3 ms·
They, with extensive legal resources, go after individuals, with next to no legal resources, threatening massive lawsuits for a dozen or so songs, or you can pa
by jlgreco 14y ago
They, with extensive legal resources, go after individuals, with next to no legal resources, threatening massive lawsuits for a dozen or so songs, or you can pay them several thousand dollars, "for many many songs", to make them go away.
If you don't see the problem there by yourself, I don't think I can help you. It should be self-evident.
Following the letter of the law does not absolve you from ethical wrongdoing.
- tptacek 14y agoIt is hard to see how this comment wouldn't be arguing that the RIAA should, if their concerns are bona fide, be suing for millions of dollars instead of single-digit thousands. All the empirical evidence available to you suggests that when the RIAA takes someone to court who refuses to settle, they are likely to be awarded 5- and 6- figure judgements. Set against that fact, it is very hard to argue that they are being malicious when they offer a $5000 settlement. If you are mugged in the city of Chicago, or if your lawnmower is stolen from your garage, or your house broken into, the chances are very good that the party who harmed you has far fewer resources than you do; in fact, your economic relationship to your assailant is likely to be comparably dramatic to the relationship between the RIAA and a defendant (it is probably more likely that you could start a multimillion dollar business this year than that a mugger will find a stable, successful career ever). And yet our system of law does not then say, "you are so much better off than the person who stole from your house, you should just shake it off". That's because the resources at your disposal do not alter your fundamental rights.
- jlgreco 14y agoIf they are interested in operating ethically (I am not suggesting they are doing anything illegal or even illogical) any proposed settlement should be for what they are actually realistically going to sue for. Offering a settlement for thousands of books, when in reality the settlement is to avoid only a lawsuit for dozens of books, and then turning around and saying how reasonable they are being, just reeks of shit. Perfectly legal I am sure, perfectly logical, a sound business decision... ...but let's just say it reminds me why I hate lawyers. That the only rational decision a defendant/potential-defendant can make in this situation is not avoid at all costs a trial just drives home to me that any loyalty I feel towards the system is misplaced... but that is a separate issue.
- tzs 14y agoJammie Thomas-Rasset was sharing 1700 songs, and they asked her for $5000. What do you think would be the ethical amount for them to ask for that many songs?
- jlgreco 14y agoI think any ethical settlement offer should be for the number of songs that they are hypothetically willing to sue for.
- tptacek 14y agoBaffling; your ethical concern is that they did not sue her for more money. "If they were really serious, and not just using the legal system to bully people", you seem to suggest, "they'd set out to ruin her completely and give no quarter until they actually accomplished that".
- jlgreco 14y ago"Pay a settlement of thousands of dollars, or get sued for dozens of songs", is, as far as I am concerned, demanding a lot of money for few songs. My ethical concern is that they were deliberately setting out to place people in a situation where the only rational decision is to go with "give us thousands of dollars and do not mount a defense of yourself over a few songs.". I know, obviously, that you disagree with what I am saying; I am sure I am unable to change that. If you want to continue to pretend not to understand... then knock yourself out. I think what I am saying is pretty simple, however flawed you may find it.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm sorry; I literally just don't understand the argument here. If I set your house on fire, incurring $300,000 in damages, and then offer to settle with you for $5,000, your only rational decision is to accept that settlement offer. Am I being unethical if I do that? If I owned 200 houses around the country, and you burned one down out of carelessness and negligence but without any malicious intent, would it still be unethical for me to offer you the $5,000 settlement?