3 ms·
"When you embrace Darwin, you're not embracing science, you're embracing fascism." Bollocks. I embrace Einstein, does that make me a Jew? You quote from "No
by jgrahamc 18y ago
"When you embrace Darwin, you're not embracing science, you're embracing fascism."
Bollocks. I embrace Einstein, does that make me a Jew?
You quote from "No Contest", an interesting book, but not a book about evolution. You'll also recall from that book that the author quotes Stephen Jay Gould saying that natural selection doesn't imply cooperation or competition a priori. So I think your supporting quotes don't add much to the argument.
And, so what if animals have evolved to cooperate with each other? If that's the way natural selection has taken things then so be it. Doesn't take away from natural selection as the mechanism.
So, the core of your argument is "Darwin basically said that species compete for scarce resources, and the organisms that are the best at competing win. This is entirely wrong."
Perhaps quoting Darwin is the solution: "As many more individuals of each species are born than can possibly survive; and as, consequently, there is a frequently recurring struggle for existence, it follows that any being, if it vary however slightly in any manner profitable to itself, under the complex and sometimes varying conditions of life, will have a better chance of surviving, and thus be naturally selected. From the strong principle of inheritance, any selected variety will tend to propagate its new and modified form"
"Owing to this struggle for life, any variation, however slight and from whatever cause proceeding, if it be in any degree profitable to an individual of any species, in its infinitely complex relations to other organic beings and to external nature, will tend to the preservation of that individual, and will generally be inherited by its offspring.... I have called this principle, by which each slight variation, if useful, is preserved, by the term of Natural Selection, in order to mark its relation to man's power of selection"
My reading of that is that Darwin is saying that individuals compete to survive and they compete with other 'organic beings' and nature in general. And specifically he is saying any variation that is profitable to the individual. Doesn't exclude cooperation with others. He says that any variation that is beneficial will make that individual survive and that it will be passed on.
I read Darwin's struggle as a metaphor. For example, if I am born with a stronger immune system than those around me I may be more likely to survive an epidemic and thus I am more successful in the 'struggle' for life. In no way did I actively compete against my fellow humans.
Similarly, if I am born with better vision than my fellow humans I may survive longer because I am a better hunter (or see the bear that wants to eat me before others do). Did I struggle against my fellow human? No.
- Alex3917 18y agoI don't think there is any a priori bias toward either competition or cooperation, I just think that in practice organisms that are better at cooperating tend to be more plentiful than organisms that specialize in competing. Because the trophic levels form a pyramid of sorts, competing really only makes sense as the dominant strategy in the top layer or two where usable resources really are extremely scarce. But 99% of organisms don't fall into that category. "In no way did I actively compete against my fellow humans." Competition just means that in order for one person to win, another person has to lose. In the case of your immune system example, I would agree that you winning doesn't cause anyone else to lose. But in Darwin's words, "As many more individuals of each species are born than can possibly survive; and as, consequently, there is a frequently recurring struggle for existence." This to me does imply that for one person to win, someone else has to lose, even if there isn't any direct fight. When in reality, for most organisms, there are virtually unlimited resources and the best way to survive is to help everyone else survive as well. There are times when resources are scarce and competition becomes essential, but those times are the exception, and not the rule as Darwin's quote seems to imply.
- electromagnetic 18y agoDarwin's theories were based upon observation, the are no rules in it. Darwin's work actually describes, contrary to what people assume, is that the fittest species survives. Fittest doesn't mean strongest or healthiest, it in fact means its ability to adapt to the environment around it. Homo Sapiens as a species have adapted extremely well, we've moved from the Savanna and each new sub-species has spread further and further. In fact we went from living in a small region of Africa to spanning from the Arctic to Antarctic and from the most westerly point to the most easterly point on the map. In fact, humans are currently the only species to ever expand off the surface of the planet. Our survivability went from bipedal primates to astronauts, currently as a species we have the potential to survive possibly anything except a gamma-ray burst aimed in our direction. Warm blooded creatures won out over cold blooded creatures, despite wasting something like 32 times the energy. Why did this happen? Well aside from the apex predators, warm blooded creatures have decimated cold blooded creatures because we always have a constant supply of energy. Right now I can get up and go for a run, but then look at Crocodiles, they only have a range of a few feet out of their territory before they're not safe anymore. The Nile Crocodile is an awesome and fearful predator, but like all its cousins it only survives in one niche. They eat everything including all the big cats and baboons. However, even full adult Nile Crocodiles are easy prey once they're on land and even in water a troop of hungry baboons can get themselves some juicy crocodile by luring it onto land. My point is, the Nile Crocodile wins nearly every time in its territory, but it'll never win outside its territory. So what happens when the environment changes? Well migratory animals appear to shift their behaviors accordingly. The only hope for the Crocodiles is that it doesn't get too hot or too cold too fast, because unless the Crocs can spread through expansion they'll go extinct. When it comes down to individuals there's lots of things that contribute to whether or not you'll 'survive' and most are down to the individuals genetics. It doesn't matter if a person is strong or weak if they're physically incapable of procreation through infertility or any other means. Reproduction is downright genocide, the sperm are dumped into a hostile environment that's designed to kill them so only the strongest actually manage to get to the egg, then it takes several sperms to die before a single sperm can implant the egg (ironically the first to get there doesn't necessarily win) and then once the fetus is developing, the mothers immune system is on a war path to destroy it. If the child survives all that, then it has a good chance of reaching maturity and passing on its own genes. Simply saying that competition means one wins and one loses is absurd because individuals don't matter, it's the species as a whole and thats what Darwin was talking about. He didn't see a fist fight and say, I know I'm going to write the greatest thesis ever! No he traveled around the world and saw how wide spread and diverse species were and then he wrote the greatest thesis ever after seeing multiple sub-species spread throughout huge swathes of the earth. Cooperation between species is merely a subclass of competition in evolutionary terms. It usually occurs in two species of prey where they can share their abilities and as a pair they can compete and win against a predator. You seem to be thinking of the Clownfish/Anemone symbiosis. It's true that both benefit from this, however they're both competing for independent goals. The Clownfish helps prevent the Anemone from dying by cleaning it of undigested food, which can grow bacteria and kill the Anemone and in this manner the Anemone wins in competition against the bacteria/death. On the other hand the Clownfish is protected from predators by hiding in the anemone, which in turn means it beats its competition from any number of predators. This symbiosis doesn't thrive because cooperation is good, it thrives because the pair compete efficiently as a pair. However, if the symbiosis breaks down they both die.