'"I think Wikipedia is great," he said when wrapping up his talk, and he wants to see it succeed, but he has trouble seeing how that can happen as the project c
by scott_s 18y ago
'"I think Wikipedia is great," he said when wrapping up his talk, and he wants to see it succeed, but he has trouble seeing how that can happen as the project continues to grow.'
If someone had explained Wikipedia to you ten years ago, would you have thought it had a chance? I'll be honest, I doubt I would have.
I think of the success of Wikipedia as similar to evolution. We're just not good at grasping the scale at which either work, so our intuition betrays us.
- jrockway 18y ago> would you have thought it had a chance? Sure... we had open source projects in 1999, too. Ten years is not that long ago.
- scott_s 18y agoWikipedia follows a different model than all open source software projects. Even if there are a large number of contributors in an open source software project, there are still a disproportionately small number of arbiters. Any random person can submit a patch, but there's no guarantee it will get in. The larger the project, the less likely it will. Wikipedia is everyone can be a contributor, and everyone can be an arbiter.
- jrockway 18y ago> Wikipedia is everyone can be a contributor, and everyone can be an arbiter. Open source is no different. Click the "fork" button on Github, and the project is now yours. > Even if there are a large number of contributors in an open source software project, there are still a disproportionately small number of arbiters. Any random person can submit a patch, but there's no guarantee it will get in. > The larger the project, the less likely it will. This is not really true. Send a patch to any open source project, and it will probably get in if it needs to be in. (Sure patches get rejected -- not everything needs to be "core", the code might not work, it might not be useful, etc., etc. But if you send a useful patch, it will get in regardless of how big or how small the project is.) Anyway, Wikipedia really has the same model, it just looks different. You can edit anything, and the edit sticks immediately. But eventually an arbiter will review your edit, and if it's bad, it will be reverted. (There are "WikiProjects" dedicated to making sure every edit in their project gets looked at.) Bad edits rarely slip by completely undetected, and if they do, that's life. Bad patches are committed to open source projects. Paper books have errata. I am not sure why Wikipedia needs to be held to some higher standard than any other form of media ever.
- scott_s 18y agoOpen source is different because forking a project doesn't fork the users of the original. There's a central repository for Wikipedia. The model is fundamentally different. It's the ecosystem around that model that makes it work.