3 ms·
This question is making me really wonder how anything useful ever gets done on StackOverflow: every time I look back at it, there is some new answer with 50+ up
by saurik 14y ago
This question is making me really wonder how anything useful ever gets done on StackOverflow: every time I look back at it, there is some new answer with 50+ upvotes that is just as wrong as every other answer. Are people seriously upvoting things because they "sound right"? There also tend to be a bunch of comments from people with rampant speculation as to why various behaviors occur, without having even taken the time to just test whether the things they are talking about actually happen on real devices, or continue to happen if you mess with the device some between tests (such as rotating it).
- smackfu 14y agoObviously stuff that gets linked externally all over the place has different kind of answers and voting than your average SO question. Seems silly to judge the whole site on it.
- ygra 14y agoThe average question is probably either one of the following anyway: • How can I parse a bit of information from a HTML page? [regex] [php] • Why does the compiler complain here? [c#] • Regex question [regex] • How to add two numbers in jQuery? [jquery] [html] • What does this operator do? [java] The long tail of not-very-highly voted questions is mostly beginner questions about a particular language or environment. As for me, it gets tiring explaining exactly the same thing in slight variations (adapted to the problem) three times a day.
- smackfu 14y agoAnd actual hard questions that can't be answered by Googling just sit there with no answers. And then I win the Tumbleweed badge: http://stackoverflow.com/badges/63/tumbleweed http://stackoverflow.com/badges/63/tumbleweed That kind of thing is the problem with SO, not the ones with 5k views and hundreds of votes.
- ygra 14y agoYep, a few times I had an actually hard problem and the question got maybe 15 views, no answer and just sat there dying. However, that's probably the sort of question you won't get answered in any forum or similar. SO does very well for the trivial and semi-complicated questions – the kind where there are enough developers to have encountered the problem already to answer. And it does so in a way that appears quite high in Google's results and often comes straight to the point (i.e. the answer) – they set out to become better than expert-sex-change which hides the answer below a plethora of ads and it's only visible if you come from Google/Bing. I'd say SO's dominance here is for the better. That's not to say there isn't anything left to improve, though :-). For trivial questions there are usually a hundred duplicates, at least one of which is often the official documentation.
- dpark 14y agoMost questions on SO fit into one of three buckets: 1. Trivial aka Dozens of answers aka Fastest gun in the west 2. Hard aka Unanswered 3. Interesting aka Closed
- recursive 14y agoThat says more about HN, or other referring sites, than it does about Stack Overflow. The problem you mention afflicts questions with incoming links much more often.