5 ms·

This is an amazing test and it's kinda' funny how terrible gpt-2-image is. I'd take "plagiarized" images (e.g. Google search & copy-paste) any day over how awfu

by dvt 6mo ago

This is an amazing test and it's kinda' funny how terrible gpt-2-image is. I'd take "plagiarized" images (e.g. Google search & copy-paste) any day over how awful the OpenAI result is. Doesn't even seem like they have a sanity checker/post-processing "did I follow the instructions correctly?" step, because the digit-style constraint violation should be easily caught. It's also expensive as shit to just get an image that's essentially unusable.

anshumankmr 6mo ago
that is interesting cause I feel gpt-image-1 did have that feature. (source: https://chatgpt.com/share/69e83569-b334-8320-9fbf-01404d18dfa5 https://chatgpt.com/share/69e83569-b334-8320-9fbf-01404d18df...)
- weird-eye-issue 6mo ago
  You are comparing ChatGPT to a raw image model. These are two completely different things. ChatGPT takes your input, modifies the prompt and then passes it to the image model and then will maybe read the image and provide output. The image model like through the API just takes the prompt verbatim and generates an image.
  - minimaxir 6mo ago
    Nano Banana Pro and ChatGPT Images 2.0 also tweak the prompt because they can think.
    - weird-eye-issue 6mo ago
      Yes exactly, "ChatGPT Images 2.0" is in ChatGPT. That is not a model.
hyperadvanced 6mo ago
I wouldn’t say it’s terrible. I wouldn’t say it’s a huge step forward in terms of quality compared to what I’ve seen before from AI
the_arun 6mo ago
This is from Gemini - https://lens.usercontent.google.com/banana?agsi=CmdnbG9iYWw6OjAwMDA1NWNmZWM3MDAyNmQ6MDAwMDAwZWI6MToxZTEyNDUzMjI1NWYwOTYzOjAwMDA1NWNmZWM3MDAyNmQ6MDAwMDAyOGNiN2QwMzM2ODowMDA2NTAwM2EzYWQyYWFmEAIYAQ== https://lens.usercontent.google.com/banana?agsi=CmdnbG9iYWw6...
- fblp 6mo ago
  Did it correctly follow the instructions? Don't know my pokemon well enough.
  - minimaxir 6mo ago
    Essentially yes (bottom got distorted), but Gemini uses Nano Banana Pro or Nano Banana 2 so it's not a surprising result. The image I linked uses the raw API.
    - thih9 6mo ago
      Note that the styles are different; there are two digit images rendered in color. Color charcoal drawings do exist, but it’s not what’s usually meant by “charcoal drawing”.
  - podgietaru 6mo ago
    Plusul and Minun sit next to each other in the Pokedex, 311 and 312. There's two 307s.
  - tsukurimashou 6mo ago
    > Create a 8x8 contiguous grid It failed at the very first instruction

by dvt 6mo ago

anshumankmr 6mo ago

that is interesting cause I feel gpt-image-1 did have that feature. (source: https://chatgpt.com/share/69e83569-b334-8320-9fbf-01404d18dfa5 https://chatgpt.com/share/69e83569-b334-8320-9fbf-01404d18df...)

weird-eye-issue 6mo ago
You are comparing ChatGPT to a raw image model. These are two completely different things. ChatGPT takes your input, modifies the prompt and then passes it to the image model and then will maybe read the image and provide output. The image model like through the API just takes the prompt verbatim and generates an image.
- minimaxir 6mo ago
  Nano Banana Pro and ChatGPT Images 2.0 also tweak the prompt because they can think.
  - weird-eye-issue 6mo ago
    Yes exactly, "ChatGPT Images 2.0" is in ChatGPT. That is not a model.

hyperadvanced 6mo ago

I wouldn’t say it’s terrible. I wouldn’t say it’s a huge step forward in terms of quality compared to what I’ve seen before from AI

the_arun 6mo ago

This is from Gemini - https://lens.usercontent.google.com/banana?agsi=CmdnbG9iYWw6OjAwMDA1NWNmZWM3MDAyNmQ6MDAwMDAwZWI6MToxZTEyNDUzMjI1NWYwOTYzOjAwMDA1NWNmZWM3MDAyNmQ6MDAwMDAyOGNiN2QwMzM2ODowMDA2NTAwM2EzYWQyYWFmEAIYAQ== https://lens.usercontent.google.com/banana?agsi=CmdnbG9iYWw6...

fblp 6mo ago
Did it correctly follow the instructions? Don't know my pokemon well enough.
- minimaxir 6mo ago
  Essentially yes (bottom got distorted), but Gemini uses Nano Banana Pro or Nano Banana 2 so it's not a surprising result. The image I linked uses the raw API.
  - thih9 6mo ago
    Note that the styles are different; there are two digit images rendered in color. Color charcoal drawings do exist, but it’s not what’s usually meant by “charcoal drawing”.
- podgietaru 6mo ago
  Plusul and Minun sit next to each other in the Pokedex, 311 and 312. There's two 307s.
- tsukurimashou 6mo ago
  > Create a 8x8 contiguous grid It failed at the very first instruction